5 ms·
Some things worth bearing in mind. These studies come from the field of epidemiology, which is notorious for low quality studies that rely on flawed assumptions
by mike_hearn 4y ago
Some things worth bearing in mind. These studies come from the field of epidemiology, which is notorious for low quality studies that rely on flawed assumptions to create apocalyptic scenarios. Everything coming out of this field has to be assumed to be suspect until thoroughly vetted by outsiders.
At least, that's my personal belief. Let's do a quick literature review to check if there's disagreement with the claims of the researchers.
Firstly, are sperm counts actually falling at all? The article says:
"Sperm quantity and quality have dramatically declined across Western countries in recent decades, with research suggesting sperm counts have been more than halved in the space of 40 years."
But Tong2022 [1] says:
"Concerns regarding declining sperm counts have existed for over 50 years, and even predate the use of a standard means to assess semen characteristics ... in the field of reproduction, the contention that sperm counts are declining is not universally accepted and has been a hotly debated topic over the last several decades.1,5-9"
If they are falling, does it actually matter?
"... our review suggests that a decline in sperm counts does not necessarily translate to a decline in male fertility"
A New York Times report [2] on their study stated:
"Now a group of interdisciplinary researchers from Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology contend that fears of an impending Spermageddon have been vastly overstated. In a study published in May in the journal Human Fertility, they re-evaluated the 2017 review and found that it relied on flawed assumptions and failed to consider alternate explanations for the apparent decline of sperm ... even the data that passed muster was geographically sparse and uneven and often lacked basic criteria like the age of the men. Moreover, its authors took for granted that a single metric — sperm count — was an accurate predictor of male fertility and overall health ... no one knows what an “optimal” sperm count is ... as methodologies for counting had improved and been standardized since the 1980s, sperm counts had appeared to fall. In other words, it may simply be that earlier scientists were overcounting sperm."
A lot of this stuff originates in a 2017 meta-study by Dr Swan et al. Tom Chivers reviews Swan's book on the "spermogeddon" [3]:
"the book does not seem sensible. Because for Swan, everything causes fertility problems, not just phthalates. Sugar, beef, cycling, stress, watching TV, doing too much exercise, doing too little, eating the wrong diet; you can barely get out of bed in the morning without sabotaging your chance of having a baby ... I half expected her to say we ought to wear ray-shielded underpants ... She even suggests that the growth in intersex conditions and perhaps the rise of gender dysphoria, and even changes in gender identity, could be because of EDCs (and taking paracetamol in pregnancy!)
This hyperventilating about human extinction, and rolling everything bad into a ball labelled “fertility and phthalates”, makes no sense if you think Swan (a respected epidemiologist) is trying to give a dispassionate assessment of fertility issues. But she’s not. This is a polemic."
A key problem with Swan's argument is that she and others like her define fertility as how many babies women have. This makes it easy to draw a correlation between falling sperm counts and falling fertility, but eliminates the impact of free choice. Women prefer to have fewer children as their countries get richer and child mortality falls, but as far as these "respected epidemiologists" are concerned that's apparently out of scope.
[1] https://bcmj.org/sites/default/files/BCMJ_Vol64_No3_bcmd2b.pdf https://bcmj.org/sites/default/files/BCMJ_Vol64_No3_bcmd2b.p...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/04/health/sperm-fertility-reproduction-crisis.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/04/health/sperm-fertility-re...
[3] https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-truth-about-spermageddon/ https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-truth-about-spermageddon/
- sumy23 4y agoEven if sperm count doesn't impact overall male fertility, the fact that sperm count is declining potentially indicates some type of endocrine disruption. Also, your comment kind of glosses over the fact that though-to-be cause hormonal interference were found at levels 17 times what is considered safe in the median sample from the study.
- mike_hearn 4y agoThe point of the scientists quoted above is that those aren't safe assumptions. 1. Sperm count might not be falling at all. 2. If it is, that might be some sort of natural variation, or an effect rather than a cause (maybe sperm counts fall if you aren't regularly impregnating women, which is to some extent a social choice). 3. Even if there is a natural cause, it might not be chemicals. 4. Even if it is, that might not actually be a problem worth worrying about. "17 times what is considered safe" Considered safe by who? Epidemiologists?
- sumy23 4y ago> Considered safe by who? Epidemiologists? Did you read the paper? The authors specifically chose chemicals that have been shown to reduce male sperm counts. The hazard levels they chose were based on the observed effects on sperm production from those studies. We know these chemicals reduce sperm count and they are being found in high quantities in urine, so it doesn't seem likely that the measured decrease in sperm is due to measurement error or some other cause.
- mike_hearn 4y ago"The authors specifically chose chemicals that have been shown to reduce male sperm counts" No, they chose chemicals that predictive modelling claims would reduce male sperm counts. This is epidemiology remember, they hardly care about real experiments. From their cited paper Kortenkamp2020: "combinations of chemicals with different mechanisms of action are predicted that should result in cumulative effects. These predictions are then mapped against evidence from experimental mixture studies with relevant combinations" If we check the Table 2 RfD data to explore the citations, e.g. for the very first entry in the table, we find: "Due to variations in the no-observed adverse effect levels (NOAELs) in high confidence studies, possible reference doses ranged from 0.0001 to 0.0099 μg/kg/d. In choosing 0.003 μg/kg/d we struck a balance between caution suggested by studies at the lower end of the doses and the weight of evidence from studies with higher NOAEL. BPA exposures currently experienced by European populations and beyond are in excess of 0.003 μg/kg/d ... The precise mechanisms by which BPA affects semen quality are not resolved" So their figure for safe BPA exposure level is made up. The evidence gave them an enormously varied range of possibilities, and they picked one of the lowest values allowable given that evidence because they wanted to incorporate "caution", and - totally coincidentally - because that level would let them say that most Europeans are being exposed to dangerous levels (according to their made up estimate). They also have no idea how this is meant to work biologically, which raises the risk of a correlation=causation fallacy, and their direct evidence comes from studies on baby rats. They exclude experiments on adult rats because, well, who the hell knows, they don't explain that, and they then go to include epidemiological studies on adult men so it's not like there's anything meaningful behind that choice. One might ask whether this evidence tells us much about humans given the frequency with which cancer has been successfully cured in rats. So what about the evidence from people? "In adult men, the best timing of exposure measurements would be around 90 days before taking a semen sample, because spermatogenesis takes approximately 75 days, with an additional 12 days of maturation as the sperm travels through the epididymis. However, none of the eligible studies adopted such a timing. Instead, most studies collected urine samples for BPA measurements at the same time, or near the time of semen analysis" So their studies aren't measuring sperm counts at the right time and they know this, but use the data anyway. Where do they find these men? "These studies are case-control, cohort or cross-sectional with participants drawn from the general population, occupational cohorts, or couples from infertility clinics" Infertility clinics! With epidemiology papers it's always like this. We learned that from COVID. You don't actually need to read the work of these sorts of 'scientists' to know they're going to be filled with wild suppositions, unverified assumptions, garbage quality data and nonsensical methodologies. It's just a totally corrupt field. Life is too short to double check everything coming out of public health research; at some point we have to learn to stop listening.