13 ms·
How Many Tracks Do Train Stations Need?
- morninglight 4y agoNagoya station in Japan has a Track 0 that runs to Kariya. Tracks in most of the world's train stations are numbered starting from Track 1. Has anyone seen another Track 0? Where?
- semanticist 4y agoHaymarket Station in Edinburgh has a platform 0 that was added to the side of platform 1 during an expansion. It's the only platform/track that terminates at the station, all the others go through the tunnel to Waverley Station.
- arethuza 4y agoI used Haymarket for years and had never noticed that - shows how observant I am! However, I was in Kings Cross yesterday and was amused when I saw a sign for platforms 0 to 8.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaheyy 4y agoLidcombe station in NSW Australia has a platform 0. It happened when a new platform for an Olympic Park shuttle was added on the “up” side of the station (which gets numbered starting from 1) and for one reason or another the existing platforms were not renumbered.
- pintxo 4y agoFor once, you‘d need to synchronize the actual track renumbering with the (yearly?) train schedule update as track numbers usually are part of the schedule.
- Svip 4y agoTølløse station in Denmark. Which is for the local train, as tracks 1 and 2 are for the regional trains. I assume the local train track was added later, and was next to track 1, so rather than naming it track 3 or 11 (as they sometimes do to highlight an "in between track"), they went for track 0. There is a bunch of pictures here[0], and you can spot in some of them where it says "Spor 0". But I assume "track 0" isn't _that_ uncommon after all. Which leads me to wonder whether a "track -1" exists anywhere. [0] https://www.danskestationer.dk/htj/toelloese.php https://www.danskestationer.dk/htj/toelloese.php
- orthoxerox 4y agoI don't know about track, but the Northern river terminal in Moscow has a negative pier. The main piers are numbered 1 to 17, but there are two discount piers outside the main area, which are numbered -1 and 0.
- schroeding 4y agoGeoff Marshall and Matt Parker made a video where they visited every track 0 in the UK: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SPQRNmXVP8s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SPQRNmXVP8s
- morninglight 4y agoThanks for the link. All these replies are great, but the video from Geoff and Matt is an epitome of modern British communication. They really did stop at nothing!
- EdSchouten 4y agoAt Nijmegen central station in the Netherlands , track 1 is preceded by 35, even though the station only has a handful of tracks. I’m not making that up. https://indebuurt.nl/nijmegen/genieten-van/mysteries/nijmeegse-mysteries-spoor-35-op-station-nijmegen~8876/ https://indebuurt.nl/nijmegen/genieten-van/mysteries/nijmeeg...
- dEnigma 4y agoLinz central station in Austria also has platforms/tracks 21 and 22 before 1, and then goes up to 8 from there, I think
- Fnoord 4y agoIn Sittard, The Netherlands track 1 was preceeded by track 20 (kopspoor with buffer stop). Track 20 being the train to Kerkrade and the other tracks being for other trains (mainly but not solely ICs). One such (obvious) exception is OK with me. Its annoying when every train station has random track numbers though.
- Someone 4y agoIt’s not random. The numbers aren’t only used for passengers, but also for train personnel, and because of that not only cover the train station, but also tracks in the neighborhood. Tracks are numbered logically or at least start out that way, but in some stations, many tracks don’t border a passenger platform (which freight trains don’t need) If there’s a shunting yard nearby, there can be many such tracks. Looking at http://www.sporenplan.nl/html_de/sporenplan/ns/ns_65/nm.html http://www.sporenplan.nl/html_de/sporenplan/ns/ns_65/nm.html, that may be the case for Nijmegen. I don’t know what rules they use for renumbering tracks, but they must weigh the cost of redocumenting things and retraining personnel (likely the trickier part. Some of them may have known the track numbers for decades, so reassigning number to make them easier to learn can be risky. From a safety viewpoint, moving from 1,2,3… to A,B,C… may be a better option) against the training of future employees.
- Tijdreiziger 4y ago
- sofixa 4y ago> Tracks in most of the world's train stations are numbered starting from Track 1 In France sometimes tracks aren't numbered but lettered. Sometimes they're both - e.g. the same train station can have tracks A, B, 1, 2, 3, 4 ( e.g. Avignon TGV, where 1 and 4 are for stopping high speed trains, 2,3 are for passing through high speed trains, and A(maybe also B, don't remember) is a separate track terminating at that station for the commuter rail link to Avignon's main railway station). Sometimes there are weird likes like only two tracks, one is 1bis, the other A. Or 1 and 1bis. Usually it's related to the historical evolution of the train station ( e.g. in the 1/1bis case it was a single track station which was expanded).
