3 ms·
There is a saying: “those who can do, do, and those who can’t do, teach.” Maybe it would be fair to augment that with, “those who don’t understand a subject wel
by rayiner 4y ago
There is a saying: “those who can do, do, and those who can’t do, teach.” Maybe it would be fair to augment that with, “those who don’t understand a subject well enough to do or teach, report.”
The problem is particularly bad in science journalism, but exists across the board. Financial journalism is really the only area I’ve seen where the journalists tend to have real backgrounds in the subject. And unsurprisingly financial journalism stands head and shoulders above other journalistic fields.
- ReptileMan 4y agoThat is because there is actually audience willing to pay for the quality content. We really should solve how to pay for content problem. Subscription is not cutting it, but per article seems to be abandoned. Add driven drives everything to crap. Couple of years ago I was joking that Jezebel and EverydayFeminism dies because NYTimes became them with better spellcheck. Unfortunately not a joke anymore.
- tensor 4y agoThis is an arrogant and toxic saying. Let's not repeat it let alone add to it please.
- zaphar 4y agoSomeone made a statement of opinion without supporting evidence. You followed that up with another statement of opinion without supporting evidence. As a result no consensus was reached and this entire exchange went no where. Why do you think it was an arrogant and toxic statement? Do you disagree that financial journalism is better? Do you think finance journalism itself is toxic? Do you have evidence that a belief such as "finance jounalism is generally more excellent than others" is toxic in some way?
- the_only_law 4y agoThey're referring the first sentence, with the cliche phrase. I personally don't make it seriously, because half the "doers" I've met can hardly do shit.
- rayiner 4y agoBut is it true or not? That’s what matters right?
- tptacek 4y agoIt's obviously not true. Teaching is a distinct skill (it's probably a large basket of distinct skills). People having varying aptitudes for it. Common sense tells you that the cliche can't possibly be true. George Bernard Shaw put those words deliberately into the mouth of a character you in particular would find absolutely insufferable.
- pen2l 4y agoTo go even further, I find a saying attributed to Aristotle to be quite true: "Those who know, do. Those that understand, teach." I find that true experts are able to explain subject matter in their domain simply, they can ably distill complicated issues to their essence lest their pupil be bogged down in unnecessary side-details. I used to think Raymond Hettinger was just an awesome teacher because he could make certain programming tasks seem like things a 3rd grader could do with ease, then I discovered he's a big force behind the creation of py and he just sees and presents things at a very fundamental level.
- tptacek 4y agoSeems pretty unlikely that Aristotle said anything like that; all these epigrams are kind of silly, in that they're all stemming from something a fictional character said (or wrote) in a play. But I agree, it's cringe-y to see people try to dunk on teachers like this. There are good teachers and bad teachers like there are good and bad everythings; if you've had a good teacher for something before, it's hard for me to imagine that you'd take Shaw's character seriously with the "those who can" stuff.
- pvg 4y agoSeems pretty unlikely that Aristotle said anything like that You'd be surprised at the kind of thing that's been recovered from excavated tweet shards: https://twitter.com/leyawn/status/585859882869469184 https://twitter.com/leyawn/status/585859882869469184
- 11amxn11 4y ago