3 ms·
> The behavior of multi-component systems are not necessarily reducible to behavior of individual components. But then again, this is also true for systems made
by tsimionescu 4y ago
> The behavior of multi-component systems are not necessarily reducible to behavior of individual components. But then again, this is also true for systems made out of humans (like societies) - yet we still consider humans sentient, and not societies.
And why is this mysterious? Humans behave in certain ways, societies in others. It turns out that the behavior of societies is more simplistic than that of humans.
> As far as the difference being that of "computation", how do you define that, if not as a series of physical state changes in response to external inputs?
Computation implies three parts: an input, an execution engine (computer) and a program to run.
A rock just falls - the information about how to fall is not encoded in any part of the rock, it is part of the universe.
A root cell divides according to external input (the medium in which it lives), and the nuclear organelles executing a program encoded in its DNA (it's more complex than this if we want to analyze it at the most basic level, as the cell or components of it do various rounds of sensing to interpret the input to the division logic).
This can easily be proved by infecting the cell with a virus - that will replace the DNA with a different kind of DNA, modifying the result of the cell division process. There is no similar way to modify the behavior of the falling rock.