8 ms·
Every time this comes up I feel obligated to add the following: 1) Samsung televisions spy on your mercilessly. They collect everything they can, including scr
by jiggawatts 4y ago
Every time this comes up I feel obligated to add the following:
1) Samsung televisions spy on your mercilessly. They collect everything they can, including screenshots at regular intervals and send them back to Samsung so that they can sell this to "partners". They are not a FAANG and don't have anywhere near their level of security expertise. I have second-hand but reliable information about their security approach, and "laughable" doesn't begin to describe it. Assume that whatever you watch on a Samsung TV is being relayed to multiple state-level spy agencies.
Ref: https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/tv-ad-retargeting/ https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/tv-...
2) Even if you buy a flagship Samsung television for five figures, it's virtually guaranteed that within a year or two they will release an update the slows it down to molasses. These things have controller boards with miniscule amounts of RAM in them, and they use the same firmware across all models. When a new model with more RAM is released, they add more features, causing all older models that self update to start swapping to the pagefile. I've seen several Samsung televisions across several model years and price points get slowed down until response times are up to 2 seconds for most actions. This is "unusable garbage" quality, for crazy money.
NEVER buy a Samsung television, ever. You're treated as the product, not the customer, despite paying them a lot of money.
PS: This isn't even the only display calibration cheating that they do! Practically all Samsung models use a "shop mode" that cranks up brightness to 11 and oversaturates the colours. Even in "normal" mode Samsung televisions have forced "enhancements" that can't be turned off. There is no "calibrated mode", because it would look like trash on these over-priced televisions.
- interpol_p 4y agoNever allow a TV or monitor to connect to your Wi-Fi network and you'll be able to avoid these two issues
- jiggawatts 4y agoWell yes, but then you're basically buying an expensive monitor and will need a second device to be the "smarts". I personally use an Apple TV for this, but in general this can be frustrating for users that just want their Smart TV to work without spying on them or implementing centrally triggered scheduled obsolescence. This is a bit like saying you should "never" turn on your new car's engine and should immediately swap it out for a third-party one, because every knows Manufacturer X leaves ticking time bombs in their engines. This is why consumer protection agencies are created by governments!
- interpol_p 4y agoExactly. I purchase an Apple TV for each screen in the house, whether that screen is dumb or smart. Actually, I have three screens and two Apple TVs, so for movie nights I move one Apple TV over to the projector so we can watch a movie there (Apple TVs are expensive!) I also had a Fire Stick and a Roku but refused to keep using them after reading their privacy policies (their UIs are also complete and utter trash, they are so terrible compared to Apple TV) I think the advice to never allow a screen to connect to Wi-Fi is reasonable, and I tell my family the same. In the past I have give them old Apple TVs or help them set one up to ensure that they are not allowing spyware on their network Agreed that this needs to be handled by government, as the level of data abuse by these companies is unacceptable
- dataflow 4y ago> This is why consumer protection agencies are created by governments! Enjoy them while they last (see Part III): https://www.natlawreview.com/article/fifth-circuit-decision-threatens-to-upend-sec-s-use-administrative-proceedings https://www.natlawreview.com/article/fifth-circuit-decision-...
- cesarb 4y ago> Well yes, but then you're basically buying an expensive monitor and will need a second device to be the "smarts". If all you want is a TV (as in, connecting to an antenna and tuning to over-the-air channels), you don't need any "smarts". (The main difference between a TV and a monitor is that a TV has a tuner, while a monitor doesn't.)
- oneoff786 4y agoI find this argument weird. Most people don’t want smart TVs. Dedicated smart devices are just better. Even non techies will probably feel this way because the TVs suck and the remote control interface is clunky and confusing. There’s simply no option to buy a dumb tv that isn’t something weird like a monitor or digital signage. Imo nothing beats a laptop with a wireless mouse and keyboard. So much better than a shitty remote. Browsers and Google are familiar. Can also do games. Can access whatever sites you want or things the smart device wouldn’t approve of. All of these devices like Apple TV and fire sticks seem pretty dumb to me.
- throwmeaway1212 4y agoHDMI can carry ethernet, so not connecting to wifi isn't a 100% fix.
- buildbot 4y agoAt least with an Apple TV and a Samsung 900r, it is unable to network between the two.
- throwaway742 4y agoGotta make a HDMI firewall.
- stormbrew 4y agoIt's pretty unlikely that you'll have ethernet over hdmi happening unless you go way out of your way to have it. It's not really something that just happens spontaneously, you need your devices to have it and the cable to support it. I think eARC canibalized the channels it used too?
- colejohnson66 4y agoEthernet over HDMI is basically dead. Just because the standard supports it doesn’t mean the devices do.
- buildbot 4y agoThey could connect to nearby open wifi if they really wanted :/
- Geonode 4y agoEvery thread dozens of people say, "just don't connect!" They can connect to open networks such as Amazon sidewalk and other deliberate corporate IoT sabotage, and soon I'm sure we'll see the first televisions that require connection to even pass a signal from the HDMI port. The best thing to do is not support this immoral garbage through apathy or ignorance.
