6 ms·
The article is a bit vague on the actual arguments. This quote deserves special consideration: > "A privatized internet will always amount to the rule of the m
by roenxi 4y ago
The article is a bit vague on the actual arguments. This quote deserves special consideration:
> "A privatized internet will always amount to the rule of the many by the few"
Giving control to the government is rather explicitly giving control to the few - the government is busy responding to issues voters see as key (eg, inflation, war, environmental concerns, skirmishes between different political groups, etc). Unless a voter is willing (and stupid enough) to prioritise cheap internet access above the important issues then public internet is just asking for regulatory capture.
The government doesn't have the bandwidth to do what this quote implies they can. It will just result in an incompetent, politically connected few in control. We know there is a group who are willing to get involved in corrupting the regulations - it is the people currently profiting off poor internet regulation. How many people are going to use voting as a signal for their displeasure in corruption of a Board of the Internet?
- Rygian 4y agoPrivatizing means giving control to "the few whose only incentive is to make more money." Which is worse beyond doubt.
- culi 4y agoYes but I think what the person you're responding to was pointing out was the high risk of regulatory capture. We tend to have this false dichotomy of the government vs private companies. When in reality most regulation that's passed is most heavily influenced by lobbyists and special (corporate) interests that don't represent the majority. OP is pointing out that government regulation will only work as long as the public stays engaged. In the long term it would actually lead to even more power concentrated to "the few whose only incentive is to make more money."
- diordiderot 4y agoIt feels really unfair that all anti-gov / taxation arguments are just fatalistic "this will fail" and we're okay with that as if entropy isn't the default state of the universe. No use building this bridge it'll just rust. Why eat! you're gonna die anyways. Why bother with a wealth tax, they'll out smart you anyways.
- 0dayz 4y agoThis has nothing to do with defeatism, OP points out the flaw with idealising regulations willy nilly without having a mechanism to make sure it doesn't get exploited (that mechanism often being the people understanding the issue and thus having a stake in it). A good example is direct democracy in Switzerland, the key reason to why it works is that people are 2 things, Switzerland big focus on education and the vast information of the for, against, status quo option the citizens are presented with. Without these things the Swiss would be very vulnerable to demagoguery.
- roenxi 4y agoI would make that argument, but I didn't today. There is a real chance in the next decade that the public will be voting on how to respond to Russia with consequences that may doom us all. That may not even be the biggest issue, depending on how these famines and supply issues resolve. That same election will also be deciding how to handle potential corruption in some Board of the Internet. Are you going to put aside the threat of nuclear war for another day and vote with the #1 issue being whether you feel your internet is too expensive and/or suitably available? Do you want to encourage others to do the same? That would be beyond reckless in my humble opinion. Internet regulation isn't going to make top 5 for me personally for a long while yet. It isn't reasonable to talk about a public internet putting control into the hands of the Many. The Many don't have that many hands, their hands are already full. They cannot grapple with this issue as well. This will just result in some random committee of people, probably paid off by corporate interests, who will be even fewer than the theoretical few that the article complains of. They will not listen to you either. And that isn't defeatism, it is pointing out that this solution takes a reasonably good thing and makes it worse by applying woolly thinking to a real situation. The complaint is that power is too centralised, then it is proposing to centralise power further.
- uncomputation 4y ago> Are you going to put aside the threat of nuclear war for another day and vote with the #1 issue being whether you feel your internet is too expensive and/or suitably available? You could make this same argument with literally anything though, as if the only priority of the government is nuclear war. Are you going to put aside the threat of nuclear war and vote on food and drug regulation? Are you going to put aside the threat of nuclear war and vote on voting rights? Are you going to put aside the threat of nuclear war and vote on tax reform? This argument reduces the government to a worst-case scenario committee.
- t0suj4 4y agoI suggest to look up the other definition of the word. Because you may meet people who see privatization as handing control over to members of the public.
- Rygian 4y agoThe useful distinction being "members of" vs "elected representatives." I live in an European country. I cannot for the life of me figure out in which way would (a consortium of) private companies come up with something like the GDPR law and the enforcement structures around it. What would be their incentive, as private entities?
