2 ms·
> There's no fundamental problem making a statement that this expected lifetime is short for new things, even if some fraction of those new things will last a l
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> There's no fundamental problem making a statement that this expected lifetime is short for new things, even if some fraction of those new things will last a long time, right?
Everything that's new in the pool might be better than everything that's old.
All you can say about the old stuff is that it was better (by some metric(s)) than anything it had to compete with so far.
But you can't say anything about the new stuff. Sure, statistically it is likely that it will some blend of bad, middling and good, but you don't actually know the mix, or which term describes which items, until after the selection process (i.e. time) has taken place.
- feral 4y agoAbsolutely there are real situations where the new stuff is going to last longer than the old stuff, even the old stuff that's been through a selection process. E.g. modern manufacturing techniques have improved overall longevity of all 2022 models. But I think you are outside the Lindy effect model at that point. To put this in the example of the original post: The author says visual studio code is expected to last less time than VIM. You could counter by saying: "hey, maybe, uh, the rise of Product Management as a discipline has meant that modern software overall will have longer lifetimes, and hence it's not fair to guess that VIM will outlive VSCode". And that'd be a fine position. But imo the right way to frame that isn't "the author did an incorrect logical inversion of the Lindy effect model"; rather it would be "I don't think the Lindy effect model applies to this domain". (No one is saying the Lindy model is universal.) I guess you could say you want to apply it only within a given year of software; so, we're happy to look backwards and apply the Lindy model to software written in 2011, but we've no idea how to think about the lifespan of software written in 2022, and aren't allowed make any inferences from software written before 2022. That's fine, but that's an additional constraint we've added, is outside the Lindy model, and, really, we're in "all models are wrong, some are useful" territory here, where I'd ask "is it really useful to throw away all that previous data? Wouldn't it be a better starting point to use the lifetimes of previous years as at least a prior?" And if you grant that, then I think theres no logical error here.
- coldtea 4y ago>Everything that's new in the pool might be better than everything that's old. It "might", but the empirical observation behind the Lindy effect points that this is unlikely (if we take "better" to mean "more fit to live and grow old and still used"). Sure, we haven't seen the new things develop yet. But we have seen that most new things dont survice time: the things that survive are a small subset of each "new things" (say, vi and emacs, and not one of 100+ 70s programming editors).