3 ms·
"Take the protocols that allow these various networks to communicate with one another and eventually produced TCP/IP. “Under private ownership, such a language
by WalterBright 4y ago
"Take the protocols that allow these various networks to communicate with one another and eventually produced TCP/IP. “Under private ownership, such a language could never have been created,” writes Tarnoff."
Um, networks communicating with each other was commonplace in those days, they were called "gateways".
Also, there were many privately developed networks, like the bulletin board system, that were global.
The internet also runs on Ethernet - all those internet cables you've got laying around are Ethernet, developed by Xerox.
- Karrot_Kream 4y ago100% the internet was a diverse mix of public and private technologies. BBSes were run privately (group or individual), Fidonet was by private individuals, and Usenet was run by universities, just on the social side. DARPA may have funded TCP/IP but computer networks were thriving before then.
- WalterBright 4y agoThat's right. The idea that a global network wouldn't have existed with DARPA is not credible. Everybody with two computers wanted to connect them, and various schemes of doing it flourished. Heck, even I came up with an outline of how a global system could work before I'd heard of DARPA. (I never did anything about it because I was stupid.)
- HaZeust 4y agoWe still know you from Empire, though - so not everything was fruitless ;)
- WalterBright 4y agoSo many opportunities to become a billionaire I missed! America is not only the land of opportunity, it's the land of blind fools.
- HaZeust 4y agoThat, and the opportunities of even the opportunistic can be lackluster - c'est la vie I suppose!
- WalterBright 4y agoHaha, thanks for the kind words! I was going through another box of my dad's papers today, and found a DECWriter listing of probably my first non-trivial program circa 1976, an expansion of the old BASIC HAMMURABI game. I had thought that was long lost. I lost nearly all of my early code because I put it on a magtape which turned out to be unreadable.
- uncomputation 4y agoThere’s a difference in private and profit-motivated. The author is referring to the latter while you’re referring strictly to the former. The "private" actors of the early internet were not motivated by profit and conducted a lot of research with no clear product goal. Xerox in particular had a hugely influential research division but directly profited from none of their contributions. In fact the only reason we still use Ethernet is because its inventor pushed Xerox towards giving up its trademark and creating an open standard.
- notacoward 4y ago> all those internet cables you've got laying around are Ethernet, developed by Xerox. Anything you're using today is probably not the version invented by Xerox. If one were to name any single inventor it would probably have been someone at SynOptics. Eventually it all became standardized, but by that point the only similarity to the original Xerox technology was the name. You probably knew all that, at some level, but it's important for us to teach the young 'uns a correct version of history that gives credit where due.