3 ms·
You have somehow failed to understand what is being claimed. The Lindy effect says that entities with longer realized lifespans have longer expected future lif
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
You have somehow failed to understand what is being claimed.
The Lindy effect says that entities with longer realized lifespans have longer expected future lifespans.
In other words, if one thing has been around for 5 years, and another thing has been around for 3 years, then we know three things:
1: The first thing's expected future lifespan is f(5) years.
2: The second thing's expected future lifespan is f(3) years.
3: f(5) is greater than f(3).
Etheryte claims, in a gross error, that this does not imply that the expected future lifespan of shorter-lived things is shorter than that of longer-lived things. This is ridiculous; the claim Etheryte denies is a simple restatement of the Lindy effect. For our two objects of ages 5 and 3 years, the "new" claim would tell us the following three things:
1': The expected future lifespan of the first thing is f(5) years.
2': The expected future lifespan of the second thing is f(3) years.
3': f(3) is less than f(5).
But 1' is exactly the same claim as 1, 2' is exactly the same claim as 2, and 3' is exactly the same claim as 3. No claim has been negated, only repeated.
- feral 4y agoI salute you, Thaumasiotes, great explanation.
- Ygg2 4y agoOk. But then you just proved Lindy effect is at best probabilistic, and most likely survivorship bias. Because it doesn't hold invariant to time. It's not hard to make a counterexample. E.g. when Windows 3.11 existed for several years and Microsoft published Windows 95. If we were to travel back then and use Lindy effect we would get wrong predictions. Because it's such a simple heuristic it only demonstrates one way effect.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> But then you just proved Lindy effect is at best probabilistic Obviously? Look at the statement of the Lindy effect: > The Lindy effect proposes, simplified, that the longer something has been around, the longer it will probably stay around still. What do you think the word "probably" means?