24 ms·
> But I think the excessive smack-down of excitement is a little patronizing of the public On the contrary, I think this is immensely important for the public
by tsimionescu 4y ago
> But I think the excessive smack-down of excitement is a little patronizing of the public
On the contrary, I think this is immensely important for the public to understand if they are ever given access to these models to play with. It can be literally dangerous for your psychological well-being to think you are having a meaningful conversation with LaMDA - as mister LeMoine has clearly proven: he will likely lose a job that he loved (per his own words) because of this fanciful illusion.
> To be able to create a master plan, you must first be able to represent the concept somehow.
That is entirely wrong. Slime mold can do planning at a level that GPT-3 probably can't, but it sure as hell doesn't have a concept of "master plan" anywhere.
> Turning this "language of thought" into a goal-directed agent is a whole different task. But its progress.
That is not at all clear - we may yet see LMs as just as much of a dead-end on the road to AGI as CLIPS or ELIZA turned out to be. Even if that's true, that doesn't mean they can't be useful in practical tasks, and it doesn't mean that we can't take insights from them into the limits of how we judge intelligence or what "meaning" is.