3 ms·
The number of amino-acids found has been mentioned in many on-line media, but it is completely meaningless. There exists a huge number of amino-acids, most of
by adrian_b 4y ago
The number of amino-acids found has been mentioned in many on-line media, but it is completely meaningless.
There exists a huge number of amino-acids, most of them are not made or used by the known living beings and of those made by living beings even fewer are used in proteins.
A very large number of random amino-acids have also been found in various meteorites, because they easily form from the most abundant chemical elements in the Universe, H, C, N and O, whenever there is not enough oxygen to oxidize everything else, but among them only about 10 of those used by living beings have been found, i.e. about one half of the amino-acids used in proteins.
What would have been interesting to know about the Japanese asteroid probe would have been if, among the many amino-acids found, there have been also the same about 10 amino-acids previously found, or only a part of them, and if there has been found any other amino-acid with biological importance besides those ten.
The press release mentions only glutamic acid and valine, 2 simple amino-acids which belong to those 10 about which it is well known that they can easily be synthesized in abiotic conditions.
- rndmind 4y ago> More than 500 naturally occurring amino acids are known [..exist], although only 22 appear in the genetic code. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amino_acid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amino_acid So, the article doesn't list which amino acids were found, except one, glutamic acid. The real question is, which amino acids were found.
- april_22 4y agoIs there the possibility that these amino acids appeared on the asteroid after it landed on earth/during entry through the athmosphere?
- driggs 4y agoHayabusa2 rendezvoused with the asteroid in space ("asteroid", not "meteorite"). The asteroid never entered Earth atmosphere. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayabusa2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayabusa2
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> press release mentions only glutamic acid and valine, 2 simple amino-acids which belong to those 10 "Proteinogenic amino acids such as glycine, D,L-a- alanine as well as non-proteinogenic amino acids including b-alanine, D,L-a-aminobutyric acid were identified. The chiral amino acids are present as racemic mixtures (D/L ~ 1), which is indicative of extraterrestrial, non-biological origins." https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2022/pdf/1781.pdf https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2022/pdf/1781.pdf
- adrian_b 4y agoThanks for the link. This is an earlier report about the progress of the chemical analysis of the asteroid samples, at a time when they had identified only 10 amino-acids and when they had not identified yet the glutamic acid and the valine. Unlike in the news report, here the relevant information is present. However the results do not contain any surprise. As expected, there are equal quantities of left-handed and right-handed amino-acids (unlike in living beings) and all the amino-acids are among those simple enough to be synthesized spontaneously, in the absence of life.
- stevenjgarner 4y ago> There exists a huge number of amino-acids, most of them are not made or used by the known living beings and of those made by living beings even fewer are used in proteins. Thanks for the clarification, I did not know this. "Roughly 500 amino acids have been identified in nature, but just 20 amino acids make up the proteins found in the human body." > but among them only about 10 of those used by living beings have been found, i.e. about one half of the amino-acids used in proteins. So you are in fact underscoring just how significant this finding is by Japan on just one out of more than "between 1.1 and 1.9 million asteroids larger than 1 kilometer (0.6 miles) in diameter" in the asteroid belt [2] [1] https://www.ajinomoto.com/aboutus/amino-acids/20-amino-acids https://www.ajinomoto.com/aboutus/amino-acids/20-amino-acids [2] https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/asteroids-comets-and-meteors/asteroids/in-depth/ https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/asteroids-comets-and-meteors/as...
- adrian_b 4y agoThe returning of the asteroid sample and its analysis by Japan are very important and interesting. The problem is with the news report, which does not include the information that could have been interesting about the results. Instead of that, the news report stresses the number of amino-acids that happened to be found in the sample, which has an extremely low importance. Any extraterrestrial sample of matter which has condensed from a gas with the oxygen content under a certain threshold, and which has not been exposed to high temperatures that would vaporize the volatile organic substances is guaranteed to contain many amino-acids. Confirming the expectations is not newsworthy. If the news report would have contained the list of amino-acids, or better, also their proportions, that could have contained some useful information. A complete list might be too much in a news report for the general public, but there is some useful condensed information that could have been given instead of a complete list, i.e. how many proteinogenic amino-acids were among the 23, how many of the amino-acids were left-handed and how many right-handed, and whether there was any amino-acid which has not been found previously in matter of abiotic origin.
- bigbillheck 4y ago> "Roughly 500 amino acids have been identified in nature, but just 20 amino acids make up the proteins found in the human body." There are 20 used to assemble human proteins, but thanks to post-translational modifications there are lot more than that in the actual proteins.
- NotSammyHagar 4y agoBuilding on that, it's ever more clear that the needed building blocks needed to create life are floating around in space, they seem to be very common. Wherever there are adequate conditions (water can exist in liquid form, not too harsh of an environment), amino acids will be deposited there from meteors, they could chemically interact and over lots of time more complex things can arise. So there's an excellent change for some kind of life (microbes at least) to be widely being created across the universe.
- pfdietz 4y ago> So there's an excellent [chance] for some kind of life (microbes at least) to be widely being created across the universe. What a whopper of a non sequitur. This conclusion does not follow at all from the evidence.