4 ms·
Regarding police and politicians and the state, you will find this paper from the 80s insightful: https://online.ucpress.edu/as/article-abstract/23/4/484/21949/
by 1sembiyan 4y ago
Regarding police and politicians and the state, you will find this paper from the 80s insightful: https://online.ucpress.edu/as/article-abstract/23/4/484/21949/The-Police-and-Political-Order-in-India?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://online.ucpress.edu/as/article-abstract/23/4/484/2194...
Police in India serves the elected powers, always. The Indian state has always been authoritarian, more so in recent times. Given the nature of how power is shared and exercised at different levels in India, it’s easy to call Prime Minister a fool and get away with it - and many do. But you dare not publicly call your local municipal councilor that, or these days, the Chief Minister.
A recent example from
1. West Bengal: https://m.thewire.in/article/culture/pure-or-profane-roddur-roys-arrest-can-be-a-defining-moment-for-bengals-social-grammar/amp https://m.thewire.in/article/culture/pure-or-profane-roddur-...
2. There’s no shortage of such vindictiveness from the UP government and its CM: https://m.thewire.in/article/government/up-police-arrests-19-year-old-for-social-media-post-against-adityanath/amp https://m.thewire.in/article/government/up-police-arrests-19...
3. From Maharashtra: https://groundreport.in/who-is-actress-ketaki-chitale-arrested-for-insulting-sharad-pawar/amp/ https://groundreport.in/who-is-actress-ketaki-chitale-arrest...
A great recent movie exploring this aspect of the police and the state in India is Nayattu, available on Netflix: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayattu_(2021_film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nayattu_(2021_film)
This movie was scripted by an ex-cop and makes a sympathetic case for the sort of daily negotiations the cops are involved in. The “hunted” from the title are literally other cops.
Many Tamil movies have been exploring the police-politician nexus for a few decades now. Sathya (1989?) comes to my mind.
This is an incomplete list, and doesn’t really explore the causes of the violence, but I think in many cases it can be linked to the parties in power: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cases_of_police_brutality_in_India https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cases_of_police_brut...
Another overview of why the police in India are particularly susceptible to political pressure: https://www.fairobserver.com/region/central_south_asia/javeed-ahmad-india-police-service-reform-political-corruption-news-15261/?amp https://www.fairobserver.com/region/central_south_asia/javee...
> They should serve the state, which is a creation of and responsible to the people. Serving a political party is corrupt and not serving the people;
Well, that’s Indian police for you. Designed to be corruptible even before we had a republic.
- wolverine876 4y ago> The Indian state has always been authoritarian Unless you mean something different than what authoritarian usually means, you are overlooking decades of democracy.
- 1sembiyan 4y agoI just gave you a bunch of examples of the politicians using the police to restrict or restrain the Indian people in some manner in contravention to constitutional principles over the past few decades. Sure, India is not a fully authoritarian state, but the folks elected have always had such tendencies. The current government still has to contest elections (and still loses them at state level), but you wouldn’t deny they are authoritarian. And many state governments (controlled by different parties of different political persuasions, as I have listed above) display the same tendencies: authority exercised via coercion and arbitrary rules. Democracy and authoritarianism are not opposites. They occupy a spectrum - democracies can display authoritarian characteristics and vice versa.
- GWBullshit 4y agoI'd highly recommend re-reading 1984. When dealing with those supporting authoritarian governments, you need less bigthink and more simplethink. Worlds like "spectrum" are bad-think-party-no-nos that lead to job-ouchies.