6 ms·
It was a mistake to write off the Russians: Neil MacFarlane takes a long view
- mytailorisrich 4y ago"Putin thinks the collapse of the Soviet Union was the single biggest disaster of the 20th century – not World War I or World War II, but the collapse of the Soviet empire." This is often repeated and might sound strange from a Western perspective. However, from a Russian perspective it makes perfect sense. The Russian Empire suffered losses during WWI but survived as the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union suffered heavy human losses during WWII but emerged as a superpower with greatly increased status and influence. When the Soviet Union collapsed Russia lost pretty much everything and this was clearly a low point over hundreds of years for them.
- yywwbbn 4y agoI’m pretty sure ~ 1922 was the low point using any reasonable metric. Collapse in agricultural production, widespread famine and the red terror (following years of both white and red terror..) The 1990’s were nothing compared to the Russian Civil war and it’s aftermath. Using logic like this the collapse of the Tsarist Empire was clearly a much bigger disaster.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThey did not lose all territories outside of Russia proper (so to speak) at that time. Things wobbled dangerously but they made it through. To take a current example, in 1922 Ukraine was a Soviet Republic. They lost it in 1991. Hence the situation today.
- wrp 4y ago> *Putin thinks the collapse of the Soviet Union was the single biggest disaster of the 20th century..." This is usually quoted in relation to one of Putin's speeches, and is generally interpreted out of context. What Putin was referring to in that speech was the humanitarian problem of millions of Russians finding themselves residing outside "their country" when the USSR dissolved. That said, I think most people would consider certain holocausts to be greater disasters. Neil MacFarlane had an article on the Ukraine situation in 2014.[1] He seems to agree with John Mearsheimer about bungled diplomacy. [1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00396338.2014.920139 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00396338.2014.92...
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's the price of moving your population forcibly outside of its borders as a part of an occupation strategy. It wasn't really 'their' country to begin with.
- wrp 4y agoBy "their country," I meant the state of Russia. Millions of Russians suddenly found themselves, not by choice, disconnected from Russia.
- yieldcrv 4y agoIt is also a massive landmass that only had small amounts of territory in any of the war theatres (despite large populations involved) There is always potential for that landmass and its vast resources to be stewarded well The Soviet Union was the closest attempt of that, being able to create similar but parallel advances as the non-communist regime, but ultimately was not able to continue for predictable reasons I can see how that perspective is worth while to consider
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Soviet Union collapsed Russia lost pretty much everything Present-day Russia is still an empire, with ethnic Russians ruling over a host of minorities [1]. Those minorities feature prominently in Russia’s mineral-rich corridors. They are far more scarce at, say, the KGB or Kremlin. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Russia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Russia
- sorokod 4y agoNot sure they are that scarce, take for example the minister of defense. Also many of the high ranking officers in the military. The army is often the only way out of shitty social and economic situation and the situation is shitty in the various republics and oblasts
- Georgelemental 4y agoIt was not just a territorial and population loss, Russia also "lost pretty much everything" economically during the 90s. Ordinary Russians suffered a lot as oligarchs enriched themselves by looting the old Soviet SOEs
- jacquesm 4y agoThey also feature richly in the canon-fodder department.
- rlkf 4y ago> The Russian Empire suffered losses during WWI but survived as the Soviet Union. I think you would find it interesting to read about the peace treaty of Brest-Litovsk, where the Russians lost about as much as they've "lost" now. Hadn't it been for the other Entente powers after the war, it would have been a done deal already then.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoOutcome was that they in fact did not lose as much as with the fall of the Soviet Union...
- akhmatova 4y agoHowever, from a Russian perspective it makes perfect sense. No, it's just a meme. Which is now speedily propelling them to yet another collapse. Russia lost pretty much everything. It was never theirs to begin with.
- Georgelemental 4y agoIt was not just a territorial and population loss, Russia also "lost pretty much everything" economically during the 90s. Ordinary Russians suffered a lot as oligarchs enriched themselves by looting the old Soviet SOEs
- csee 4y agoWW1 and the famines after the revolution were more of a humanitarian low point for them than 1991. Even after considering the dip in life expectancy and the financial crises and the kleptocratic corruption, the 1990s doesn't compare to what Russians (not to mention the minorities like the Tartars) went through in the early years of Bolshevik rule. I would only agree that the 1990s were an unprecedented low point from the viewpoint of national pride via the prism of nationalism, given the losses in territory and influence that Russia had. Which explains why Putin thinks it's the single biggest disaster - he's a fascist and ultranationalist. Such people care about national pride and empire above all else.
