4 ms·
I dunno if that's strictly true. Many fields can be reasonably covered with some minimal training. The hard sciences, though, are constantly changing so much th
by solardev 4y ago
I dunno if that's strictly true. Many fields can be reasonably covered with some minimal training. The hard sciences, though, are constantly changing so much that even practitioners in the same field of science can barely keep up in peer review... much less scientists from other disciplines, and much less poorly-paid journalists without dedicated science training. And these days, so many of the findings are subtle and perhaps somewhat interesting in a purely scientific sense, but have to be hyped up in marketing dept PRs to make the general news cycle at all.
The issue compounds when poorly trained, poorly paid journalists interview scientists and then misreport and misquote their findings, leading to a loss of a trust, the next interview being less detailed, etc. It's a vicious cycle of dumbing down and hyping up, all to fit our clickbait-sized attention spans.
Is there an easy way around it? I doubt it. You're essentially reporting bleeding-edge findings from leading PhDs flailing under a publish-or-perish model, to an audience who mostly has not touched science since middle school (if even then). People don't even know why they should CARE about science, much less what your margins of error and P-values are, etc.
- feet 4y agoMaybe reporters just shouldn't be reporting on every little paper but rather universities should have a media department with scientists that handles press releases so they don't suck ass
- davrosthedalek 4y agoHaving seen the PR disasters from CERN, I'd say we need less PR releases.
- feet 4y agoYea because those were undoubtedly worse than your average scientific reporting from whatever Times? Honestly, come on
- davrosthedalek 4y agoThe problem is that they caused that reporting. No PR about superluminal neutrinos, no hysterical reporting about them. This would have given the community time to find the bad connection which caused the bad data.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI'm sure that would go down well, I mean what better way to make enemies at your university than by publishing critical reviews of your colleagues work in a public press release. A better idea would be to have the anonymous peer reviews published as an addendum to each paper, that would be fun. Also highlight whether or not the work was published in a 'private club' journal with lax standards or not. Maybe interview the lab techs as anonymous sources to see what kind of standards the lab really operates with? Do some investigative journalism? Cue furious PIs demanding the entire media relations department be fired... University media relations departments are just not going to to point out flaws in the work of their own PI-led research groups, they're in the business of fluffing their reputations, because that means they might get more students, more grants, more positive media coverage, etc. It's a business these days, isn't it? Corporate PR professionals are running that show more often than not.
- feet 4y agoI agree with essentially everything you say, although I would hope we could figure out a way to structure our research organizations to prevent that sort of bias but having a dedicated scientific reporting organization of some kind that does serious due diligence I think could definitely work
- solardev 4y agoUniversities do. But they're biased and try to hype up the science. Reporters are supposed to sort through that and find the good ones. It's just not easy. You can try it yourself sometime if you'd like. Choose a field of science, comb through a year (or a month's) worth of primary liteature on Google Scholar and Sci Hub, along with press releases from research labs, without resorting to secondary sources like blogs and science news. See if you can pick out the top 10 stories in any given time period and accurately summarize them for an 8th grade reading level. Email competing labs and other experts to get contrary opinions. Write it all up within a day or two, per article. Try to get it published somewhere, and get paid for it if you can. It's not an easy job...