- ultra2d 4y agoBergamo has a track '1 west' hidden away in a dark corner. They should have called it track 0 as that would be less confusing to non-locals.
- Findecanor 4y agoBologna Centrale has numbered tracks 1,2,3.. and different number series for both "West" and "East" tracks, with "1 West" being the leftmost of a number of tracks side-by-side. When I was there the first time, of course we waited at the wrong platform and missed our train.
- mschuster91 4y agoSwitzerland and Denmark have one. [1] [1] https://www.aargauerzeitung.ch/panorama/vermischtes/in-aarau-gibt-es-das-einzige-gleis-null-der-schweiz-ld.1978907 https://www.aargauerzeitung.ch/panorama/vermischtes/in-aarau...
- dbuxton 4y agoThere’s one to the right of Platform 1 at Kings Cross, London
- johannes1234321 4y agohttps://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1jpK https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1jpK this openstreetmap query finds a few (and probably be improved to find a few more)
- ourlordcaffeine 4y agoCardiff central station has a platform 0
- kurthr 4y agoJust a personal anecdote, but I was waiting for a train in Osaka with a friend. It arrived 2 minutes before our departure time so we got on. Then it announced departure 1 minute before our departure time... we looked at each other and jumped at the door with it closing on us and our luggage. With a nasty look from the other people on the train we got off... and waited another minute until our train arrived. The trains in Tokyo all seem to have nice new signs with upcoming train info next to each of the tracks. That makes it much harder to get on the wrong one. Also, google maps works disturbingly well for Tokyo subways.
- CydeWeys 4y ago> Also, google maps works disturbingly well for Tokyo subways. Tokyo is a large engineering office for Google (and the first in Asia IIRC). This probably explains it.
- Semaphor 4y ago> The trains in Tokyo all seem to have nice new signs with upcoming train info next to each of the tracks. It’s the same in Germany. Something like this [0] is at pretty much every train station nowadays, even the small ones. [0]: https://sbahn.berlin/fileadmin/_processed_/d/b/csm_Ring_anzeige_mg_1682_byDavidUlrich-035_454e4a2981.jpg https://sbahn.berlin/fileadmin/_processed_/d/b/csm_Ring_anze...
- 411111111111111 4y agoYeah, the upcoming trains are usually shown on these. There is a difference though: In Germany the train will usually be 10++ minutes late or straight up never show up (at least for long distance travel).
- Semaphor 4y agoThat’s probably why they focused so much on getting digital signage up :D
- 4y ago
- tormeh 4y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding, but as far as I've gathered, the main source of unreliability is old and shitty signaling systems. Found it odd that signaling wasn't mentioned.
- innocenat 4y agoI don't know about "shitty" but old signalling system isn't a problem if well maintained. Japan Chuou line mentioned in the article is still on the old ATS-P system and it runs 28 train per hour. Even older ATS-S system in Osaka runs 16 train per hour on the inner track of the Tokaido line. The NY Subway made a big fuss of CBTC and that it would allow them to run more train more reliably than their current old ATS system, which I find funny looking at various line in Japan. In fact, CBTC in Japan is mostly planned for rural line with infrequent service so the amount of infrastructure (track circuit, etc) are reduced
- bobthepanda 4y agoNot all of the NYC subway has ATS. The current signals being replaced by CBTC date from the 1930s, and are mechanically operated. They are literally historical relics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mjx3S3UjmnA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mjx3S3UjmnA
- PapaSpaceDelta 4y agoOn very busy urban systems, one major advantage of CBTC is that the signalling blocks (the section of line that only one train can be in at a time) can be smaller, since the possibility of a driver failing to notice a red signal can be discounted. This increases the number of trains that can be run on the same line.
- innocenat 4y agoAnd Japan run 28 train per hour with non-CBTC block, and that's my point. You can't really get much higher than that.
