3 ms·
I'm a little uncomfortable with the author's insistence that hue, saturation, and value are objective physical measurements: > Outlined are the controls for th
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
I'm a little uncomfortable with the author's insistence that hue, saturation, and value are objective physical measurements:
> Outlined are the controls for three parameters which define the physical parameters of any colour uniquely. ‘Hue’ for the part of the spectrum the colour falls on; ‘saturation’ for the range from grey to vivid; and ‘value’ for lightness-darkness.
> Hue, saturation, and value represent only the physical characteristics of coloured light.
I don't think this is right. Hue, saturation, and value are statements about human perception, not about the physical characteristics of light. A description of the physical characteristics of some light would look like a histogram plotting the wavelength of the light against the amount of light present at each wavelength. How do you interpret HSV from that?
Well, value is pretty straightforward: the greater the area plotted in your histogram, the higher the value, I guess. More light -> more value. This falls apart if we're considering light of a single wavelength, where increasing the amount of light doesn't cause the color to get more washed out.
Saturation is less straightforward, but the idea is there: a color with low saturation (greyish) should have a histogram that looks more or less flat, and a color with high saturation should have a histogram characterized by a lot of zeroes and spikes. The number of spikes in the histogram is... completely arbitrary.
Then we come to hue and our model completely falls apart. Hue is purely subjective and there's no way to systematically relate it to light wavelengths.
The article comes close to suggesting that hue is objectively significant:
> In the colour circle at the left, the direction from the centre represents hue
> Most English speakers would be comfortable using ‘blue’ to refer to all of the top left quarter of the circle. But we wouldn’t feel nearly as comfortable grouping all of the bottom right quarter under a single term.
This is true, but it's an artifact of an arbitrary definition of hue. You could change how much angular space is assigned to each color without causing any problems in the HSV model.
There's another interesting claim in the piece:
> Gladstone does make a starkly racist declaration that ancient colour systems are ‘less mature’ than contemporary English.
It seems pretty likely that Gladstone would have been happy to claim that he and the ancient Greeks belonged to the same race. Why is this a starkly racist declaration?
- pvg 4y agoIt seems pretty likely that Gladstone would have been happy to claim Well, he did write a book titled The Ethnology of the Greek Races. Victorians had a fairly different, more granular notion of 'race' but most of them took racial determinism as a given, they were fundamentally racist in the most literal sense. They came up with stuff like this, for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martial_race https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martial_race
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jacobolus 4y ago> Hue, saturation, and value are statements about human perception, not about the physical characteristics of light Color in general is a statement about human perception, not physical characteristics of light. As Newton said, “the rays are not colored”. Hue, chroma, and value are human-perceptual color attributes. They vary based on spatial and temporal context, and vary from observer to observer. But people should not use the HSV color model (or your favorite image editor’s color picker) for this kind of analysis. It is a garbage tool for just about every purpose, but especially for this one. Munsell’s model, which is much more perceptually uniform, or e.g. the World Color Survey chart based on it https://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/wcs/images/jrus-20100531/wcs-chart-4x.png https://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/wcs/images/jrus-20100531/wcs-... are much clearer.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Color in general is a statement about human perception, not physical characteristics of light. As Newton said, “the rays are not colored”. The color is fully and solely determined by the wavelength of the light, and the wavelength is an objective physical phenomenon; it is not crazy to talk about the objective realities of color. But yes, it's full of pitfalls.
- jacobolus 4y ago> color is fully and solely determined by the wavelength of the light The incorrectness of this assertion is pretty much the first (and most fundamental) thing you will find in any book about color science. Then the rest of the book is spent elaborating about why this statement is false and explaining the technical details. If you want a definitive definition of color, you can find one in the CIE’s International Lighting Vocabulary. But here is Mark Fairchild of the Munsell Color Science Laboratory at RIT, one of the world’s leading color scientists: http://markfairchild.org/WhyIsColor/Questions/1-1.html http://markfairchild.org/WhyIsColor/Questions/1-1.html > Our eyes sense the light from the world around us and start the process of seeing color. You might think the light on these eyes is colored, but really it is your very own eyes and brain that are creating that color from the light coming from this picture. > Color is a human perception. > We see color because our eyes and brains respond to light present in the world around us. That light comes from light sources such as the sun, light bulbs, or even televisions. Sometimes that light interacts with objects before reaching our eyes and the objects allow more or less of the different types of light to reach our eyes. This makes different things look different colors. > Color is part of our sense of vision. It is similar to how we respond to other aspects of the world with our other senses such as taste, hearing, touch, and smell.
- a1369209993 4y ago> > Gladstone does make a starkly racist declaration that ancient colour systems are ‘less mature’ than contemporary English. That's particularly eyeroll-inducing since most contemporary English terminology and culture is to some degree descended from the ancient Greeks (either directly or via the Romans), so whatever the alleged merits of "maturity", the English stuff clearly has about two extra millennia of it.