- deadbunny 4y agoAnd every thread says they can connect to open WiFi without providing any proof that they do. It would be trivial to test and prove but no-one ever does. I'm not saying they wouldn't do it but I'd prefer some proof before judging them (without having to shell out to be the guinea pig).
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoWhat would be the proper way to test this? Wireless networking is something I usually avoid in a technical capacity, but this seems like something worth messing around with (and reporting back on).
- livueta 4y agoShould be a fairly straightforward bit of airodump. Even if you don't capture the handshake, you can cross-reference the macs of stations associated with the AP of interest against the mac of your device. If the mac is randomized to a sufficient degree that you can't cross-reference it I guess you'd need to capture the association, but that shouldn't be a problem if you can turn the tv off/on and it does the thing consistently.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoThank you kindly, that’s exactly the start I needed. Cheers
- deadbunny 4y agoEven easier than that, set up an open WiFi network, see if the TV connects to it. Super easy for anyone that claims TVs are doing this to do.
- mgraczyk 4y agoI have a QN90A, the ads are annoying but it's fine and it's a great TV overall. It's basically just a tiny banner ad at the bottom right of the home screen. Personally I take much bigger risks day to day by doing things like biking to work, so I'm okay with the risk of my TV sending data back to advertisers. BTW, I'm pretty sure the only Samsung TVs that are five figures are the 98" beasts. My 75" QN90A was $1600, and the middle tier models are much cheaper and look great.
- 4oh9do 4y ago> the ads are annoying but it's fine This doesn't parse. It's like saying 'this apple is rotten but it's fine'. If the apple is rotten, then it is not fine. If the television has annoying ads, then it is not fine.
- mgraczyk 4y agoThis is a common way of speaking in American English. For example "Hey earlier today you fell down, how's your elbow feeling?" "Not too bad, it's annoying but it's fine"
- comprev 4y agoDouble negatives are very much a British English thing and are commonly used in every day language.
- richrichardsson 4y agoI think you would have avoided all the downvotes with, "Double negatives are very much an English language thing and are commonly used in every day language", since American and British English both involve double negatives in colloquial usage.
- comprev 4y agoI only know a handful of Americans and we often talk about the differences in our language. Even had an Australian join the conversation once too and it was a very interesting discussion. The use of double negatives stood out as something more commonly used in British English however I accept it was a very small sample size!
- pabs3 4y agoIf Software Freedom Conservancy win their lawsuit against Vizio for GPL violations in their TVs, you will probably be able to install open source Linux distros with Kodi on any Vizio TV and soon afterwards lots of other smart TV vendors will be similar. Allowing the vendor operating system to remain on the device after you purchase it basically means spyware these days. https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html
- oynqr 4y agoHaving the kernel source won't really help with a locked bootloader.
- pabs3 4y agoThats why the GPL requires the ability to install as well: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2021/mar/25/install-gplv2/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2021/mar/25/install-gplv2/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2021/jul/23/tivoization-and-the-gpl-right-to-install/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2021/jul/23/tivoization-and-t... https://events19.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Safely-Copylefted-Cars-Reexamining-GPLv3-Installation-Information-Requirements-ALS-Bradley-Kuhn-Behan-Webster-1.pdf https://events19.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017...
- oynqr 4y agoYeah, try to argue in front of a court that this somehow covers private signing keys.
- pabs3 4y agoI don't think the GPL covers signing keys, just some mechanism for installation. Allowing addition of additional signing keys is a good way to do it, just like UEFI Secure Boot does things. There are also plenty of phone vendors who allow bootloader unlock after wiping the device DRM/etc keys too.
- 4y ago
- ofTheFountain 4y agoI have one of the earlier mid range 4k Samsungs. About two years in they gave it an update that added a Lote of bloatware, some of their own TV streaming channels full of Samsung ads. And for a bit I had Adguard home on my router and Samsung endpoints where the biggest thing blocked by far, and it was the only Samsung device in he house. Now I have the internet disabled on it and just use an Xbox for smart stuff, will probably get an Apple TV next time they upgrade it.
- dawnerd 4y agoThe notification ads are what made me swear them off. I don’t want GameFly ad notifications popping up when I’m watching a movie.
- 2000UltraDeluxe 4y agoI use an Xbox aswell, since my TV has an open security hole that the manufacturer refuses to patch, and because it sends unspecified data and fetches updates over an unencrypted connection. Mind you, the Xbox does just as much snooping, but at least the Xbox fetches updates over encrypted channels and doesn't let anyone on the same network have root access to the TV's linux installation.
- ofTheFountain 4y agoTrue with the Xbox, bat at least imo MS is slitty more trustworthy with my data than Samsung. The tv was doing more network requests than the xbox and a few Apple devices combined.
- 4oh9do 4y ago> They are not a FAANG and don't have anywhere near their level of security expertise. What a weird thing to say. Are you suggesting that it's fine that FAANG companies also spy on you mercilessly, because their security is ostensibly better?
