12 ms·
Polluted air cuts global life expectancy by two years
- kmlx 4y agoi think this is a missed opportunity when it comes to convincing more people about the advantages of switching to clean energy, especially in developing countries (at least from a marketing pov). for example my dad isn't really convinced about "climate change", but would love for the air to get cleaner. and for this reason he installed solar, a battery, even got a hybrid car.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoIsn’t a hybrid the dirtiest to manufacture? You have batteries AND an ICE.
- kmlx 4y ago> Isn’t a hybrid the dirtiest to manufacture? not sure, could be. with a hybrid he was happy that he got to spend less money on fuel, and in turn produce less pollutants. he would've bought an ICE (and charged it from their own solar), but those were much, much more expensive than the car he got. nonetheless the point was that some people might not be convinced by climate change, but a lot of people want to breath cleaner air.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd everyone wants to save money - even "coal rollers" will buy a hybrid truck if it's cheaper to operate in the long-run.
- kingnothing 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal
- jakear 4y agoThis is miles from the truth. Installing coal rolling equipment actually costs money. And the act of rolling is a lower efficiency combustion. Some people just want to watch the world burn.
- Tade0 4y agoThe difference in fuel consumption more than makes up for that small battery and powertrain. That's at least two metric tonnes of fuel saved over the lifetime of the car compared to ~150kg of additional components. The process of making them would have to be especially dirty to reach the environmental footprint of such an amount of fuel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rad_gruchalski 4y ago> The difference in fuel consumption more than makes up for that small battery and powertrain. Does it not depend on the driving style?
- Tade0 4y agoLess than in a regular ICE car. I've found that at least in my case average speed and use of accessories in heavy traffic is a better predictor of fuel consumption - I suppose it's due to regenerative braking.
- _ea1k 4y agoI wouldn't think so. I can't imagine that manufacturing a small ICE engine is particularly dirty compared to a much larger battery pack. With a PHEV, it would seldom need to run as well, negating the emissions of a purely ICE vehicle.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoHybrid does not imply a small engine. For example, 2023 Toyota Sequoia has an option of a hybrid V6.
- _ea1k 4y agoThat's fair. Not all hybrids are created equally. With larger vehicles, the larger gas motor is almost essential, tbh, as otherwise the total power output will sometimes be limited by the maximum output of the gasoline motor. The i3 was an extreme example of that.
- r00fus 4y agoThe "dirty" battery build pales in comparison the the cost of extraction/transport/burning of gas in the hybrid. I have yet to see any EREOI impact study of gas vs. battery electric that shows gas vehicles to be anywhere close to hybrid or electric.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoApparently it all depends on the driving style? So it seems to require an eco-conscious driver?
- r00fus 4y agoNot at all - you can drive with a lead foot on an EV and still be better off than gas by miles.
- paganel 4y agoMaking people in developing countries poorer is not a “missed opportunity”, is not realizing the true context. Because, yes, trying to force people in developing countries to “buy an EV!” (or equivalent) when they can barely purchase a 10-year-old SH car from Germany will make them poorer.
- kmlx 4y ago> Making people in developing countries poorer who said poorer? > trying to force people in developing countries to “buy an EV!” who's trying to force anyone? i'm sorry, but what i wrote has to do with convincing people (via marketing for example) that it's much better to switch to clean energy because of clean air. and i was referring to "developing countries", a huge list: https://www.worlddata.info/developing-countries.php https://www.worlddata.info/developing-countries.php, aka a huge opportunity.
- starkd 4y agoI think that confuses two potential problems in one: pollution from particulates and pollution from carbon dioxide. If you don't really think carbon dioxide is that big of a problem, or can be managed effectively, the priority should be on filtering out particulates from the burning of fuels. This can be accomplished with much less disruption to the economy than trying to eliminate fossil fuels, which will likely backfire anyway, as countries such as China and India will continue to use it without regard to either problems.
- kmlx 4y agohmm, interesting, i think you're right, but i also think that focusing more on "clean air" than "climate change" in certain countries could alleviate both of the pollution problems you mention.
