2 ms·
The real question is, what even is sentience? The only real certainty about it is that one is sentient oneself - and that's because "I'm sentient" is taken as a
by int_19h 4y ago
The real question is, what even is sentience? The only real certainty about it is that one is sentient oneself - and that's because "I'm sentient" is taken as an axiom! From there, you basically have two approaches: either try to somehow define the specifics of sentience, or give up and say that anything that behaves as a sentient entity is one. The latter is the premise of the Turing test. The former all try to decompose one's sentience into bits that can be translated to other entities - but doing so "from within" produces criteria that are tautological or circular.
I strongly suspect that notions such as sentience and self-awareness don't have a meaningful physical definition, but are necessary for us to function, because they're the mental glue that makes thinking about "I" possible at all - which is broadly advantageous for survival. But why should a different mind necessarily need the same kind of glue to function as a whole? And how do we even know if it's the same or not without being able to observe it from the perspective of that other mind (since that's how we observe our own sentience, that's necessary to make accurate comparisons)?
I furthermore suspect that we refuse to embrace these notions because our sense of identity - of self - is, by necessity, so strong that any premise that undermines it is strongly disadvantaged from the get-go. Basically, we do not like to even contemplate the notion that "I am not one indivisible whole", even if it might be closer to how our mind actually operates on the physical level.