3 ms·
When you're cross-multiplying, you are relying on a basic identity that if ab = ac, then either b = c, or else a = 0. So you want to prove that this multiplyin
by kazinator 4y ago
When you're cross-multiplying, you are relying on a basic identity that if ab = ac, then either b = c, or else a = 0.
So you want to prove that this multiplying both sides is valid?
This is something that is very close to the fundamental axioms of arithmetic (Peano axioms).
To prove it you have to show that the basic rules like associative and distributive property will derive ab = ac from b = c.
x(yz) = (xy)z # associative law
x(y + z) = xy + zy # distributive law
HOw can we use this? If we have
b = c
Suppose we already have a proof which allows us to add to both sides: we can add -c:
b - c = 0
One way we could do that is proof by contradiction. Assume ab ≠ ac and show that it must be that b ≠ c, without ever relying on multiplying both sides. (Which would be begging the question: assuming that which you're trying to prove; you must never assume the truth of the rule you're trying to prove.)
For instance:
ab - ac ≠ 0 # subtract ac from both sides
a(b - c) ≠ 0 # distributive law
a ≠ 0 AND (b - c) ≠ 0 # Follows from 0x = 0
b - c ≠ 0 # right branch of AND above
b ≠ c # add c
Thus if we assume that b = c, yet ab ≠ ac, we arrive at a contradiction: b ≠ c. Something has to give if we want to keep b = c, namely it must be that ab = ac.
We relied on some existing rules, like being able to add the same quantity to both sides, but we didn't multiply both sides of the inequality by the same factor; we relied on inferring something by using the distributive property to rearrange the difference of products ab - ac into a product form a(b - c). If a product XY is nonzero, Y must be nonzer, and so must X; if either is zero, then it falls victim to the 0x = 0 rule: zero times anything is zero.