4 ms·
This is just unreasonable. Humans have a natural desire to preserve their own lives. First responders aren't any different. The idea that first responders ar
by kube-system 4y ago
This is just unreasonable. Humans have a natural desire to preserve their own lives. First responders aren't any different. The idea that first responders are superheros is a fallacious trope. The vast majority of police never use their gun over their entire career.
- banannaise 4y agoPolice departments are budgeted and equipped on the assumption it will be useful in situations like this, but the equipment isn't used in situations like this. Instead it's used for the abuse of defenseless civilians. If we're willing to remove these things, then I'm more than fine with not expecting them to handle dangerous situations.
- the_only_law 4y agoIf a soldier goes AWOL because they're "scared" of fighting or consistently straight up neglects to do their job, I'm sure "natural self preservation" will be a stunning and effective defense at the court martial regardless if they're ina combat role or not.
- kube-system 4y agoSoldiers are not first responders.
- the_only_law 4y agoClearly that doesn't matter as GP made it clear that this is a human trait, not tied to any profession.
- 1991g 4y agoIt's almost as if civilians (read: police) and soldiers are trained, equipped, and deployed to different environments, with different rules.
- Apocryphon 4y agoAnd yet, today's police departments are often as militarized as soldiers. Plenty of HN stories about the phenomenon over the past decade https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=miltiarization%20police&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- jjulius 4y agoIf you're not willing to put your life at risk, you should not be a first responder. Plain and simple.
- kube-system 4y agoCalculated risks, yes, like going in to the same building as an active shooter. They're not going to jump in front of a bullet to protect anyone else, though. The primary responsibility of any first responder -- police, fire, or EMS -- is to preserve their own lives.
- jjulius 4y ago>They're not going to jump in front of a bullet to protect anyone else, though. The primary responsibility of any first responder -- police, fire, or EMS -- is to preserve their own lives. And this is where, circumstantially, you and I seem to have a fundamentally different viewpoint. We'll just keep going in circles.
- jjav 4y ago> The primary responsibility of any first responder -- police, fire, or EMS -- is to preserve their own lives. This is fundamentally wrong. If it were ok, let's just disband them all and save a lot of money since their responsibility doesn't benefit anyone other than themselves. I reject the concept of a society where this is somehow ok.
- kube-system 4y agoIt's 100% the truth. First responders are neither instructed to nor required to sacrifice their lives at work. They're required to take upon some amounts of risk as a matter of circumstance, but that line stops far before death. The idea that first responders can solve anything is a very comforting idea that resonates with many people. That doesn't make it true.
- fzeroracer 4y agoFirefighters can and do frequently put themselves at far more risk than any police officer ever will. Police don't even rank up near the top of the list in terms of most dangerous jobs to hold. If the police cannot do their jobs to save children from being killed by a school shooter then they should not be police officers. They should not be militarized and given advanced equipment, they should not pretend that they ever need it and their budget shouldn't be the majority of a town's spending. And if they don't like it, then maybe the police and the police union can do better campaigning on actual ways to stop school shooters instead of using it as an excuse to further increase their own budget.
- ceejayoz 4y agoPutting themselves in harms way is the deal. It’s why they get to retire over a decade earlier than the rest of us with a nice pension. It’s why they get qualified immunity for a whole bunch of actions. They aren’t holding up their side of the deal here.
- kube-system 4y agoYes, it's expected that first responders may do things that are generally dangerous but they're not on kamikaze missions, it's completely normal for them to back out when they believe their own life is in danger. This is not any different for any first responder. Firefighters will run right back out of your house if they think it's required to save their own lives.
- ceejayoz 4y ago19 cops (in the hallway alone; more outside!) with rifles, armor, and complete control of the scene against one shooter is not a "kamikaze mission". What's the point of militarizing the police if they can't handle 19-on-1 situations?
- kube-system 4y agoHaving a large number of police doesn't decrease the risk to the first person to jump through the door. And most police body armor is only effective against handgun rounds, across part of the body. Police militarization helps the police protect themselves when a situation gets out of control. I don't think there's much evidence to show that it ever helps police protect others. Although, there's a lot of reasons why people might be misled to believe so.
- Apocryphon 4y agoDon't soldiers have to undertake such dangerous actions? What's the point of militarizing all of these police departments with actual War on Terror surplus if they're not going to make use of it? So that weaponry can be misused in disproportionate responses in less dangerous situations?
- manquer 4y agoIf it were adults your theory may hold, but not for children. Evolutionarily we have even higher desire to protect our young(so does most of animal kingdom). The instinct to protect young children is stronger than desire to protect self - the trait is easily strongly selected under evolutionary pressure.
- zo1 4y agoThere are many, many stories of individuals putting themselves in danger and in cases dying to protect others. Just the one that came to mind while reading about this sad story, done by a bunch of teens saving their fellow school members. https://westdene1985.co.za/reports/the-survivors/ https://westdene1985.co.za/reports/the-survivors/ " >>Koen, Petrus Lucas received the Wolraad Woltemade award posthumously. The 17-year-old drowned after rescuing his cousin and five fellow school pupils. >>Du Toit, Daniel Sarel, aged 14, dived back into the water three times and saved three lives. >>Mahner, Alfred who drove to the site, jumped into the water and helped several children to safety and assisted the fire brigade to attach cables to the bus. >>Opperman, Gotlieb Rudolf, aged 15, was rescued in an unconscious condition from the bus after jumping back into the water three times to rescue children. "
- kube-system 4y agoI'm sure there's a constant stream of similar stories every day. Out of the 700,000 police officers in the US, there are undoubtably hundreds, maybe thousands, of them that would voluntarily sacrifice their life to save others. The other 99.9+% of them do as much as they can and but still want to go home to their own children.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackflip 4y ago