3 ms·
More generally, lay juries making decisions about patent cases that hinge on arcana like the ways a session could be embedded in a URL and the stateless nature
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
More generally, lay juries making decisions about patent cases that hinge on arcana like the ways a session could be embedded in a URL and the stateless nature of HTTP is just ... totally fucking absurd.
Yes, it's the lawyers' jobs to explain it to the jury so that they can understand it, but sometimes you just have throw you hands up in the air and say "this is absurd, we can't possibly expect you to get this".
- pclmulqdq 4y agoBench trials are honestly equally absurd, particularly when one party is a big tech company. Judges in the 9th circuit (CA) are known to be extremely favorable to big tech, and the conflicts of interest are obvious - big tech controls the judge's reputation and can offer a lot of future opportunities for people who agree with them on the law. It's like what happens when you sue the New York Times in New York. Juries with competing experts are probably the fairest option, honestly. The people in the jury often don't have a horse in the race. Their job is to go through the elements of the patent and match them up to the supposed infringement and see if everything is there. It's not that hard. Certain technology patents have also been subject to appeals based on what is patentable and what isn't (see Alice vs CLS Bank which invalidated a ton of patents). Those questions are more about technical issues than following the elements.