4 ms·
> ministers have proposed replacing pop-up cookie alerts on websites with an opt-out system where users set cover-all data permissions in their web browser sett
by dane-pgp 4y ago
> ministers have proposed replacing pop-up cookie alerts on websites with an opt-out system where users set cover-all data permissions in their web browser settings, removing the need to consent to cookies on each site they visit.
That sounds like a nice idea, but are they going to make it illegal for a site to have one of those banners? The headline says "appear less", so it doesn't sound like they'll be forbidden.
Of course the real reason for this law is to remove the protections of the GDPR, and the "cookie pop-ups" claim is just designed to make people continue hating the EU. If the UK government really cared about those pop-ups, they'd properly fund the UK's data regulator and bring actions against companies that don't have a one-click "Refuse cookies" option.
It's also worth asking why companies started using those cookie banners in the first place, instead of complying with the spirit of the GDPR and not using unnecessary tracking cookies at all. My guess is that the pop-ups were designed as a way to gaslight users into hating the regulations, so in that sense the cookie banners have been successful.
I only hope that, as these banners won't actually be illegal, companies that implement UK-specific cookie banner functionality will put up different wording for those users, saying "Thanks for voting for a government that lets us not care about your privacy any more. [Accept]"
- mmarq 4y agoMinisters have proposed the DNT header
- drstewart 4y agoGaslight isn't just a cool word you throw in to make your argument sound more forceful. It actually has a specific meaning. Given that, can you explain how companies are making users doubt their own sanity / reality through cookie banners?
- Semaphor 4y agoI’m afraid you are a bit late to enforce the original meaning > The term may also be used to describe a person (a "gaslighter") who presents a false narrative to another group or person, thereby leading them to doubt their perceptions and become misled, disoriented or distressed. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting
- OJFord 4y agoHm, in particular see the 'excessive misuse' section. I (not person you responded to) haven't seen it in this 'mislead' use before though, only in much less extreme cases than the film but still in the spirit of it, 'denying reality/the other's experience' etc. - I thought that was what people objected to but was a lost cause (until now, thanks).
- dane-pgp 4y agoAre you saying "gaslight" doesn't mean what I thought it did all this time? I feel like I'm losing my mind...