- BoxOfRain 4y agoInterestingly this is exactly the line of reasoning arch-privatiser Margaret Thatcher gave in her speeches on the subject, she claimed privatisation put nationalised industries in the hands of the public because anyone could buy shares in these industries which were hitherto limited to an out-of-touch government elite, while her ideological opponents (retroactively known as 'Old Labour') made the argument that nationalisation was putting those industries in the hands of the people because they were run by the democratically elected state rather than an out-of-touch corporate elite. Personally I lean towards Thatcher having done more harm than good, while the British government absolutely did have nationalised industries that were inefficient and needed to be wound down or at least heavily reformed (coal mining and the nationalised car company British Leyland being the prime examples) the way her government just cut down whole communities at the knees was wanton and unreasonable. Rail privatisation in the UK has been a failure too, our system is much more expensive and less reliable than nationalised Continental equivalents to the point it's cheaper to fly from London to Newcastle via Barcelona than it is to take the train, which is fairly likely to be cancelled without reason five minutes before it's due anyway. Even without the economics, the negative environmental effects of this situation are too obvious to mention! I don't know why so many people insist on absolutism for either position though, the position that natural monopolies and strategic national assets (like nuclear power stations for example) should be nationalised and other industries should be privatised isn't unreasonable.
- 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoDisagree strongly. Far better to be distributed resources and not in the hands of the group with a monopoly on violence. I mean the US already tried to create a “Disinformation Bureau”. You imagine if they had the keys to the internet too?
- xyzzyz 4y agoNot just “Disinformation Bureau”, but also “Rumor Control Program”. It’s all in the released documents — though, shockingly, missing from the DHS Secretary testimony to the Congress. She must have just forgotten to mention it, surely nothing sinister going on in there.
- safety1st 4y agoI'm decidedly not interested in choosing between control by a handful of bureaucrats vs a handful of profiteers. Neither is an acceptable lesser evil. If Paris Marx or any other leftist intellectual du jour wants a greater public role in Internet governance, they need to first admit that there's a permanent bureaucracy in Washington which is largely immune to elections and unaccountable to the people, then get rid of it. We already know what the outcome in the US will be if they don't. You can introduce as many rules as you want. They'll still be written by Eric Schmidt, he'll just have a different job title.
- UberFly 4y agoA+ comment
- sien 4y agoLast week they were demanding that dating sites be 'socialized'. https://jacobin.com/2022/06/tinder-hinge-for-profit-dating-apps-socialize-democratization https://jacobin.com/2022/06/tinder-hinge-for-profit-dating-a... It'll be interesting to see what must be 'socialized' next week.
- Ygg2 4y agoKnowing Jacobin, the answer is yes. As in everything. My 2cents: Last mile is most expensive and isn't conductive for competition. So there is some sense for it to be publicly owned. That said, giving government power over it must me done in a way that can't be used to discriminate. I.e. if you are Republican in a blue state, state can't just arbitrarily decide to prevent from connecting, or vice versa.
- usrn 4y agoThe internet is probably the very last thing I would associate with "rule by the few." I don't know what this guy is on about.
- bitwize 4y agoBut that's only because the government as it exists now is the puppet of private interests. But don't worry. Once the glorious revolution comes and the reactionaries are all imprisoned or shot, the government that emerges will act strictly in the interests of the people. Fun history lesson: look up who the Jacobins were and what they did.
- Loughla 4y agoLegitimately, one of the best quotes about this is from Terry Pratchett' Night Watch book: >Don't put your trust in revolutions. They always come around again. That's why they're called revolutions.” Commander Sam Vimes
- HWR_14 4y agoI am trying to understand why "cheap internet access" isn't a political goal that could be achieved but inflation could be?
- pmoriarty 4y ago> > A privatized internet will always amount to the rule of the many by the few > Giving control to the government is rather explicitly giving control to the few There's no clear distinction between the government and corporations. It's an open secret in politics that government jobs are a revolving door to/from industry. Corporate executives frequently go in to politics, and when politicians retire they often get cushy, high paying jobs at the very corporations they benefited while in office. They don't have to be outright bribed while in office (though it's not unknown for that to happen), but they know they'll be handsomely rewarded once they leave. That's not to mention them or their family members investing in companies they know will benefit from their actions while in office. So if you're against concentration of power in the hands of government then you should also be against concentration of power in the hands of corporations, and vice-versa.
- eterevsky 4y ago> Corporate executives frequently go in to politics, and when politicians retire they often get cushy, high paying jobs This can explained by some benign reasons: both political and management jobs require similar skillsets, like leadership, charisma, speaking publicly and so on. So it makes sense that same people could do both. Furthermore, if a political position involves regulating a certain industry, a person taking it has to have expertise in that industry, which further makes it more approachable for people from the industry.
