5 ms·
It's simpler than that, it is all about incentives. Science can happen even in the trenches of war, or by random employees in a patent office. Engineering needs
by seydor 4y ago
It's simpler than that, it is all about incentives. Science can happen even in the trenches of war, or by random employees in a patent office. Engineering needs resources and conerted efford. But when the incentives have nothing to do with science itself but rather with the struggle to keep all the PhD people employed, you end up with paper-mills and grant-harvester PIs. There s also a degeneration of the science culture due to so much self-promotion. Whatever happened to humility?
Engineering projects like Apollo or Manhattan succeded by taking the theory invented by a few madmen and making the entire effort to the end product. Instead we now have projects like the Human brain project (EU) and the Brain initiative that don't seem to have a defined goal, and no clear incentives. The HBP used to be about building an artificial brain, as ambitious as it sounds. Instead, petty politics and meddling led to the project becoming a project salad with very little to show. AFAIK the Brain initiative has not done better.
The article itself is another example of weak incentives. We don't need to invent another field called "progress studies" in order to make progress. That's only making the problem worse.
- alexfromapex 4y agoAgreed, it's all about choosing the correct performance indicators
- LesZedCB 4y ago"When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure" > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- peteradio 4y agoConsider all the buzz word paper milling was to supplant the nepotistic framework from before.
- Jensson 4y agoBut that nepotistic framework produced a lot of good results, so it is unclear if fixing it this way actually improved the output. Meritocracy isn't a good thing if the extra burden of trying to evaluate merit actually worsen the outcome of the process.
- madacol 4y agoSo, what is progress? I like to think that progress is about maximizing global satisfaction. But then really hard questions follow - Who are included in "global"?, every human being?, every conscious mammal?. Do we all get the same weight? - (Assuming last answer is all human beings) How should we come to a consensus?. How do we coordinate to achieve our agreed goals? If you think this is all too subjective, should we stop pouring resources into philosophy and arts? I think this questions deserve at least some studying
- LesZedCB 4y agohaha, i think it's been studied. you described "utilitarian ethics" https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/utilitarianism-history/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/utilitarianism-history/
- madacol 4y agoThanks!, good to know
- robocat 4y ago> should we stop pouring resources into philosophy and arts? Do we exist just to eat, shit, and breed? Hopefully our civilisation is concerned with more than just the cold necessities of life: a civilisation that lets us do with our minds what we will. Circuses and Netflix have more meaning than bread: bread is merely a low level dependency in the skill tree. I think there is a lot of bollox to our liberal humanities: but who am I to judge what others choose to put their minds to? Edit: the small percentage of gold produced is what matters, not the large percentage of load bearing ore. There can be a lot of worthwhile waste. Disclaimer: I am Engineer, not Word Rotator.
- andsoitis 4y ago> Do we exist just to eat, shit, and breed? we exist because we eat, shit, and breed. But that will end too. We are just an expression of processes in the unfolding universe.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]