5 ms·
Why is a blob running on a 3rd party chip less of an issue than hard coded transistors on a 3rd party chip?
by tedunangst 15y ago
Why is a blob running on a 3rd party chip less of an issue than hard coded transistors on a 3rd party chip?
- Someone 15y agoGood argument. I would say it is not less of an issue, but I also think it isn't less of an issue than having a blob running on the main CPU. IMO, such blobs only become problematic if they do not work properly or aren't flexible enough. Whether they are made in soft-, firm-, or hardware is immaterial for that. In the end, for almost every case (yes, you probably _can_ build your own 1kW 6502-class CPU from sand, if you are good, start young and persevere for a couple of decennia) it boils down to the fact that you will have to trust some other people. After all, you cannot reasonably verify that say a x64 CPU really behaves as its documentation states it does.
- tedunangst 15y agoOne reason the blob on the CPU is so different is the way it interfaces with your code. In that regard, it is almost never flexible enough and the exposed interface surface is generally enormous. Your kernel version is supported only at the mercy of nvidia or whoever. Firmware chunks have a very simple interface: load. Anybody with the firmware file and some basic documentation can make it happen.