- 4y ago
- ojii 4y agoYou can get pretty far with four terminal tracks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ge81gKqtvE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ge81gKqtvE
- innocenat 4y agoShinkansen isn't really designed for short dwell time. And since it's Tokyo terminal, the train also need to be cleaned. For commuter train, 15 train per hour is easily doable with 2 tracks.
- sofixa 4y agoA minor nitpick: > The biggest required investments for this are electrification and level boarding. Both have many benefits other than schedule reliability, and are underrated in Europe and even more underrated in the United States. Neither is underrated in Europe. Both are the norm on new projects, and almost all heavy duty old lines have been upgraded to at least be electrified. However the costs associated are often astronomical ( and might require closing the line for extended periods of time) so for some of the rest it's done piecemeal.
- ssl232 4y agoIn Scotland the electrification of part of the (200 year old) network involved rebuilding every car and foot bridge and tunnel along the route to add enough spare height for the overhead wires. It's one downside to being "first" to build widespread railways - with the initial huge investment made in Victorian era when trains were single decked and run on coal, the room for expansion was limited. The good fortune Britain has had in avoiding real destruction of infrastructure in war has also meant there hasn't been much opportunity to rebuild having learned lessons since the Victorian era (separate cycle lanes? Hah). Meanwhile, in Hannover for instance, U-Bahn stations were built in the bomb craters in the city center - making use of the "free" excavation. Obviously not saying war or coming later to the party are good things, but it's one of those ironies of humanity.
- CalRobert 4y agoFunny you should mention cycle lanes - in the 1930's Britain had a fantastic network of cycle highways, which they let fall in to disrepair https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/britain-forgotten-1930s-bike-network https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/britain-forgotten-1930...
- steve_gh 4y agoThere is an interesting development going on to electrify some of the UK rail lines - an OverHead Line (OHL) - battery hybrid system. The idea is that you have a standard electrified OHL system where it is easy and cheap (!!!) to install. Places whee you can't put it easily, such as under bridges, through tunnels etc, you don't. You have some (small-ish) battery capability in the train which recharges from the OHL system, and use that in the areas where the OHL hasn't been installed.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI just want to say that trains are I've of the great amazing features of civilization. I look at them like Plato might look at electricity. It is a wonder.
- pvsukale3 4y agoIndian railways is really good at managing much higher traffic at lower number of platforms and tracks in general. New infra upgrades are much slow and expensive. So at a majority of high traffic stations, track sections IR has to do a really tight exercise of managing schedules and maintenance. They also have recently improved on time performance. It is not Japan like or anything, but it is getting better.
- ssl232 4y agoIndian Railway must have some fascinating stories. It's absolutely ginormous and historic. Isn't it also the largest employer in India, which must put it in the millions? The fact it works at all shows there must be something special about its structure.
- pvsukale3 4y agoYes, IR is largest employer employing 1.54 million people. There has been a lot of automation in signalling, switching recently, because of which we will see number of employees going down in near future. But beyond this, yes it is a humungous project that keeps humming without major glitches. Supported by a lot of workers on the ground doing tasks like track inspections, cleaning, maintenance day and night.
- euroderf 4y agoI remember reading a factoid that at any given time, 10% of the population of India is on a train. Is this for real ? Is this possible ?
- pvsukale3 4y agoI am not sure about that factoid, but before pandemic in FY 2019-20 IR did 8.08 Billion trips. IR runs in losses for passenger service, it makes up for those losses in freight service. ref: https://indianrailways.gov.in/railwayboard/uploads/directorate/finance_budget/Budget_2021-22/Statement-Railway-Receipts-Expenditure-Budget-2021-22.pdf https://indianrailways.gov.in/railwayboard/uploads/directora...
- Jaruzel 4y agoBased on my observations at London Bridge station, it's clearly always more than are ever built, even after its recent redesign. :(
- baybal2 4y agoIn China, it's 6-8 per a large city, and up to 12 in a megacity.
- londons_explore 4y ago> brick wall rule It's time we got rid of this. The train in front of you won't suddenly turn into a brick wall. The quickest it will ever slow down is with its emergency brakes. And if it applies it's emergency brakes, then your train should also apply your emergency brakes. So the minimum headway is the reaction time (milliseconds if automatic) plus the worst-case difference in performance between the brakes. Using that, you can get headways down to a few seconds.