- 5e92cb50239222b 4y agoOh please. I live in a 'developing country' (don't like that term because I have doubts that it's actually developing). A substantial portion of the population lives in houses heated with coal furnaces. Except that for the past few years coal prices went up somewhat and many people went to burning trash: rubber tires, old rags soaked in motor oil, pieces of bitumen, old plastic bottles, you name it. In winter air quality is simply horrible (my Grafana instance shows an average of 240 µg/m³ PM2.5 for January of this year). I have a t-shirt that was hung out to try at the beginning of this year and it still smells of burnt coal and rubber. The government spent a pretty penny subsidizing installation of natural gas furnaces. Guess what, almost nobody is actually using that now since coal is noticeably cheaper, so people went right back to burning it. I understand they don't care about anybody else, but in winter their own kids breathe air that is literally black and reduces visibility to a few dozen meters. Good luck trying to convince them of anything.
- bombcar 4y agoThe solution is to make natural gas cheaper than coal, even free. But the West reacts violently to "installing carbon-emitting natural gas in developing countries" and it doesn't happen.
- jeromegv 4y agoWhy would you subsidize gas, of all type of energy we could subsidize?
- gruez 4y agoI wouldn't, but it seems somewhat plausible to do it if you really care about costs.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y agoSolar and wind costs much less than gas, and we can still increase the % of intermittent energy sources by a lot before we actually need to install stationary storage. Of course people will oppose gas when we have a better and cheaper alternative.
- lm28469 4y agoWhen 50% of the west is obese/heavily overweight and under exercises I'd be hard pressed to think people care about living longer.
- user_7832 4y agoOn a slightly meta note, things like this show how "letting the free market do its job" isn't really a great idea unless you explicitly also have a pollution (Pigovian) tax/Coase's property rights to handle such externalities.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spaetzleesser 4y agoThere is no “free market” unless you have no rules at all. Markets and capitalism can only work properly if they are regulated.
- junofan 4y agoGenerally a free market is one where the rules are arranged voluntarily by participants. Not sure what you mean by “work properly,” but there are plenty of examples of people successfully producing goods and trading them free of coercion.
- TimPC 4y agoI’d argue working properly includes appropriate consequences for negative externalities which by definition is impossible in an unregulated market. If you make it free to pollute you get a lot of pollution and that’s much worse for people than a $1/unit increase in the cost of some things.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoThat's just because the market is not encompassing everything. A free market is inconsistent with a government and publicly owned resources. Governments don't care if rich companies bribe them and will happily let them pollute until people are pissed enough. Look at plastic and that recycling government propaganda bullshit. They sold us to the oil companies and now we literally eat and breath microplastic. If a polluter is polluting on your share of the shared sky you'll sue them into oblivion.
- userbinator 4y agoI'm sure if everyone lived absolutely sterile and risk-free controlled lives, average life expectancy could be much higher, but I don't think that's a direction me or many others want society to take.
- timcash 4y agoEver think about day to day health? It is not just a life span of 78 vs 80 years. Living in pollution has many other negative effects including biology other than humans.
- user_7832 4y agoIt doesn't have to be a (false) dichotomy though. A 50% reduction in particulate matter and pollutants would still provide significant benefits.
- notahacker 4y agoI'm not sure breathing polluted air is the sort of risk humans choose to take by weighing up their preference for the fun of imbibing fumes vs the possible downsides though...
- defterGoose 4y agoWow! You're so unique and edgy!
- schnebbau 4y agoAgreed. Why are we obsessed with keeping people alive for as long as possible? QoL after 80 is garbage compared to before 80, if I live that long please just let me die.
- site-packages1 4y agoBut we could improve the environment and live longer, higher quality lives without going so far as to create "absolutely sterile and risk-free controlled lives."
- dariosalvi78 4y agoit's interesting how we are fine to let GDP drop considerably to reduce the impact of Covid, but we are perfectly fine to let millions die from air pollution because we don't want to impact GDP.
- izzydata 4y agoDying slowly vs dying quickly. As a society we seem fine with letting people destroy their health in any number of ways from smoking to eating a pound of sugar a day, but we will go to great lengths to prevent people from committing suicide.
- pif 4y ago"Living" is another name for "dying slowly".
- izzydata 4y agoTrue, but I'd prefer to die as slowly as possible.
- skeeter2020 4y agoYou've got the premise backwards; you should try to live a full as possible, not die slowly. An extra few years at the end are worth a lot less than in the middle.
