3 ms·
> The purists demand they open source that proprietary software if they want it integrated into the open source. ...and as a result we got GPLv2, GPLv3, open I
by bayindirh 4y ago
> The purists demand they open source that proprietary software if they want it integrated into the open source.
...and as a result we got GPLv2, GPLv3, open Intel, AMD and Broadcom drivers. Lastly Paragon donated NTFS source code to kernel tree (...and probably many smaller examples I've forgot).
> The developer wants a compromise, but the purists won't allow it, so the developer is left to pick up their ball and go home.
Because purists don't care about the developer, they care about the user. MIT/permissive licenses are for developer freedom, but xGPL and other strong copyleft licenses are for users' freedom.
As a developer, I contribute to projects licensed permissively, but I license all my code with GPL, because I care about the user who's gonna use and explore it, and I don't want my handful of users to be locked out of developments.
> And it rarely ends with the developer open sourcing their proprietary system; they often just shrug and leave...
Again we have Intel, AMD/ATI, Broadcom, Logitech, Paragon software and others.
- nix23 4y ago>MIT/permissive licenses are for developer freedom, but xGPL and other strong copyleft licenses are for users' freedom. That's a bit to simple, being a user of FreeBSD i just want opensource, i would never use a FreeBSD-fork that is no open anymore, so i have even more freedom as a dev and a user. >Again we have Intel, AMD/ATI, The Intel driver is BSD and ATI is MIT, and i think it's absolutely logical for those two to take that license's, and not GPL. But please don't get me wrong, GPL2 is a great license.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoI think that the point here is that as a user, with MIT you may not have a choice. Of course, you would never choose a FreeBSD fork that isn't open. But if you buy a TV running a closed fork of FreeBSD you might never even find out. In that case, it was great for the developer: they were able to get a great OS for free. However, it was not great for the user: they get a closed OS that they can't patch, upgrade, downgrade, or change in any way that the developer doesn't approve of.
- nix23 4y agoOk look, i have that TV that run's Linux, they even send me a "CD" with all the source-code of linux/gnu of it, BUT there is that highly proprietary module loaded into the kernel, firmware and so on, so patching my TV is as easy as re-engineering a whole closed-source system. In theory the idea is great, in reality it makes nearly no difference.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- goodpoint 4y ago> MIT/permissive licenses are for developer freedom, but xGPL and other strong copyleft licenses are for users' freedom. GPLv3 also provides plenty of protection for developers unlike other licenses, especially around patents. Also, all developers are users of development tools and libraries.
- bayindirh 4y agoYes. All developers are users of the said tools, applications and libraries, but the reverse is not true. i.e. not all users are developers. So, while I see this is a clarification, I don't think what I've said is blatantly wrong.