5 ms·
Next up: Facebook, Twitter, Google liable for content indexed on internet, millions of lawsuits launched. Then follows every cloud provider for abusive content
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Next up: Facebook, Twitter, Google liable for content indexed on internet, millions of lawsuits launched. Then follows every cloud provider for abusive content hosted on S3 buckets and eventually we'll have some three of four companies that run The Internet according to Internet Law.
Sorry, but you can't just hold a provider accountable for user uploaded content. Sure, you could argue for further abuse scanning like Google foolishly tries with content ID but the real solution is to go after the uploaders. If Pornhub is required to ask for special validation so is every single service with user postable content.
I imagine the end goal here is to require government ID for every Pornhub account which will definitely not be abused in an inevitable hack. Similarly, Reddit, Instagram, Tiktok and Onlyfans will all follow in requiring ID before being able to do anything. After all, why post revenge porn on Pornhub when you can sell it on Onlyfans? What's stopping you from creating fake Reddit accounts and posting to NSFW subs? Plenty of stolen content on there already!
There's not quick and easy solution. Pornhub is not your problem, your abusive ex or the guy who found your cloud storage password is. Have the police solve these problems instead of forcing the responsibility to uphold the law to a random company that happens to be the biggest distribution of free porn.
- tomjen3 4y agoI feel like there is a difference between hosting something and recommending content. One is neutral and the other is an editorial decision, even if done by a bot. Sue over the latter, maybe. Sue over the first? You should be laughed out the room.
- mbg721 4y agoThe real problem in this case is that an abusive ex has way more leverage than before. We can't say "stop providing that leverage", because it's victim-blaming, but those backward social norms were there for a reason.
- jeroenhd 4y agoIt all depends on what you qualify as "before", sharing leaked videos has been a thing since the early days of online porn, be it abusive exes or "hackers" humiliating their victims. As always, the internet brings out the very best and the absolute worst of humanity. I personally hopetthat soon enough we'll be able to move on to a post-blackmail society with the advance of deep fakes. When anybody has the ability to paste any face onto any movie, no video can be trusted (it already can't be, to be fair) and everything should be covered under plausible deniability. Just declaring something a fake by some Facebook creep that wants your money should hopefully be enough to wars off any confrontation from friends or family about leaked explicit content. It's really the best I can think of to hope for. Banning porn won't help, putting up red tape will only spawn more websites outside enforcing jurisdictions, and the perfect deep fake singularity may be mere years of not months away.
- Chris2048 4y agoGoogle links/indexes websites, but doesn't host them. Unless you are talking about the cache. > you can't just hold a provider accountable for user uploaded content. Can't you hold providers accountable for not verifying user identity? Just ask for verified photo-id and illegal content becomes enforceable. An video-hosting adult site of obviously more sensitive than a web-scraper/search engine, so the extra steps are justified. Then (and only then) can you go after the uploaders. > require government ID for every Pornhub account for uploading, yes. Not spectator accounts. > Plenty of stolen content on there already! Mostly it's links, not hosting, afaik. If they remove any cached images/videos if the original link goes away then I figure they're covered.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThe cache and the preview snippet have been considered stolen IP by news agencies for years and in several cases these news agencies have been awarded the right to demand Google stops displaying their content (which they quickly reverted once nobody visited their site anymore). Google Images also contains a vast amount of material that's cached by Google, available for quite some time after the source has been deleted. You can definitely hold companies accountable for ID verification. The EU even required Google to verify users are 18+ to view some YouTube videos, either by uploading an ID or by paying a cent through a credit card. Pornhub already requires ID verification and more, so it should catch abuse of their systems. However, when you have a video of five people going at it in front of a camera with a whole production team, I'm not sure who you're going to verify and how.