- aaronsimpson 4y agoNot enough people realize this. I was reading Obama's memoir recently and he mentioned this exact concept during the financial crisis, where everyone wanted him to publicly skewer the big banks and talk trash on their CEOs. The problem is, those same big banks are (1) the ones he's trying to convince to re-invest back into the market and stimulate the economy and (2) probably the ones most knowledgable on how to rebuild and fix the financial sector. It's not corruption any more than the NFL hiring Peyton Manning as commissioner would be "corruption"
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- analognoise 4y ago>The government doesn't have the bandwidth to do what this quote implies they can. Oh right, they can organize world wars, figure out how to build Manhattan Projects, send people to the moon, invent the internet... But oh no, they don't have the bandwidth? Where did this ridiculous idea come from, and why is it parroted so often? The internet is a joke compared to what the government can do. It's part of a long term trend for people to actively work against successful government projects, then use the resulting failure to try to privatize that which should be public.
- smolder 4y ago"The government" is tiered. A move towards local (e.g. county or city level) control of things like broadband has so far on average been very successful. Maybe even stuff like social networks should be locally run. I'd love to see some city or county level fediverse instances pop up to tie in with locally run broadband. Maybe some craigslist-like personals ad boards and other services would be good, too. In that case, if it sucks, you can stand a chance at politically influencing the state of things, or move somewhere where it doesn't suck. Over-consolidation is bad. Things that don't strictly require nation-sized central authorities to do should not be controlled by nation-sized central authorities. Throwing up our hands and accepting the status quo because government is corrupt is not something anyone should be advocating for. The government is still the battleground whether it's corrupt or not. Corrupt officials need to be named and shamed. People who claim not to see a problem or who think it's not worth addressing need to be moved out of the way or convinced otherwise.
- bombcar 4y ago> "The government" is tiered. A move towards local (e.g. county or city level) control of things like broadband has so far on average been very successful. Maybe even stuff like social networks should be locally run. I'd love to see some city or county level fediverse instances pop up to tie in with locally run broadband. Maybe some craigslist-like personals ad boards and other services would be good, too. This is the concept of Subsidiarity [9537] - "the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level". In practice this would mean things like the last mile broadband should be handled by the town or neighborhood, the links to the main city in the area by the county, the links to the biggest cities by the state, and the international links by the federal government (roughly). Same can be applied to many things, and it does add inefficiency to the world, but not much, and prevents giant centralization and the issues that come with it. It also becomes much easier to fix things as the issue is most likely at a lower level. If everyone in the town wants faster Internet, they can just do it without having to negotiate with a massive company or government. [9537]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidiarity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidiarity
- avivo 4y agoThere actually is a way to give devolve power away from both the government and private companies. Details here: https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/towards-platform-democracy-policymaking-beyond-corporate-ceos-and-partisan-pressure https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/towards-platform-de... Essentially get a representative sample of the population, pay them and train them up (through neutral 3rd parties), and have the make the ultimate calls. This isn't a crazy new idea; it's been done around the world for many complex and controversial issues. Here's a video from the Economist on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UcFQ-eDhTk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UcFQ-eDhTk and here's examples of uses of this approach around the world https://www.oecd.org/gov/innovative-citizen-participation-and-new-democratic-institutions-339306da-en.htm https://www.oecd.org/gov/innovative-citizen-participation-an...
- bombcar 4y agoGreat, just have the neutral 3rd parties do the decisions. If you have those, you have everything! But "getting those" is the whole problem.
- kwatsonafter 4y agoJust chiming in to say that I concur with your reply here; this article seems to be missing the fundamental point which is, "when/where do experts capable of avid citizenship come from?" It's worth noting that this can be reduced to, "how can you make the public more well informed and capable of mediating and governing itself?"
- uncomputation 4y agoThis argument is completely harpooned by the fact that the number one threat to the internet in recent memory was the repeal of net neutrality which was pushed for and funded by big ISP corporations. If the pushback for net neutrality is any indicator, a huge number of people would use, if not their vote, then their voice to defend the public internet. History has shown time and time again that corporations have perverse incentives for public utilities, electricity for example. Privatizing the electrical grid was a complete disaster for Texas. Yet we seem to keep having to relearn this lesson because people think “government bad, corporation good.”
- bombcar 4y agoUm, net neutrality lost and so the current internet is on fire and ceased to work. https://www.broadbandsearch.net/blog/net-neutrality#post-navigation-3 https://www.broadbandsearch.net/blog/net-neutrality#post-nav...
- guelo 4y agoISPs are boiling the frog slowly on net neutrality because they don't want a backlash. But behind the scenes business deals are being made between content providers and ISPs. Thanks to Ajit Pai we also don't get to see any details about those business deals. Your ISP is throttling content and you have no idea.