4 ms·
> trying to isolate Desktop Linux as an irrelevant layer They're obviously doing that, but they don't really need to. Desktop Linux is its own enemy. 2 major
by oblio 4y ago
> trying to isolate Desktop Linux as an irrelevant layer
They're obviously doing that, but they don't really need to.
Desktop Linux is its own enemy. 2 major GUI toolkits, frequent upgrades to them, generally with breaking changes, multiple DEs, frequent upgrades to them, also with breaking changes, a full decades of bickering over a solution that solves actual end user and operator problems in a standardizing way (systemd), immature GUI software after decades (Gimp & co), chronic lack of funding because nobody can figure it out, etc.
I've been around Desktop Linux for more than 15 years. I still hear bad arguments I heard back in 2005.
Plus, the ship has sailed. Mobile devices outnumber desktops and laptops and will only continue to grow. The money surrounding mobile dwarfs desktop. And Linux lost on mobile, it was it best chance to become the primary platform somewhere. Android doesn't count. Android used a cheap and standard kernel with many drivers and plopped a million proprietary things on top that look nothing like Desktop Linux.
You'll say I'm wrong, yet I'm willing to bet $100 that this discussion will look the same way in 15 years.
- bayindirh 4y agoI'll just say that while Linux desktop is not perfect, I see much more people who're "assembling" their own environments to work at speeds I can't ever imagine. I'm part of a community who does amazing things with all these fragmented parts and assemble unimaginable things while staying productive and inventing new ways of work. The overall maturity of these small parts have not reversed the tide, but actually changed it a lot. As a macOS and Linux user for 15 years, I see that both can work seamlessly without much effort, but Windows built on a completely different platform, can't talk this language of protocols and composability natively, or work as seamlessly. Microsoft is right to feel threatened, because they're threatened by two sides.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> people who're "assembling" their own environments to work at speeds I can't ever imagine. People who assemble cars from scratch can accomplish things from that are amazing too, but only 0 1% of the population will ever want to do that.
- andi999 4y agoIt is 2022 and my suse linux smb share still doesnt work (after spending a few hours on it)
- bayindirh 4y agoThe thing is, some of these people are professional developers, and they inspire their peers and younger generations. There's an active momentum around that and it's definitely larger than 15 years ago.
- Ygg2 4y ago> I'm willing to bet $100 that this discussion will look the same way in 15 years I'm willing to take it, but only because I think there won't be a Linux in 15 years. And yeah. Android doesn't count. It's essentially an enclave that runs Dalvik programs. Linux basic assumptions about hardware don't hold on mobile. I think Linux is suffering from the Lisp curse. Because they never choosed a DE, there is endless splintering and re-invention of the wheel.
- bayindirh 4y ago> I'm willing to take it, but only because I think there won't be a Linux in 15 years. Let's see. I've added a reminder in my calendar with a link to this comment. > Because they never choosed a DE... But they created a Desktop Standard which allows every DE to behave the same where it matters. This unified a lot of things. So every DE is a shell and workflow with same underlying principles underside. Much like POSIX.
- Ygg2 4y ago> every DE to behave the same where it matters. Sure. Except the end user won't care. As end user I don't see it implements DS. I see that KDE has bug A and Gnome has bug B. Or KDE has feature C that Gnome doesn't have, and vice versa. All in all as user. No DE fits me because bugs and features are scattered around. E.g. Haiku did it right. You don't get to choose. It's baked into the OS
- deadbunny 4y ago> I see that KDE has bug A and Gnome has bug B. Or KDE has feature C that Gnome doesn't have, and vice versa. All in all as user. No DE fits me because bugs and features are scattered around. Can exactly the same not be said for Windows or MacOS? The difference being that you're basically locked into your choice with Windows/MacOS.
- bayindirh 4y ago> I see that KDE has bug A and Gnome has bug B. Or KDE has feature C that Gnome doesn't have, and vice versa. All in all as user. No DE fits me because bugs and features are scattered around. This is a "grass is greener over the fence" perspective. You can install apps for missing functionality or report bugs for the things you don't like. Except, Windows and macOS doesn't care about your bug reports, and some of the applications are not implemented on these systems because there's no financial incentive, and open source tools for these platforms are low quality. On the other hand, this modularity and composability does wonders in the Linux side. Linux DEs have feature levels. from LXDE to E17/XFCE to GNOME/KDE. People try, change, select and settle. Their most important settings are carried around. BTW, Qt/KDE guys allows amazing interoperability between GTK and Qt, regardless of your primary choice. So, after some time it's borderline nitpicking IMHO.
- zozbot234 4y ago> Android doesn't count. Android used a cheap and standard kernel with many drivers and plopped a million proprietary things on top that look nothing like Desktop Linux. Android is doing what every Linux embedded platform had been doing anyway. If anything, they're more open than the rest of the mobile/embedded space. It's not like e.g. OpenMoko looks more like Desktop Linux than Android does.
- bigpeopleareold 4y agoI think the goal of a single, quality "desktop linux" (or really a "free desktop", whatever kernel drives it), in the face of so much software diversity, is a lofty and improbable goal. The only issue probably is to match an ideal ("all IT departments use free software") with the practicality ("there is too much software diversity") with a fear that our current free software will fall out of favor with people seeking to work on and maintain software. It is unfortunate though that some free competitors to commercial software still struggle a bit. GIMP has worked fine for my rather simple image editing needs though. I think mobile is another beast, I'm not going there yet :D
- goodpoint 4y ago> 2 major GUI toolkits, ... multiple DEs, frequent upgrades to them, also with breaking changes, a full decades of bickering I was using Linux desktops 20 years ago and the same arguments were made. They were FUD and they still are. 1) having "too much" choice is nothing to complain about. 2) if you are a beginner, pick a stable distribution and your desktop will be completely immune to churn. Use it as a productivity tool, not as a playground. 3) if you are not a beginner you should be able to maintain a desktop. If you are busy, pick a simple DE and use it on a well know distribution.
- oblio 4y ago> They were FUD and they still are. Sorry, but take the horse blinders off. If this kind of criticism coming from a long time user of Linux desktop (not as active nowadays because work is Windows, but most of my work is done in IDEs, browsers and through Cygwin anyway), FOSS supporter, etc is FUD, then boy, are you going to have a hard time fighting Microsoft's or Apple's marketing teams. > 3) if you are not a beginner you should be able to maintain a desktop. And therein lies the main rub :-) Most people aren't able to "maintain a desktop". They don't really maintain either Windows, or MacOS. Most people are at best, "perpetual intermediates". Only a small fraction of users want or actually become power users. Most just trundle along trying their best to learn the least possible. And that's in every domain you can imagine. This is the thing that will condemn Desktop Linux to being a niche product. That's fine, up to a point.
- nerdix 4y ago> Most people aren't able to "maintain a desktop". He offered the solution though. If you are not able to "maintain a desktop" (either because you don't know how to, just don't want to, or don't have the time to, etc) then use a stable distro and accept the choices that were made for you. Thats not much different than just installing Windows or buying a Mac and accepting whatever decisions Microsoft/Apple made regarding how the desktop experience should be.
- goodpoint 4y agoWhat part of "pick a stable distribution" you did not understand? There's a good number of large tech companies providing Linux desktops for both tech-savy and other employees and it just works. > Sorry, but take the horse blinders off. Horse blinders? Ironic given how you looked only at half a sentence and ignored the rest.