4 ms·
Prospective jurors who are "too smart" (highly educated/credentialed) are often dismissed as well.
by SoftTalker 4y ago
Prospective jurors who are "too smart" (highly educated/credentialed) are often dismissed as well.
- dontbenebby 4y agoThey should do that with being charged for crimes too then, since we're entitled to a jury of our peers. (I'm not at all joking.)
- tjohns 4y agoEach side in a trial gets to dismiss a certain number of potential jurors, for nearly any reason they like. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voir_dire#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voir_dire#United_States
- dontbenebby 4y agoI know, but thanks for sharing this for those who do not.
- woodruffw 4y agoYour peers are your fellow citizens, usually from the same municipality as you. The US doesn't recognize a right to be tried by peers of a particular status, since consideration for that is likely to always be a positive or negative bias (e.g. juries of landholders against a tenant, juries of the educated against someone illiterate.)
- dontbenebby 4y agoYeah, that's why my metro area has negative population growth. You can EXPLAIN things like you just said, but if you just explain over and over "that's the way it is" to people who are trapped in interactions with you, they tend to act out, it's why Pennsylvania has been having so many issues lately.
- woodruffw 4y agoI can think of a handful of other things in the last 24 months that probably better explain why your metropolitan area has negative population growth.
- dontbenebby 4y agoIt's been that way since I first emmigrated then returned under duress due to persistent discrimination. We have been too welcoming to antisocial people.
- WalterGR 4y agoThat’s weird. Where can I learn more?
- 0des 4y agoDuring voir dire usually.
- sleightofmind 4y agoThe one and only jury I was seated on (civil trial) had both a Ph.D in statistics and a Masters in mathematics. The remainder (12-man jury) was probably evenly split between High School only folks like me, and BA/BS crowd. So from janitor who couldn't afford a car to a Ph.D all on one jury. We discussed matters politely, but at times with some intensity. Overall jury position swung 180-degs over 2 days. Gave me hope that the system can work.
- woodruffw 4y agoI don't think you can assert this unequivocally. Prosecutors often favor highly educated jurors for anti-social crimes, under the theory that members of polite society are more willing to dole out punishment against defendants accused of violating peace and tranquility.
- WesternWind 4y agoI mean one can at least say that it's treated as a salient factor. And a good education does inform how people think about justice. For example, the jury selection this blogger talks about. https://www.exurbe.com/on-crimes-and-punishments-and-beccaria/ https://www.exurbe.com/on-crimes-and-punishments-and-beccari...
- woodruffw 4y agoYep, it certainly is! It's an instance where prosecutors (and defenders) will select in either direction, depending on whatever they think is most likely to obtain their outcome. Education is a proxy for all kinds of other things, so it's particularly salient.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYeah, maybe I should have said "sometimes" rather than "often." The gist of what I remember about it is that sometimes a "smart" juror can end up trying to outhink the lawyers, rather than just evaluating the evidence presented and whether or not it meets the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard.
- zer0-c00l 4y agoIME it’s more about selecting a group that is the most to be likely receptive to the particular argument/narrative/story you’re trying get the jury to accept
- grogenaut 4y agoI got a chance to chat with the defense attorney of a case I was a juror on like a year later when they sat down next to me at a bar. He said that they generally took IT folks as they tended to be salaried and thus not impacted by a court case. Same for retired folks. Note I am making the assumption that a high % of IT folks went to higher education.
- colechristensen 4y agoI’ve known a couple of people working on technical phd programs who served on juries so it happens.