3 ms·
> There are no paths to clean energy by 2050 without nuclear power. This is either stupidly wrong or stupidly right. Stupidly right, there's fairly new nuclea
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> There are no paths to clean energy by 2050 without nuclear power.
This is either stupidly wrong or stupidly right.
Stupidly right, there's fairly new nuclear plants in operation that there's no real reason to shut down, so will probably be running in 2050.
Stupidly wrong, it seems to be placing some entirely unwarranted implication that without nuclear we'd be lost, when most serious analysis agree that renewables will be about 80% of energy production, which doesn't really leave much room for nuclear to take all the credit.
IEA's net zero roadmap:
> In the net zero pathway, global energy demand in 2050 is around 8% smaller than today,
but it serves an economy more than twice as big and a population with 2 billion more
people. More efficient use of energy, resource efficiency and behavioural changes combine
to offset increases in demand for energy services as the world economy grows and access
to energy is extended to all.
> Instead of fossil fuels, the energy sector is based largely on renewable energy. Two-thirds
of total energy supply in 2050 is from wind, solar, bioenergy, geothermal and hydro energy.
Solar becomes the largest source, accounting for one-fifth of energy supplies. Solar PV
capacity increases 20-fold between now and 2050, and wind power 11-fold.
> Net zero means a huge decline in the use of fossil fuels. They fall from almost four-fifths of
total energy supply today to slightly over one-fifth by 2050. Fossil fuels that remain in 2050
are used in goods where the carbon is embodied in the product such as plastics, in facilities
fitted with CCUS, and in sectors where low-emissions technology options are scarce.
> Electricity accounts for almost 50% of total energy consumption in 2050. It plays a key
role across all sectors – from transport and buildings to industry – and is essential to produce
low-emissions fuels such as hydrogen. To achieve this, total electricity generation increases
over two-and-a-half-times between today and 2050. At the same time, no additional new final
investment decisions should be taken for new unabated coal plants, the least efficient coal
plants are phased out by 2030, and the remaining coal plants still in use by 2040 are retrofitted.
By 2050, almost 90% of electricity generation comes from renewable sources, with wind and
solar PV together accounting for nearly 70%. Most of the remainder comes from nuclear.
- BenoitP 4y ago> most serious analysis agree that renewables will be about 80% Well, let's see them; and see how much they rely on yet to be proven industrially new storage tech (and without humongous mining activity)
- rswskg 4y agoYep! Once battery storage doesn't pan out(and it won't currently for trucks), I see synth hydrocarbons picking up the transport slack. But that will require alot of energy..
- ncmncm 4y agoTrucks will operate on synthetic fuel, so no.
- ncmncm 4y agoThat is, synthetic ammonia. Which will be much cheaper than synthetic diesel.
- pfdietz 4y agoIf there is mass production of synfuels, that means mass production of hydrogen (which is either used directly as the synfuel, or used to make the synfuel). And as soon as there's mass hydrogen production, it's an ENORMOUS amount of dispatchable demand, which solves the intermittency problem of renewables (even if the hydrogen is never turned back into electricity.)
- user_7832 4y ago>Stupidly wrong, it seems to be placing some entirely unwarranted implication that without nuclear we'd be lost, when most serious analysis agree that renewables will be about 80% of energy production, which doesn't really leave much room for nuclear to take all the credit. >IEA's net zero roadmap... I'd like to make a slightly vague rebuttal to your slightly vague rebuttal (ofc not your fault if the IEA doesn't explicitly say anything about nuclear, not blaming you). The IPCC has said that nuclear is necessary if we want to hit our climate goals.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt gets a mention, just not a starring role: > By 2050, almost 90% of electricity generation comes from renewable sources, with wind and solar PV together accounting for nearly 70%. Most of the remainder comes from nuclear. So "no path to clean energy without solar" and "no path to clean energy without wind" are a bit more defensible, though in both cases, we'd just build more of the other one. "no path to clean energy without hydro"? Maybe, again we'd just build more solar and wind. So, if someone waves a wand and magically makes nuclear disappear (or just economically unattractive) then I think the our path is still fairly clear. No real need to take that path unless nuclear becomes much more relatively expensive, but it's definately an option, and possibly one we'll gladly take because it's cheaper.
- trashtester 4y ago> By 2050, almost 90% of electricity generation comes from renewable sources, with wind and solar PV together accounting for nearly 70%. Most of the remainder comes from nuclear. In other words, IPCC counts nuclear as "renewable"?
- pfdietz 4y agoNo, the "remainder" that is nuclear is the 10% that renewables don't cover. The renewables other than solar/wind are things like hydro, geothermal, and waste/biomass.
- SECProto 4y agoExpecting global energy consumption to drop 8% in the next 30 years (while also reducing fossil fuel usage to 20% and all of that with carbon capture and underground storage) is... hilariously unrealistic (or very pessimistic for overall energy usage trends). Here[1]'s a visualization of world energy usage over time. Here[2]'s a sketch I just made to show what the IEA apparently thinks will happen to get to net zero (per your post). Here[3]'s a tweet that looks at the IEA's other renewable energy forecasts over time (spoiler: they were laughably pessimistic, which doesn't instill confidence when they instead make a laughably optimistic forecast)... [1] https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption [2] https://imgur.com/a/xvkZSRi https://imgur.com/a/xvkZSRi [3] https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/1064529619951513600 https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/1064529619951513600
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's easily possible because most energy we produce today is wasted as heat when burning it and dumping the carbon into the atmosphere. Since we're going to stop doing that, by electrifying lots of things that currently burn fuel, we can achieve both goals at the same time. The text on top of the graph you cite says this: "Primary energy is calculated based on the 'substitution method' which takes account of the inefficiencies in fossil fuel production by converting non-fossil energy into the energy inputs required if they had the same conversion losses as fossil fuels." It would be clearer to reduce the fossil fuel amounts by that percentage, since we currely don't use that energy, and in fact expend more energy trying to get rid of it as waste heat in many cases. And, note the difference betwene energy and electricity, they say electricity will grow by nearly 3x ("To achieve this, total electricity generation increases over two-and-a-half-times between today and 2050"). You should look up recent graphs of renewable growth, with hydro seperated out, to see that your quick mock-up looks positively sedate by the recent standards of growth. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-renewables?tab=chart&country=~OWID_WRL https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-renewables?... global renewables including hydro. Solar and Wind are barely noticeable until 2000, when wind, then solar (in 2010) grow from nothing to octuple previous hydro within about a decade: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-solar?tab=chart&country=~OWID_WRL https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-solar?tab=c... https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-wind?tab=chart&country=~OWID_WRL https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-wind?tab=ch... They have an article about why this is occuring too: https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth I didn't choose IEA to demonstrate because they are the only outlier that support my point. My whole claim is that even the boring, cautious industry analysts are saying broadly the same thing. I think their assumptions about carbon capture are silly and more renewables will be built instead, but even their numbers make it clear than nuclear is a sideshow at best.