3 ms·
> I think these ideas are mostly delusional because they rely on a fundamental misapprehension about the world around us — namely that we live in a society that
by roenxi 4y ago
> I think these ideas are mostly delusional because they rely on a fundamental misapprehension about the world around us — namely that we live in a society that can be made simple enough to comprehend.
This might be the most interesting quote, but it misunderstands the intellectual underpinings of the right.
Society is fundamentally too complex to understand and therefore big government will cause untold damage and also the individuals should focus only on what they understand well. Governments give control to a system that can only cope with issues that the median person (ie, median voter) understands, and creates a single point of failure for corruption. The right deals with that by decentralising power and the left by building technocratic bureaucracies (not sure how that strategy still gets positive coverage after the USSR and China, but maybe the idea is some mild version works well). That they have a more effective strategy on this specific issue is a core strategic strength of the right, balancing out the fact that the rhetoric is generally a bit heartless.
- cyanydeez 4y agoAs decentralization has shown in crtocurrency, it doesn't produce anything inherently valuable, just what the median person in a geographic area has determined best. Unfortunately, it's a delusion to believe republicans actually believe small government is better except in the sense they can corrupt it, Control it and bias it as they see fit. The benefit of centralization is that it isn't given to the whims of some random gunmen or January 6 type treachery.