3 ms·
People are obsessed with losses. Systemic losses across the pump in and output phase. I think this is typically allowing a second order effect to override the f
by ggm 4y ago
People are obsessed with losses. Systemic losses across the pump in and output phase. I think this is typically allowing a second order effect to override the first order benefit, but there you are: "the losses are too high" is a low bar hall pass out.
What they forget is that the energy input in question is often otherwise being wasted. System loss against throwing it away is not such a bad sum.
There is also a return on capital side of this: spend $100m on Tesla batteries, earn $70m on frequency stability services a year, you're in positive return inside a year on your capex. Invest the same certifying a new pumped hydro, you've barely scratched the surface and you can't earn that sweet FCAS income.
You're not wrong. I will say anything with seawater is a massive turn off. No engineer likes salt water. But that's a minor issue to your underlying point: we're missing cheap, low capital effective storage and gravity based systems because of (in my opinion) second order cost and loss arguments.
Don't hate on the cement block condo btw. I believe the more ugly "crane and bucket model" is in test.
- ncmncm 4y agoCement block condo is super-expensive, but could in principle work (for a short time) if anybody was dumb enough to buy one. The crane thing won't even work if there is any wind at all. But there is always wind. (Maybe they could build a dome over it?) Losses are almost irrelevant when top-line generation is so cheap. So, even though round-trip efficiency of hydrogen is low, it doesn't matter; you just add a few more panels. I.e., losses increase capex but not opex.