3 ms·
I find the arguments under "But how is this different from traditional advertising?" very unconvincing. They provide examples as to what is different about soci
by whimsicalism 4y ago
I find the arguments under "But how is this different from traditional advertising?" very unconvincing. They provide examples as to what is different about social media advertising, but no convincing reason why traditional advertising wasn't also treating attention as a commodity.
- EchoAce 4y agoI strongly agree, in addition statements like "Before social media advertising would have to hitch a ride with some content produced for something else. Billboards, newspapers, television shows, and magazines all tried to provide a use value to their customers and audiences" are pretty incorrect. As bad as many people agree Facebook is for mental health, it was clearly created for and does provide value. The author does a fairly poor job of carrying out the argument without form-fitting irrelevant details to their desired narrative.
- andrenotgiant 4y agoYeah 100%. This article reads like the reddit.com/r/im14andthisisdeep/ version of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_economy > Traditional advertising could never get your attention. Are you serious? > Before social media advertising would have to hitch a ride with some content produced for something else. This is exactly what social media advertising does. >Billboards, newspapers, television shows, and magazines all tried to provide a use value to their customers and audiences What does that even mean? Advertising was effectively getting attention and subverting behavior long before the internet. Watch the Century of the Self for some prime examples.