2 ms·
It's often impossible to separate the content of the message from the tone. Back when I was a student, there was a professor emeritus of communications who lik
by jltsiren 4y ago
It's often impossible to separate the content of the message from the tone.
Back when I was a student, there was a professor emeritus of communications who liked to say things like "communication usually fails, except by accident". The idea was that if you intend to say something but many people interpret it otherwise, that was you failure to communicate. Musk is certainly smart enough to realize that his tone changes the meaning of what he says, but he keeps doing it anyway. That makes him a kind of a troll.
The thing with trolls is that people often don't like them. They may barely tolerate trolls they agree with and actively hate ones they disagree with.
Musk reminds me of another person: a former communist (of the minority faction who supported the USSR) who later made a 180-degree turn and became a successful investment banker. He is one of the richest people in Finland who didn't inherit their fortune, and he is probably also one of the most hated people in the country. And he genuinely enjoys trolling. Often when business leaders or right-wing ideologists have something that needs saying but can't be said aloud, they let him say it.
- anitil 4y ago> "communication usually fails, except by accident" I feel like I don't understand this. Is the idea that you need to try very hard to communicate well?
- bcbrown 4y ago> Back when I was a student, there was a professor emeritus of communications who liked to say things like "communication usually fails, except by accident". Are you talking about Osmo A. Wiio? https://jkorpela.fi/wiio.html https://jkorpela.fi/wiio.html
- jltsiren 4y agoThat's him. His "laws" probably arose from his frustrations when he was in the parliament, and he didn't intend anyone to take them too seriously. Today, as far as I understand, people who are trying to be serious communications professionals approach the same issues from a constructive angle. They try to minimize the chances for misunderstanding, which leads to those bland and thoroughly vetted corporate communications.