- krisoft 4y ago> The quickest it will ever slow down is with its emergency brakes. What about derailments? Can a derailment lead to a higher deceleration than the emergency brakes are able to produce? (I don’t know the answer, genuinely curious.) > So the minimum headway is the reaction time (milliseconds if automatic) How do the following train detects that the leader train is emergency breaking? Is it based on trackside sensors, or some train-to-train communication?
- londons_explore 4y ago> Can a derailment lead to a higher deceleration than the emergency brakes are able to produce? Yes. But a derailment of one carriage of a 5 carriage train will already likely cause the derailment of the other carriages, and in my proposal the carriages of the train behind. Derailments at speed are already typically deadly. > How do the following train detects that the leader train is emergency breaking? I would use train 2 train communication to say "I am not emergency braking" every 1 millisecond. If more than a few of these messages aren't received, then you have to assume the train in front is emergency braking, and act accordingly. A design like that is important because infrastructure failures are frequently coincident - eg. power loss causes signalling and comms failure due to an untested UPS.
- londons_explore 4y agoIn a more detailed design, you would have every train publish a "movement plan" every few milliseconds. The plan contains the current location (with uncertainty bounds), and future locations. The plan also contains alternate future locations that could happen in various emergency or failure situations - and one of those is to apply the emergency brakes. A system checks each plan against the plans of all other trains, and approves them if they are non-colliding. The 'alternate' plans can overlap only if to do so indicates independant failures must have occurred - for example the brakes of train 1 fail at the same time as the traction motor of train 2 gets stuck on max, and comms fail. Track infrastructure such as signals and points would also submit plans - so that for example a set of points can prevent any trains passing over while it isn't in a safe locked state. All trains must then follow one of the plans they have approved. If comms fail and they can't get a new plan approved, they must still follow an approved plan - which means they are guaranteed not to collide with any other train. All plans would be signed with timestamps (to prevent someone maliciously changing them to cause an accident), and would normally be delivered by dedicated rail infrastructure, but could be delivered by 3g/4g/wifi in an emergency. Manual plans could also be entered and distributed, for example via USB stick, for maintenance - such plans would say "I have access to this huge segment of track, and nobody else may enter".
- Lammy 4y ago> It is bad enough that Germany is keeping some outer regional rail branches in the exurbs of Berlin and Munich unwired; that New York has not fully electrified is unconscionable. I think about this a lot every time I see the glacial pace of the ongoing electrification work for Caltrain on the SF peninsula — "studied" since 1992, groundbreaking in 2017, and hopefully in service by 2025 if there are no additional delays: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrification_of_Caltrain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrification_of_Caltrain Electric motive power was novel in 1895 when the B&O electrified part of the Baltimore Belt Line, but we should be good at it by now! For comparison, the PRR was able to electrify their line from New York City to Washington D.C (225 track-miles, 1928–1935) in roughly the same amount of time it will take Caltrain to build out their 77 track-miles, at which time 90 years will have passed since GG1s were zooming up and down the NEC at 100mph: https://thebhc.org/sites/default/files/beh/BEHprint/v009/p0143-p0151.pdf https://thebhc.org/sites/default/files/beh/BEHprint/v009/p01... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amtrak%27s_25_Hz_traction_power_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amtrak%27s_25_Hz_traction_powe... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pennsylvania_Railroad_class_GG1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pennsylvania_Railroad_class_GG...
- lbriner 4y agoI don't know what physical issues exist but there are immense challenges with these projects, not least of which is that you often have to do most or all of the work before you can get any benefit. You then have old trains that need replacing as well, driver training, maintenance training etc. Oh, and you also need to find a workforce of several thousand skilled workers and mostly do the work at night so that you can still run a train service. In the UK, they recently electrified a lot of the Great Western mainline and decided to go with a cheaper/quieter type of installation method - auger drills iirc - for the pillars (why not), but at certain points, they started finding large granite boulders from the original railway construction which wouldn't be drilled, which meant new plans, new equipment, new training and loads of cap-ex when they were still years away from service. They also found tonnes of electrical system conflicts which meant whole signalling systems being replaced even before they had life-expired. I love trains and I love modernisation but most of us underestimate the enormous amount of work involved in an upgrade like this.
