6 ms·
> However, this gives a framework for answering the question of timing: do you want more social policies now? If you think it's a good time, then yes, unions ar
by tsimionescu 4y ago
> However, this gives a framework for answering the question of timing: do you want more social policies now? If you think it's a good time, then yes, unions are one way forward. If you think the economic/geopolitic situation is still fragile, you may want to vote for more slack in the system.
Absolutely! Let's give it a few more hundred years of the Bezoses of the US getting richer off the work of everyone else, and only then ask for some rights in return - wouldn't want to do it too soon!
Besides, peeing in a bottle to make your delivery times is actually fun once you get used to it!
- sparrish 4y agoIf you think Amazon delivery drivers are the only drivers pissing in bottles, you don't know much about the long and gross history of delivery drivers. It's common place in the industry.
- tsimionescu 4y agoWhile it's the only ones I heard about, I don't see how this is very relevant. Powerful unions in the industry will tend to raise the standard for everyone, even in shops that are not yet unionized, if we ever get there.
- radu_floricica 4y agoYou engaged none of my points, and are strongly suggesting that you don't care about the state of economy and overall wealth, as long as "the rich get what's coming to them". That's spite socialism.
- tsimionescu 4y agoFair enough. > - Amazon has better wages and conditions than the industry average. Warehouse work is tough in general, Amazon isn't making it particularly hard and pays relatively well. People working in Amazon warehouses often feel exploited for other reasons - such as the absurdly strict time keeping that doesn't often doesn't allow them enough time to get to a toilet, use it, and get back to work in the alloted time for a toilet break. This not how the industry universally works. Further, Amazon has a monopoly on employment in this industry in many areas, so workers are not free to choose who to work for - they take the Amazon terms or starve. Finally, even if Amazon is above the industry average, that doesn't mean that the industry average is all workers can hope for. They are well within their rights to demand much better, give how crucial they are to our way of life. > - Unions aren't universally good. The reason we got to "defund police" is because cops are practically unfireable due to a strong union; and unions were at least part of the reason why GM lost so hard in front of Toyota and other competition. Police unions are fundamentally different from worker's unions in some ways (because of police's virtual monoploy on the use of force). Also, even in common practice, police unions are highly aligned with their employer (the city/state authorities) on most items of interest to the general public, so they are part of the problem for those issues. Even so, police unions are extremely beneficial to their members - probably much more so than an Amazon union could hope to be in the coming years. Finally, if GM lost to Toyota because Toyota was willing and able to exploit their workers, then it is a failure of the US government to have protected GM than a failure of the unions. If the unions were simply sabotaging GM, then yes - they were short sighted and did more harm; future unions should learn from their mistakes, just as business owners learn from the mistakes of people who bankrupt their own companies. It doesn't mean the concept of unions is bad, just like Yahoo being run into the ground by an incompetent CEO doesn't mean we should get rid of CEOs. > In general, societies create wealth through freer markets, then vote to spend that wealth on social policies and income redistribution. Which is perfectly fine, btw. This only works if all people have an actual ability to control policy. In all studies done on this for the last 30-50 years in the USA it has been found that the lower ~50% of the population by income has essentially no say in government, at least on economic policies at the federal level. They put in the work, but have no ability to control how the wealth is allocated. As such, even if society overall is prospering, it is often doing so at the expense of the well being of its poorer working class, which understandably is not ok with that. Unions are one of the more benign and constructive ways this can be changed. Historically, societies on this path have ended in bloody revolutions or fascist autocracy, both of which hopefully can be avoided. I ridiculed your original post because of the implication I felt that it's somehow too soon for these changes. The lack of unions and the erosion of worker rights, and extreme inequality of the use of wealth are problems that have been around for 40 to 50 years. It is in fact very late for some efforts to improve things for the lower class. Perhaps some of the current crises could in fact have been avoided or softened if this had happened earlier.
- systemvoltage 4y agoAmazon has made my life better since I started using them in 2005. That's delivering value for over 17 years. Saved countless trips to stores. You don't become a billionaire without providing value to millions of people and improving their lives. I admire Bezos and his achievements, candor, leadership, and judgement. His yearly memos are profoundly thoughtful and he has changed the world forever, for the better. Obviously he is not perfect. Amazon employees have become millionaires and they are paid fair wages. I really don't understand billionaire hate.
- jseban 4y ago> I really don't understand billionaire hate. Same here, I really could not care less if some guy has 10 sports cars in a basement somewhere, so what? It seems so incredibly childish and petty to walk around and be angry about that. And when having a few billionaires comes with the benefit of more jobs, higher salaries and better economy for me and everyone else, then it seems great to me. How can people prefer an equal society where everyone's poor just to be relieved from their childish jealousy? It's not going ever be fixed anyway, because nature and life is always unfair.
- matsemann 4y agoNo one is having "childish jealousy", they just want fair treatment and a chance at a good life. No one "prefers a society where everyone's poor", that's just childish and off-putting straw men by you. Please explain how having a few billionaires "comes with the benefit of more jobs" and stuff for everyone else. How is it better to share the crumbles, instead of the whole bread? Perplexing.
- jseban 4y ago> they just want fair treatment There is no such thing as fair, it's impossible to even define what that would be, and that's the whole point of the free market, that it solves this problem. The more you use these outdated political catch phrases, the more impractical and meaningless things become. Life is unfair, nature is unfair. > No one "prefers a society where everyone's poor", that's just childish and off-putting straw men by you. This is demonstrably what happens as we have seen during 100 years of large scale experiments involving millions of people. If you keep pushing socialist politics from the 1970s I'm just going to suspect that the same bad things will happen, as happened then. When there is such a massive body of evidence, why should anyone suddenly start thinking "oh yeah, I bet it works this time, let's try that again"? > Please explain how having a few billionaires "comes with the benefit of more jobs" and stuff for everyone else. Because it's the only way to make people pull in the same direction, to create value in a positive bottom line. > How is it better to share the crumbles, instead of the whole bread? Perplexing. Because there will be no bread to begin with, if you share the whole bread, because nobody wants to bake a bread when they are forced to give away the whole thing.