- sorokod 4y ago"Russia lost pretty much everything" It's worth looking at the map, the Russian Federation as it is today is huge. A lot of the territory and it's peoples are underdeveloped and economically depressed. So much could be done there. I spent a few hours watching Girkin's (aka Strelkov) channel on VK. The man is the unofficial mouthpiece of the hawks faction in the government. It is pure nationalistic empire building.
- Georgelemental 4y ago> "Russia lost pretty much everything" This is not just about territorial loss. In the aftermath of the Soviet Union's fall, during the transition to a market economy, the oligarchs basically looted all of Russia's wealth by taking control of the old Soviet SOEs. It was a truly terrible time for a lot of ordinary people. And Putin is the one who brought the oligarchs under control. So it's natural that he and much of the Russian people see him as the strong man who can pull Russia out of the 90s disaster and restore Russia to the glory it deserves. That's part of the mindset driving the present war, I think
- sorokod 4y agoThey are still looting and I'd say it's not so clear cut who is controlling whom nowdays. Glory is off course in the eye of beholder and the desire to be glorious is definitely at the root of this war.
- Georgelemental 4y agoNah, Putin's hold over the oligarchs is stronger than ever, now that they can't invest abroad anymore due to sanctions. Putin loves to bring this up in his speeches, arguing that getting burned by sanctions was the predictable consequense of engaging with those traitorous Westerners and that clearly the oligarchs should have invested in the Glorious Fatherland instead
- sorokod 4y agoThat is just PR. The thing with oligarchs is that the loot and power they hold is considered to be some sort of escrow to be used by the power structure as it sees fit. Those who forget it, die or go to prison.
- darthrupert 4y agoThe biggest disaster of the 20th century happened when nuclear weapons spread outside the US.
- yywwbbn 4y agoWhat makes you think the US wouldn’t have nuked half the world by now if they were the only ones that had it? The main reason why nobody uses nukes or why are there no direct wars between world powers anymore is nuclear proliferation. I might be wrong and we might have had 80 years of relative peace without them but looking at human history up to and including WW2 that does not seem likely..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ericmay 4y ago> What makes you think the US wouldn’t have nuked half the world by now if they were the only ones that had it? Mainly because Americans just aren’t they kind of people. Had the opportunity, actually, after Japan surrendered and the US could have went to war with the USSR and built and used more atomic weapons but it didn’t. It has had ample opportunity and actual generals in the military during war time who advocated for their use and they still weren’t used again. I sympathize with the OP (though I don’t think the US being the only one with nuclear weapons would make a difference) because proliferation has largely fallen into the hands of bad actors and as they continue to proliferate it effectively locks their awful governments in power.
- ksec 4y agoSlightly Off Topic. Is there a word, theory, law or something that describe this phenomenon, where the contrarian view ( so to speak ) only gets published when the worst really did happen. We told you Russian will Invade. We told you Crypto wasn't sustainable. Or may be some day, We told you China will invade. Or in terms of tech, We told you TSMC will overtake Intel. ( That was in 2013/2014, most of HN didn't even know what TSMC was ) And only when shit hits the fan will you get "Here is a professor who have been stating this since x ".
- eevilspock 4y agoHow does one distinguish between intelligent contrarian views and a broken clock being right once every 24 hours? How to know if your examples point to an unnecessarily high failure to listen to contrarian views rather than reflecting a survivorship bias mistaking natural randomness for a problem? I don't disagree with your observations or that we have a hear no evil problem, but I'm a contrarian by nature, so I guess I'm being contrarian about contrarianism.
- soSadm4n 4y agoNo because the content does not “only get published” when the worst happens. You can find books, popular newspaper articles, etc that predicted the housing crash and some that even predicted the 07-08 timeline. 2022 video about changing world order: https://youtu.be/xguam0TKMw8 https://youtu.be/xguam0TKMw8 1997 article about leveraging worker insecurity to keep people in jobs: https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-of-workers-is-a-big-factor-in-fed-policy.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-o... Accurate predictions are all over because human society is intentional, and physical reality has constraints. I predict you will die of dehydration if you stop drinking fluids. Many things are certain despite all the uncertainty we feel.