- izzydata 4y agoI can do both I think. Unless doing specific life extending activities like exercising is considering not living a full life. I wonder if exercising for a minute can extend your life by 1 minute or if it's mostly a waste of time in that regard.
- dcolkitt 4y agoOver the past 50 years, the US has invested massive economic resources in reducing air pollution.
- Guthur 4y agoThis is not just gdp or some fat guy getting rich, the fact is that industrialisation has raised millions out of food poverty and allowed us to support a population never before dreamed of. Robbing billions of that to theoretical gain 2 more years (calculated in a strategic vacuum) is foolhardy in the extreme. I don't think anyone quite grasps what potentially going backwards really means for humanity. Without industrialisation there will be significantly large portion of population being made unsustainable.
- thematrixturtle 4y agoWhile I don't disagree, it's educational to visit a place like Delhi, India or Jakarta, Indonesia, which have terrible air pollution but are not particularly industrialized. The main culprits in both appear to be farmers burning their fields and emissions from vehicles, not factories.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd those places are where we should focus our efforts - an electric car in the USA may reduce carbon emissions/air pollution a bit, but that same amount of batteries used in vehicles in India would offset a much greater amount.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThat's true, but the main reason is the lack of cadillac converters on their vehicles. Which generally only cost $1,000-3,000 per vehicle. Which is much less than a full electric car. So if they can't afford cadillac converters, how are they going to afford 40k+ electric cars?
- bombcar 4y agoThen perhaps we should buy catalytic converters for them - there are 300 million vehicles in India, so that would be about 900 billion dollars - is it worth it? Would the pollution reduction be that great? Probably a better use of a trillion dollars than the war on terror, at least from a pollution standpoint.
- hulitu 4y ago> Polluted air cuts global life expectancy by two years Two normal years or two leap years ?
- adolph 4y agoDo the products/services that result in polluted air extend or reduce life expectancy? Could those products/services be provisioned as broadly as they are if all potential pollutants were eliminated? Is pollution a necessary step function on the way to a higher standard of living? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI like to recommend what we did as young parents for the past many years: Get a large room air purifier to simultaneously (1) generate a large spectral range of white noise while also (2) keeping plastic etc. dust out of their lungs (for almost half their life while they sleep so much).
- site-packages1 4y agoI also got a few of the Airthings View Plus boxes, one for each floor of the house and one in the bedroom specifically. Learned some very interesting things, such as that when the A/C comes on at night, the VOCs and CO2 spikes so we were able to address this properly. As an SRE style person, the idea was that without observability into the current state, we didn't really know where the problems were or what we should do to fix them (though perhaps the solution is always just "buy an air purifier").
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y ago>Get a large room air purifier Better start removing the main sources of air pollution. Manufacturing and powering air purifier adds to pollution (and global warming) so it should definitely not be the priority.
- judge2020 4y agoThese are different contexts; in terms of global air pollution, sure, but in terms of in-home exposure to pollutants and microplastic stuff, something that filters the air might help in the place you spend 1/2 or more of your life at.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoFor those looking to change something today, for themselves, consider indoor air pollution and your contribution to it inside your own home with various household "cleaning" chemicals and "fragrances". I have been to several communities which are entirely fragrance free, including entire towns (rules for public spaces) but it's still behind the threshold of public awareness outside of "canaries" and their allies and a few NYTimes articles. Google is your friend on this issue, WHO and EPA have information pages about it.
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoEurope is doing the best to mitigate the pollution, but Europe produces only 8% of global pollution. China and India should do something, but instead they’re doing almost nothing.
- murderfs 4y ago"We did all of our polluting in the past and achieved our industrialization already, why doesn't everyone else just choose to stay poor?"
- adrianN 4y agoIndustrialization can be achieved with less pollution today than two hundred years ago. You're allowed to skip some steps and immediately start with clean technology.
- hedora 4y agoThey've outsourced the vast majority of their air pollution to India and China, but still somehow produce 8% of global pollution. One way to fix this is to change international trade agreements to place producers under the environmental (and human rights) jurisdictions of the places where their goods are ultimately sold. It would force a race to the top instead of the current race to the bottom.
- tsol 4y agoAnd where are Europe's cheap goods being made?