2 ms·
To try to clarify the conversation a bit, here's (my version of) a couple definitions. Sentience is awareness of one's surroundings. Your cat is sentient. Mo
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
To try to clarify the conversation a bit, here's (my version of) a couple definitions.
Sentience is awareness of one's surroundings. Your cat is sentient. Most embedded systems are to some degree sentient. We know what makes this - adequate interfaces to adequate sensors, plus some mechanism to respond to the input in some way. That's basically all it takes.
Sapience is the awareness of one's own mind - the ability to watch yourself think. We're pretty sure that your cat is not sapient, and neither are embedded systems. But we don't know what enables or causes sapience, nor how it does so.
So when we're talking about "consciousness" or something, we have to be clear whether we're talking about sentience or sapience. (And the conversation won't be using my words, so don't go by that - you have to sort out which idea is being discussed.) And of course the worst discussions have different people using the same word for different ideas, and nobody recognizes it, so the discussion is really about different definitions of the same word.
- foobarian 4y agoThank you for pointing out the word "sapience," it is a great distinction to the more general concept. Also did you mean to say "sapience" instead of "sentience" in the 3rd paragraph?
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoFixed, thanks. And, credit where due: I stole the term from Howard Tayler's wonderful "Schlock Mercenary" webcomic. It may not be original with him, but that's where I got it.
- epgui 4y agoCats are almost certainly both sentient and sapient by your definition. Even crows appear to be sapient, and their brain architecture is a lot more primitive than cats'.