- steve_gh 4y agoReally good clear explanation of the issues. The group I work in (Amey Consulting) have built a couple of systems for Network Rail here in the UK, called Quartz and Cosmo. These are analytic systems examine rail delays and delay propagation, especially sub-threshold delays (in the UK delays over a threshold - 2 mins IIRC) have to be reported, but those under 2 mins don't. We started looking at sub-threshold delays a few years ago, and have understood how these small delays build and propagate through the network, affecting multiple services. We are always recruiting (UK - main sites London and Manchester, some folk in Birmingham too) - so if you have an interest in applying data science to infrastructure have a look here: https://www.amey.co.uk/what-we-do/amey-consulting/careers-with-amey-consulting/careers-in-advisory-analytics https://www.amey.co.uk/what-we-do/amey-consulting/careers-wi..., or DM me
- zelos 4y agoOut of interest, what kind of state is software engineering in the rail industry in? Watching a documentary about Crossrail the other day their testing seemed to consist of a driver manually driving a simulator in real-time through signals and recording when buttons don't work etc. I was kind of hoping that was just a misrepresentation.
- Milner08 4y agoI assume part of the reason for doing it like that is that it gives user feedback for the systems rather than just following what ever assumptions they put in place for their automated testing. It also servers to be driver training, which is very important and takes a long time, so if they can start sooner its probably a good thing.
- lbriner 4y agoI saw the same program and was cringing. "The train has crashed" now meaning its software has crashed and it needs a reboot. It is not frightening that it might physically crash the train, which I assume has crazy numbers of failsafes but more about the terrible reliability of some software which has unexpectedly crashed despite whatever modelling/testing was already carried out. If it is that unreliable, it has to have loads of failsafes which means lots of unexpected failures. At least with older trains, you could usually move the train in emergency, even if slowly, but having the software tell you that you can't close the doors or pull away is really bad. There were also issues with trains missing from the passenger information systems and even worse, a broken down train on the boundary between TfL-controlled and Network Rail-controlled lines and it sounded like no-one knew what to do and it caused 2 hours of messing around.
- Reason077 4y agoFrom the article: > “It is bad enough that Germany is keeping some outer regional rail branches in the exurbs of Berlin and Munich unwired; that New York has not fully electrified is unconscionable.” There is a strong argument that battery-electric trains will replace the need for overhead electrification on shorter routes and branch lines. Track electrification can be very expensive, and hard to justify on less-busy lines. But with batteries, a train can charge while running on an electrified trunk line, then continue onto smaller branch lines.
- mike_hock 4y agoThere's a strong counter-argument that batteries large enough to power entire trains are also expensive to produce and maintain, especially when battery prices shoot up due to lithium scarcity, and that's not even mentioning the massive carbon footprint of producing those batteries. Diesel-electric trains are probably better emissions-wise.
- Reason077 4y ago> “Diesel-electric trains are probably better emissions-wise.” Definitely not!
- loonster 4y agoProbably safer in the event of a crash or mechanical failure. I would not like to see what electrical fire would look like from a lithium battery big enough to power s train.
- Reason077 4y agoElectric buses in Europe and China usually use LFP chemistry, because it's cheap(er) and much safer in a crash or fire because it's not prone to thermal runaway. Electric passenger trains will likely be using the same, or other stable li-ion chemistries rather than the more volatile nickel-based ones.
- 4y ago
- lbriner 4y agoA couple of extra points. The article alludes to the need for through tracks although it is perhaps not immediately obvious that this can also be used for main "terminal" stations. In Germany, very few trains terminate in the Hauptbahnhofs (main stations) but instead will then move out, often to another large station or depot outside of the city centre. This allows high traffic into the main stations without blocking them up while cleaning/turning round. Another issue about level loading is made but it sounds like this is mainly related to the difference between a "road" at ground level needing steps vs a platform at carriage level. However, even in the UK where everywhere uses platforms, there are still issues with level due to the variation in track height related to ballast working so even "mostly level" can be a problem, particularly for wheelchairs and even done efficiently, loading these can easily take a minute or more. Thirdly, at least in the UK, it isn't just the build up of subtle delays that can be an issue but small problems creating large delays. The other week, trains were delayed and cancelled for hours (for some reason) because a trespasser was seen on the main line and needed to be found by the police. One relatively small and common occurance affected 1000s of travellers. A single signal problem, a broken rail, failed point etc. This means that you could in theory run e.g. Kings Cross Station with fewer platforms but as soon as there is a problem, people don't want to sit on a train for 2 hours somewhere on the line. Having more platforms gives you that flexibility.