- nvr219 4y agoI mean if SOMEBODY is going to spy on me I'd rather they have better security
- pdpi 4y agoWhen Google collects data about me, I’m relatively certain what I’d going to happen to that data — it gets folded into a bazillion models and is used to sell me shit. When Samsung collects data about me, I have absolutely no clue what happens next with that data. It’s not necessarily better or worse, but it’s a very different bit of privacy calculus you need to work through.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoYou may have forgotten the part where it's directly fed to the NSA. PRISM existed and still exists, and there is ongoing collaboration between every large tech company and the NSA.
- arthurfm 4y ago> I have second-hand but reliable information about their security approach, and "laughable" doesn't begin to describe it. Back in 2017 a security researcher found 40 zero-day vulnerabilities in Samsung's Tizen OS. [1][2] [1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/04/samsungs-tizen-is-riddled-with-security-flaws-amateurishly-written/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/04/samsungs-tizen-is-ri... [2] https://www.vice.com/en/article/xy9p7n/samsung-tizen-operating-system-bugs-vulnerabilities https://www.vice.com/en/article/xy9p7n/samsung-tizen-operati...
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> They are not a FAANG [...] Assume that whatever you watch on a Samsung TV is being relayed to multiple state-level spy agencies. You don't feel the same about FAANG? And by state-level spy agencies you mean government spy agencies, or something else?
- deanc 4y agoYou can block 99% of this by using the "Samsung" list with nextdns on your TV. Few other hosts in this thread [1] [1] https://gist.github.com/peteryates/b44b70d19ccd52f62d66cdd4bcef1e52 https://gist.github.com/peteryates/b44b70d19ccd52f62d66cdd4b...
- Sophistifunk 4y agoNetwork administration skills are not an acceptable pre-requisite for a consumer product like a TV.
- deanc 4y agoI'm not justifying it in any way - but changing DNS is trivial - something well within the capabilities of all the readers here.
- alexb_ 4y agoYou have absolutely no idea what "trivial" means. https://xkcd.com/2501/ https://xkcd.com/2501/
- deanc 4y agoCan't tell if you're being facetious or not. If a technologist can't change an IP address on a TV's network settings then they're probably in the wrong community.
- bartread 4y agoI think the wider point here is that technologists represent a small portion of Samsung's target market. Most people won't know or care how to change an IP address in the TV's network settings. Whereas I fall into the "I could, but why should I?" category of people who mostly try to buy devices that don't actively spy on me in the first place (doesn't work so well for modern phones or games consoles).
- de6u99er 4y agoWhat about LG WebOS TVs?
- MaxikCZ 4y agoI made myself a promise to convey my sentiment towards LG tvs to anyone asking, so here you go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24662353#24665736 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24662353#24665736
- de6u99er 4y agoThanks ;) I just recently upgraded my LG B8 OLED TV to a C9 model by switching out the main board with one I got from eBay. Now I have 4K@120Hz, HDMI 2.1, and VRR ;)
- dspillett 4y ago> use a "shop mode" that cranks up brightness to 11 and oversaturates the colours Practically every TV does this. It makes them look better in brightly lit shops, and any TV that doesn't will look washed out next to all the ones that do even if they are actually better. Always review display settings when you get a new visual device, even if you buy online (devices are set this way out of the box rather than relying on the showroom making any tweaks, so all purchase methods are affected).
- consp 4y agoSamsung's approach to security is writing a memory mapper for the camera app which can map any memory region to userspace and is by default world accessible. I'm not expecting anything.
- jahnu 4y agoDoes anyone know if they do this on TVs sold in the EU?
- jiggawatts 4y agoThey do this in every country.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- extrememacaroni 4y agowhy, you’d just go and throw your money at them if they didn’t?
- potamic 4y ago> They collect everything they can, including screenshots at regular intervals and send them back to Samsung so that they can sell this to "partners" Isn't this a gross violation of privacy and be clearly illegal? I could be playing my home videos with very private content. Add to that copyright violation if they are using screenshots of my content for commercial purposes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jiggawatts 4y agoYes, it’s a gross violation of privacy. People watch porn on their TV, including home-made porn they made themselves. This is being captured and sent back to Samsung. The bigger danger is that you could be watching something on a streaming system that could land you in jail in an authoritarian country. No amount of HTTPS encryption or VPNs will save you if the decoded image is sent raw back to Samsung — where it is not safe and secure!
- potamic 4y agoWhat I don't understand is that how have they not been sued already, in the Western countries at least? Seems it should be a clear cut case.
- p49k 4y agoAre there any efforts to completely replace the firmware of TVs, much like dd-wrt for routers? I would gladly donate money toward such a project.
- Volker_W 4y ago> Even if you buy a flagship Samsung television for five figures, it's virtually guaranteed that within a year or two they will release an update the slows it down to molasses. These things have controller boards with miniscule amounts of RAM in them, and they use the same firmware across all models. When a new model with more RAM is released, they add more features, causing all older models that self update to start swapping to the pagefile. Source / Proof?