3 ms·
The hype: "Lenders have a lot to gain when they join Celsius. The platform pays out rewards as high as a 17% yield. These rewards are calculated by the system b
by Animats 4y ago
The hype: "Lenders have a lot to gain when they join Celsius. The platform pays out rewards as high as a 17% yield. These rewards are calculated by the system based on your loan terms and paid out every Monday."
This is like a junk bond. You get a high yield in exchange for a risk of loss of the principal. So junk bonds require due diligence to price. You don't buy just one kind; you buy a diversified collection in hopes that they don't all go bust at once. In 2008, mortgage-backed securities did all go bust at once.
In crypto land these things are blind pools. Customers have no idea where the pool operator is investing, and to what risks they are exposed. This is why there is a requirement for SEC registration.
That's if it's honest. It might be an out and out Ponzi, like Madoff's.
What the crypto crowd does not seem to get is that none of this is new. These are all old ideas in finance. In the 1920s, retail investors were being offered similar blind pools.
- haimez 4y agoIt’s kind of like the (public!!!) shares or options companies offered before the dot com boom. Too good to be true.
- Animats 4y agoNo, it's not. This is a high risk loan. Limited upside, unlimited downside.
- thethimble 4y agoDownside is limited to your principal investment.
- Animats 4y agoYou can't be busted to below zero, unless you borrowed to make the investment.
- haimez 4y agoYou’re right, the upside is fixed at 17% and my comment wasn’t really addressing the contents of yours, but the general sense of unease I get talking to people about their “crypto positions” as if having some > 1% (often a lot more) portion of their whole net worth “in crypto” is a reasonable part of a balanced portfolio.
- 37ef_ced3 4y agoAnimats, I was a fan of your Downside site: http://downside.com/ http://downside.com/ Downside's goal is to remind people that we're experiencing a financial bubble, and that financial bubbles always burst. (We originally wrote that in April, 2000. Any questions?) And here we are, living through another huge bubble.
- piva00 4y agoNowadays we are a bit more sophisticated and call it "the business cycle". It's totally normal and the people hurt during the process are doing it for the greater cause of the free market™, don't worry, they love it.
- puranjay 4y agoReminder that the second largest pension fund in Canada invested in Celsius at a 4B valuation. There really needs to be more oversight on what these funds invest in.
- soperj 4y agoHonestly, every time I hear of the Quebec Pension fund it seems like they're doing something that makes no sense at all.
- salmonlogs 4y agoQuick Google shows Quebec Pension Fund managed circa ~$325B. They will invest across a range of asset classes and risk profiles. Looks like they put around $200M into Celsius which is about 0.06% of their AUM. Numbers might not be totally accurate but order of magnitude shows the scale of these funds and how they choose high risk to try and get some return for their beneficiaries. (Note: I'm not condoning investment into Celsius/crypto in general; just making a point on the investment scale)
- t_mann 4y agoPension funds still have no mandate to act as ultra high risk VC investors. There are other funds for that.
- nly 4y agoArguably pension funds are best placed to take on (diversified) high risk investments. They have a long time horizon (20-40 years), and their members can't arbitrarily withdraw their funds. If you've been sat in high quality government bonds for the last 15 years then you've basically made nothing, or even a loss, in real (inflation adjusted terms). My pension fund is in 100% global equity. I've got no choice if I want to retire at a sensible age.
- t_mann 4y ago'Our investors can't get out' is an absolutely terrible justification for doing ultra high risk investments. 'We have a long-term horizon', which in this context can easily translate into 'by the time this blows up everyone responsible will have long left the company / vested their bonuses' is hardly better. The only good justification for doing high risk investments is 'our investors know, they understand the risks and they want us to do this'.
- tornato7 4y ago> In crypto land these things are blind pools. Customers have no idea where the pool operator is investing This is factually incorrect. Celsius' addresses are publicly tagged on Etherscan[1], and everyone can see exactly where they are investing, just like most other 'pools' of the sort. Celsius Network is also SEC registered[2]. 1. https://etherscan.io/address/0x8aceab8167c80cb8b3de7fa6228b889bb1130ee8 https://etherscan.io/address/0x8aceab8167c80cb8b3de7fa6228b8... 2. https://sec.report/CIK/0001739052 https://sec.report/CIK/0001739052
- Animats 4y agoThey registered their stock as offered only to qualified investors per Rule 506(c). So all they had to file is a Form D, which has a name and address and not much else. Their loan system isn't registered as a security. They even say "Earn accounts have not been registered under the Securities Act and may not be offered or sold in the United States, to U.S. persons, for the account or benefit of a U.S. person or in any jurisdiction in which such offer would be prohibited." But not prominently on their home page. They will get to explain to the SEC why they have the US toll-free number "1-866-HODL-NOW" and are on the Apple Play Store for the US. Yes, you can look at their transaction log, but it's doesn't tell you all that much. 7 hours ago, they sent 50,000 ETH to somebody.[1] Some people are "paused" less than others, apparently. Someone noted this on Twitter[2] [1] https://etherscan.io/tx/0xf9e0788094c0bbfdc61ed2fbcf79dfcd4d346707baf49cd24cd183bc33a68740 https://etherscan.io/tx/0xf9e0788094c0bbfdc61ed2fbcf79dfcd4d... [2] https://twitter.com/btcinchina/status/1536186927707066368 https://twitter.com/btcinchina/status/1536186927707066368
- nullc 4y ago> This is like a junk bond. More like a HYIP feeder fund, and considering reports that they were investing in things like Luna/Anchor it sounds like a fair description. Madoff had feeder funds too, they're critical to reach the entire market-- as there are people who won't invest in the HYIPs directly but will once they've been laundered through a middleman who reduces the yield, making them somewhat more plausible.