3 ms·
Angry mobs are a signal of our justice system either having a gap or otherwise not working. The whole point of having a justice system at all is to transform mo
by Spivak 4y ago
Angry mobs are a signal of our justice system either having a gap or otherwise not working. The whole point of having a justice system at all is to transform mob rule into a dialog so when mobs form it’s usually because justice isn’t being served. You don’t see people showing up at a murderer’s house with pitchforks or workers breaking down the doors of factory owners because we have laws that (roughly) enforce the outcomes the people want.
Angry mobs produce fantastic outcomes at identifying when the justice system’s outcomes fall outside of the norms they’re supposed to be enforcing but they’re terrible at functioning as judge and jury in individual cases.
- b112 4y agoAngry mobs are a signal of our justice system either having a gap or otherwise not working. Lately, most angry mobs start on twitter/facebook, and often are based upon exaggerations or lies, and have the aide of twitter/facebook amplification effects, which purposefully try to fan anger to drive more engagement.
- fleddr 4y ago"Angry mobs are a signal of our justice system either having a gap or otherwise not working" Or...radicalized always-online bullies that simply takes joy in taking a political opponent down.
- andrewflnr 4y agoAngry mobs are a signal of humans being stupid pack animals. It's sheer luck if they coalesce around a good cause.
- somat 4y agoMy threshold for whether a mob is legitimate is looting, I have no tolerance for your cause if your mob starts looting. Note however that police stations and capital buildings are a fair target.
- andrewflnr 4y agoSo Twitter mobs are 100% legitimate as they have no opportunity to loot, but you make no allowance for mobs of mixed idealists and opportunists, or for attacking critical infrastructure? Fascinating.
- somat 4y agoIf your twitter mob stays on twitter, that is free speech, stupid, but that is your right to be stupid. when your twitter mob starts to take action(swatting, doxing, physical attack) is when it starts to matter. First note that mobs are ugly stupid irrational things in the first place. Now ask your self. agree or disagree with the message, who is this mob attacking are they attacking their enemies? if so this is a legitimize mob, they have goals, objectives and are acting on them. you may be on the other side, they may be your enemy but the attacks are valid. leave the fight to them and the people they are attacking, or take a side. however if the mob is targeting civilians, random people, causing willful destruction for the sake of destruction, that is, are they looting? This is an illegitimate mob, their message has no value, they have no right to exist and should be actively suppressed by all.