4 ms·
> it's that all news is that bad. I don't think so. Weather news are alright, traffic news are alright, etc. There are fields that suck harder and there are fi
by atoav 4y ago
> it's that all news is that bad.
I don't think so. Weather news are alright, traffic news are alright, etc. There are fields that suck harder and there are fields that just work okay, maybe because they are simple enough, maybe because you can learn them once and apply what you have learned forever.
But science is different for sure and the journalism on it sucks because getting to the point where you even understand the problem might require years of preparation. And the journalist might not have had those years, despite them having to explain it in a simpler way to an audience which might even know less. A good journalist writing about any other topic might be able to grasp a topic quite firmly when they prepare for a week or two, but something as complex as the bleeding edge of any scientific field will be extremely hard to grasp at times for them (understandably so).
Now the issue is: to explain a complicated issue in a very simple fashion requires more proficiency in that subject, not less.
- Closi 4y agoWeather news is ok if you are outside the weather industry - but to those in the industry the forecasts are simplistic and biased, and the news doesn’t generally cover developments in forecasting technology or technique. The broader topic of climate in popular news is known to be a total shit show however (not just science, also policy etc). For what it’s worth, I work in Supply Chain and articles around that in the last year range from vaguely accurate to wild stabs in the dark.
- areoform 4y agoWhich ones were the best, in your opinion?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoUntil weather reporting became mostly automated, most news agencies had a policy of never reporting a chance of rain as being less than 20%. If it was 8%, it was always rounded up to 20%. If you remember seeing "20% of rain" excessively most of your life, this is why. Some of them still do this, especially with on the air reports by a human.
- dtech 4y agoThat actually sounds like good practice, due to humans not having good intuition about chance. Most people will interpret "8% of rain" as "it's not going to rain", and then be mad at the "inaccurate" weather report if it rains the next day.
- Planktonne 4y ago> But science is different for sure and the journalism on it sucks because getting to the point where you even understand the problem might require years of preparation. This is not at all unique to science; people tend to assume this about their own fields, not realising that it actually applies to most of them.
- ghaff 4y ago"Terrible" reportage can indeed mean getting quotes wrong and basic established facts incorrect. But it also covers simplifying things for a (somewhat educated) lay audience, making decisions about what to include and exclude, and including perspectives that some experts may take issue with. Certainly, it would be nice if many journalists had a better background in what they're writing about. But it's also a case that experts can have unreasonable expectations about the depth and nuance of something written for the more or less general public.
- mattkrause 4y agoI think the nature of science reporting exacerbates it. The "Science Section" of your local paper covers an absolutely massive range of topics: astronomy one week, zoology the next, and everything in between. Nobody--literally nobody--has the breadth of expertise to do all of those fields justice. The rest of the paper has a more consistent focus. If you covered last year's debate over gun control, that background carries over to this week's debate. The players change slowly too--some of the folks in Congress have been there for decades.
- Clubber 4y ago>Weather news are alright, traffic news are alright I'd venture to say weather news is also alarmist and therefore bad, particularly during severe weather events and hyping up hurricane news.