- Chris2048 4y ago> to view some YouTube videos, either by uploading an ID or by paying a cent through a credit card viewing isn't the issue - it's uploading, of illegal content meaning users willing to break the law, such as spoofing/faking photo id or credit cards, so for this both these verification methods aren't enough. > I'm not sure who you're going to verify Anyone accountable as the copyright holder e.g. if it's a production company a liable director or something. The point is - you need someone to go after if the material turns out to be illegal i.e. non-deniable proof of liability. Incidentally, this rules out any videos originating in countries with legal systems that do not cooperate with the local one.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Sure, you could argue for further abuse scanning like Google foolishly tries with content ID but the real solution is to go after the uploaders. If Pornhub is required to ask for special validation so is every single service with user postable content. Content ID actually isn't so foolish. It works reasonably well to target copyrighted material, the problem rather is that it by nature cannot determine "fair use" exceptions and getting an actual human to review false strikes is an unreasonably excessive effort. When someone notifies Pornhub that a video they host is distributed without the consent of the persons involved, it should be very very easy for Pornhub to scan for other videos containing the same content, even as snippets, and subsequently take these down. The technology exists, both as SaaS (e.g. Amazon Rekognition) or as open-source solution to self-host. Side note, I always did wonder how PornHub and friends were able to evade the record-keeping requirements of 18 USC § 2257.
- jeroenhd 4y agoContent ID is extremely sensitive to audio and vague video. Upload half an hour of white noise and you'll have at least three content ID strikes. Actual "songs" get stricken easily as well because someone uploaded their own rendition of a free song, uploaded it to YouTube, and now all renditions of the song are "theirs". I agree that Pornhub should remove and block all related content but finding such content is not a solved problem. The article talks about small snippets being uploaded independently, you're never going to find those. If proper contextual recognition was a solved problem we'd have self driving cars by now. It's very easy to overestimate image recognition technology. We're getting closer every day, but we're still far from an real AI.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Content ID is extremely sensitive to audio and vague video. Upload half an hour of white noise and you'll have at least three content ID strikes. That's mostly because Youtube has allowed the major labels to directly upload stuff to Content ID instead of doing quality control to make sure the content is actually valid and at a quality that allows actual comparisons. > The article talks about small snippets being uploaded independently, you're never going to find those. Take each video, create a visual hash of each frame (or at least for each detected scene). When a video is reported, compare its frame hashes with the database, manually examine matches if they are identical, and do the same for all new uploads. Easy enough to get at least a sensible start on the problem and to crack down on the worst abusers. Identifying all videos of a given person is harder, granted, but seriously, at 97 billion $ of revenue [1] each year it should not be too much of an expectation that Pornhub actually does something beyond requiring victims to scan for their content on their own! [1] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10058065/Owner-97bn-Pornhub-named-Pandora-Papers-defends-investment-saying-taxes-paid.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10058065/Owner-97bn...
- JackFr 4y ago> Sorry, but you can't just hold a provider accountable for user uploaded content. You absolutely can. Honestly it wouldn't even be that hard. Start with: you need a real name and address to upload.
- jeroenhd 4y agoPornhub already requires proof of ID and/or residence, as well as a facial scan. Clearly this hadn't solved the issue.
- toss1 4y agoYou seem to have missed the "start with". The problem here, as with many things is the privitization of profits while externalizing the harms onto someone else. Modern technology now allows this at ruinous scale, and that needs to be prohibited or seriously controlled if we want to continue as a society. It's often said that my ability to swing my fists in the air ends at the tip of your nose. Similarly, my ability to make profits should end at the point of causing massive harm to others. Whether it is fossil fuel industry scaling up ecosystem-destroying tech, or tech hubs scaling up ability for any sick rando to ruin lives, it needs to be well controlled. If you cannot solve the problem of your tech being used for life-ruining purposes, shut down. One actual solution is to provide easily accessible routes for people whose lives are ruined by the tech platforms to claim recovery. You share all your profits with those whose lives are ruined, in sufficient measure to properly compensate them, and it's still profitable, maybe ok, if the harm is actually compensated. And no, allowing liability only after massively costly lawsuits with no ability to collect because profits have been offshored is not a solution - it's more like put up a sufficient bond in every jurisdiction. Funny how that is likely to kill the business. IOW, if we want a civilized society, allowing private profits on the backs of externalizing harm must be well controlled. Otherwise only psychopaths run the place.
- otterley 4y agoWas this true before the issues of unauthorized content/CSAM became widely reported a couple years ago?