- bombcar 4y agoAlso, "equal level" can have issues if you're serving multiple trainsets - they may all be at platform height but some are narrower than others, resulting in a platform gap that can be difficult to navigate. If the trainsets are all identical and the platforms are straight, you can get a very, very narrow gap (easily navigated by a wheelchair alone).
- twobitshifter 4y agoThe article doesn’t understand dwell times at Penn Station or the capacity limitations there. For example: * Penn Station Dwells are not limited by passenger movement at doors. It’s not a metro, go and watch trains being loaded. * Escalators constrain the rate at which people can actually reach the platforms * These escalators need to switch direction when a train arrives, meaning multiple arrivals and departures are not simultaneously supported. * The tracks do not support all operators and the station design divides Amtrak from LIRR * Some tracks do not support full train lengths * Not all tracks in the station are through tracks * Trains are terminating at NYP which requires a longer process of ensuring no passengers are still on on board before leaving for the yard. * It’s not only the north and east river tunnels, there is an entrance from the Empire line for Amtrak and separate paths to the WSSY for LIRR, not to mention train storage within Penn in the ACDE yards. * Engineers walk the entire length of the train when a trip reverses direction. This takes a long time. The OP mentions through-running solution, but doesn’t point out the problems with it, namely incompatible equipment and giving an entirely different agency access to your multimillion dollar trains. I could go on and on.
- jcranmer 4y ago> Escalators constrain the rate at which people can actually reach the platforms Let people wait on the platform as the train arrives. This is something that basically every train operator but Amtrak does. > The tracks do not support all operators and the station design divides Amtrak from LIRR This isn't a problem... trains in most stations are already basically scheduled to an individual platform anyways. > Trains are terminating at NYP which requires a longer process of ensuring no passengers are still on on board before leaving for the yard. Through-run trains. Yes, this requires cracking some heads at NJT and LIRR (and MTA before much longer). Is it really worth spending billions of dollars to avoid having to resolve agency turf fights?
- twobitshifter 4y agoThe platforms are not large enough to support people waiting at the same time as the train is unloading and are full of columns. There are safety concerns in not being able to evacuate passengers quickly enough in the event of an emergency via narrow escalators. Through running NJ Transit onto LIRR is through running AC trains onto a DC network. That is billions. In addition, nobody from NJ wants to go to Long Island and vice versa, and most NJ Trains run-through the station in the same direction already to be stored at Sunnyside. The same is true of LIRR, they go into the west side yard as a straight move. The NJ trains that don’t run to SSY are usually making use of the stub end tracks at Penn where through running isn’t an option.
- 323 4y agoChina Wuhan station with 50 bullet trains tracks picture: https://i.imgur.com/sWxR4DU.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/sWxR4DU.jpeg
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoThat is no passenger station, as is visible by the missing platforms. That is part of a servicing yard. edit: Not meaning to say they don't have giant stations, but the passenger parts don't look like this.
- winReInstall 4y ago2- one for the train to pass through and another for wagons with arriving to decelerate and another wagon with departing to accelerate and catch up with the passing through train..
- mason55 4y ago> Good operations can substitute for station size, and it’s always cheaper to get the system to be more reliable than to build more tracks in city center. The main problem here is one of politics and human attention span. It’s easier to drum up a bunch of support towards a construction project. It’s visible, some politicians get credit for it, and you can have a campaign that builds excitement to a crescendo before people move on to something else. Good operations are invisible because everything operates as the margins and gets small wins. No one gets credit. If they slip just a little then no one notices, so you can borrow a little from operations to find something more visible, and it’s a boil the frog situation. And, finally, people just don’t have the attention span for caring about long-term operations. I don’t know the solution and I’m not saying the above is good, but any solutions that don’t attempt to address the human and political aspects of public works are going to have trouble. That was THE reason imo that Andy Byford was so promising as head of NYCTA - he seemed to be someone who would focus on the pragmatic human aspects. Sadly Cuomo made sure Byford had no chance of success.