3 ms·
> Question: who's making this claim and on what basis? The Solend Team. https://realms.today/dao/7sf3tcWm58vhtkJMwuw2P3T6UBX7UE5VKxPMnXJUZ1Hn/proposal/HuaL6cD
by yieldcrv 4y ago
> Question: who's making this claim and on what basis?
The Solend Team.
https://realms.today/dao/7sf3tcWm58vhtkJMwuw2P3T6UBX7UE5VKxPMnXJUZ1Hn/proposal/HuaL6cDtuNtfnJgvwMnYiZDHVCoLAuDtVFgJD8kYChJ4 https://realms.today/dao/7sf3tcWm58vhtkJMwuw2P3T6UBX7UE5VKxP...
> Question: why is allowing this liquidation the end of the world?
Its not. They believe a function in their own project will cause the underlying Solana blockchain to have some uptime issues, because a similar function has been a culprit in the past, according to them. (Solana has failed to produce blocks periodically, I haven't followed more specifically why) This function will be called autonomously if the price of the collateral in question continues to decline. The rebuttals are:
a) a big cascading liquidation being interrupted by block production issues will just resume as block production resumes. so that's stupid. Solana goes down all the time, if other applications there can't handle that by now that's those application's problem.
b) DEX liquidity isn't all liquidity. So if $170m crashes the price on a DEX, that's just an opportunity for anybody paying attention to buy Solana cheap on the DEX and sell it for more on centralized exchanges like Binance and Coinbase. Its not Solend's problem. It is a completely unnecessary and amateurish "vote".
> what does any of this have to do with Solend? Are they the ones that lent the $108M out, or are they just the middle man?
They're the service being used where people deposit collateral, yes.
- laweijfmvo 4y ago> Its not Solend's problem. Right, that's my confusion. Which is what makes the whole thing smell fishy.
- yieldcrv 4y agoIts amateur hour. Currently governance projects have no bylaws to constrict the nature of a proposal, and they have no continuity between proposals to restrict future proposals, and there is no arbiter, and proposal outcomes mostly have to be coded by the original team so people are trusting them, and there is no agreed upon compensation path for a third party implementation team.