3 ms·
.NET PRs sit unmerged for years if they're not a priority for MSFT. I'm glad it works well sometimes and that MSFT seems to care about .NET on Linux, but it's
by loeg 4y ago
.NET PRs sit unmerged for years if they're not a priority for MSFT. I'm glad it works well sometimes and that MSFT seems to care about .NET on Linux, but it's not that open.
- tomnipotent 4y agoPoint out a major language that doesn't have a graveyard of PR's with similar stories.
- loeg 4y agoThe important distinction is that the PR graveyard of other projects isn't determined by MSFT's corporate priorities.
- tomnipotent 4y agoEvery major open source project is in no small way driven by the interests of corporate users, from which a non-trivial number of PR's and contributions come from. This is true from Linux and Postgres to Rust and Java.
- Genbox 4y agoOf course Microsoft only include functionality they want. Just like any other platform only include what they want. It is entirely their prerogative. Just because they don't include anything and everything other people want, it does not make them less open source. We are entirely free to fork the project, embed the change and compile our own binaries. You don't have to strongarm a change into upstream for that.
- ngc248 4y agoAny non-trivial OSS project has corporate sponsors on the steering committee and feature set/fixes are mostly driven by these corporate sponsors. So in the end it's all same.
- michaelcampbell 4y agoThat other languages may or may not be as bad as .NET does not make .NET any more or less bad.