3 ms·
Is there any downside to this? Seems to me this is a positive outcome if it encourages speculators to leave the cryptocurrency space. Crypto was never intended
by nice_one 4y ago
Is there any downside to this? Seems to me this is a positive outcome if it encourages speculators to leave the cryptocurrency space.
Crypto was never intended to be used (and abused) in such a way, and is a considerable deviation from Satoshi's original vision regarding Bitcoin. Perhaps it's time to get back to basics.
- Eji1700 4y agoI think there's some % chance that this collapse will hit outside the crypto world. I'm not going to be shocked when we find out through some stupid chain pensions were invested and the like. Could wind up with major governmental oversight moving forward, basically making damn sure it's barely ever adopted. Everyone always talks about "satoshi's vision" and what not, but crypto isn't going to be worth shit if you are forced to make trades in black market scenarios because it shit the bed so bad it took down serious stuff with it. Granted this is probably worst case which i'd put at very low odds.
- anonymoushn 4y agoWe recently got to hear that some Canadian pensions had invested in Celsius, but not very much.
- bb88 4y ago> Could wind up with major governmental oversight moving forward, basically making damn sure it's barely ever adopted. I'm basically of two minds about this. One is that as long as people understand they're buying nothing of real value, it's fine if they want to "gamble". It's like a lottery ticket in this regard. The other is if or perhaps when taxpayers will need to bail out crypto companies. At this point, I'll be extremely angry, and want the strictest government regulation possible.
- rurp 4y agoI think it's best to let people make their own decisions wherever possible. Of course with pensions the people with exposure aren't the same ones making investing choices. I would be fine with regulation that just bans those sorts of vehicles from investing in crypto. That way individuals can speculate with their money, while being guarded against more systemic and indirect risks.
- bb88 4y ago> I think it's best to let people make their own decisions wherever possible. Of course with pensions the people with exposure aren't the same ones making investing choices. If pensions were involved the people who decided that pensions should be invested in crypto should be prosecuted. > I would be fine with regulation that just bans those sorts of vehicles from investing in crypto. I would be fine with regulation that banned people from investing in something that has no value.
- int_19h 4y agoValue is subjective, so who decides?
- octodog 4y agoIt doesn't seem like the linkage between traditional finance and crypto finance is that strong yet. If it ever got to that point I think we'd more likely see prudential authorities restrict traditional finance actors from investing in crypto rather than governments banning crypto outright.
- wpietri 4y agoI appreciate the feeling, but the problem is that Bitcoin just isn't very useful for the original vision, "a purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash". [1] It's fine for a little light crime, where people are willing to put up with slow transactions, high costs, inconvenience, and significant risks to e.g., buy some mail-order LSD. But when you compare it with things like debit cards, Venmo, and M-Pesa, it's just not competitive. I think Bitcoin was a really interesting idea in the pre-iPhone era, but for a variety of reasons it just didn't pan out. Which is why the space was so readily colonized by scammers, grifters, criminals, fraudsters, speculators, and loons. [1] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- fooey 4y agoYeah, the original vision was never plausible. BTC has absolutely never been viable as a currency and never will be.
- runnr_az 4y agoTotally. Why would I want anyone I pay to know exactly how much I’ve spent on all my other transactions?
- fidelramos 4y agoNot a problem thanks to CashFusion [0], easy privacy for P2P electronic cash. [0] https://cashfusion.org/ https://cashfusion.org/
- kersplody 4y agoIt was supposed to be cash without the burden of nation state oversight. Instead, it turned into a giant casino ecosystem of unregulated securities involving more and more layers of abstraction (exchanges, stable-coins, NFTs, bundled transactions, hedges, subchains, ...)
- nickelpro 4y ago> It was supposed to be cash without the burden of nation state oversight While convenience remains the core point under contention, the secondary point of debate with crypto is the one you raise here: why is this a good thing? Why would I want an unregulated currency, free of consumer protections or government oversight? If someone steals my credit card I call the bank and reverse the charges. When a bank gets robbed or collapses, the FDIC ensures consumers are unaffected. Governments aren't a power independent of their communities, they're not aliens from outer space interfering with natural human ways of life. Government is how we the community organize ourselves to ensure our collective protection. They're, obviously, deeply imperfect, but a system completely severing itself from those organizing principles is fated to replicate them with even greater imperfection.
- bb88 4y agoThere's a non zero amount of people who put their life saving into crypto because it was going to go "to the moon." Everything was coming up Milhouse... until it wasn't. So those people are probably going to rely upon taxpayers for help. And so when homeless hodlers appear on the streets looking for the government handout, that's gonna piss off liberals and conservatives alike.
- sbf501 4y agoHomomorphic encryption without financialization will be the final form of cryptocurrency, and only for things like escrow and transfers between banks (probably replacing commercial paper). It'll take a decade and people will probably never see anything but their native currency in their banks. Part of the slow adoption will probably be due to it making Olde-Timey forms of corruption no longer possible. (But I'm sure new kinds will arise.) It was never meant to be an investment, just like you said.
- kersplody 4y agoThe problem is that the people at the bottom of the pyramid have no idea how crypto works or the risks involved. Seems to me that defining crypto as an Unregulated Security would be a good first step, allowing only "Accredited Investors" to participate in crypto trading directly.
- monodeldiablo 4y agoThe original vision has some questionable assumptions. Being deflationary by design practically guarantees speculation and undermines any utility as a currency. If broad adoption was an actual goal, cryptocurrencies wouldn't be fundamentally structured like ponzi schemes.
- 323 4y agoSatoshi was absolutely aware that this was going to happen, even if Satoshi might not have liked it. It's impossible to have a currency without speculation and financial markets on top of it.
- yieldcrv 4y agoNo, there is no downside to this There are going to be some great discounts when correlated assets bid down during these liquidations, and some nice block space available Just pick the right asset if you want to speculate, there is always some that move pre-2017 crypto was not a beneficiary of quantitative easing, the hedge funds didnt exist (barring like 3 with low AUM) and the LPs had no vehicle to purchase crypto its more closely a return to that environment, except with waaaay better infrastructure There is still over $200bn in stablecoins ready to move into any crypto asset at any moment 24/7, the redemptions to fiat aren’t really happening