9 ms·
Jimmy Carter asks court to defend Alaska’s ‘unrivaled wilderness’
- kinnth 4y agoYes the resident logic is a bait and switch for further developments. Wilderness should stay wild. Leave it as is and do nothing. It's amazing how many powerful politicians and obviously lobbied individuals keep trying to change that.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoThe residents in this particular area have been complaining for 30+ years (somewhat loudly) to the Alaskan government that they don't have access to basic commerce. There's no road! Jimmy Carter doesn't want to build a road to meet these people?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- macinjosh 4y ago
- rc_mob 4y agoThis logic leads to extinction of many animal species
- stefan_ 4y agoAnd yet more spawn. You know they started cataloging species to "document gods work"; rooted in ignorance and ever since Darwin we know that is futile, and mostly silly.
- ericmay 4y agoWhat I question is whether or not we really need to further develop a lot of natural spaces with sprawl and waste. I’m not sure why protecting untouched lands is “hating your own humanity” either. In fact I think it’s the opposite - it’s getting in touch with the core essence of being human, which is part of being in a natural environment, which we have less of because we have been tricked to think we more strip malls that are ugly and dumb compared to even the most barren in disturbed landscape. Hating humanity is destroying our history and our environment so we can pave roads and build another fast food chain. In a place like Iceland you’ll find undisturbed volcanic rock and moss. It’s more beautiful than all but the greatest brick house neighborhoods , monasteries built on cliff sides, castles, and Brooklyn Bridges. There are very few government run agencies or programs that get voluntary donations. NASA is one, our national parks are the other. It’s obvious.
- EB66 4y agoIs this sarcasm? Is there a single example in the history of mankind where mass human development has not led to the significant decline of plant and animal species in the surrounding areas? If you accept that the diversity and abundance of plant and non-human animal life has instrinic value then it's an awfully easy to say that blocking further human development in wild areas is the "right" thing to do.
- rayiner 4y agoBlaming “politicians” is a canard. People in Alaska want to develop their land for the same reason people in New York and California did—for economic development and jobs. If other folks value the wilderness so much, they should pay folks in Alaska not to develop their land.
- tomjakubowski 4y agoThe land in question belongs to the federal government*... we already pay them not to develop it, with taxes! *: subject to the land swap, which Carter argues is illegal
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lovich 4y ago> If other folks value the wilderness so much, they should pay folks in Alaska not to develop their land. We did. Congress used our tax dollars to purchase Alaska and then later on carved out part of that purchase as this reserve. It is in no way more their land than it is the New Yorker’s or the Californian’s.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cudgy 4y agoWasn’t California purchased from Mexico? According to this logic, the only people that truly own land to develop as they please are those that own property in areas that were seized from Indians without compensation like the original East Coast states.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lovich 4y agoMore like, the national parks in California that are owned by the federal government aren’t free to be developed on. Again the Alaskans don’t want to develop their own land. They want to develop on the land that is jointly owned and that the rest of society wants to have remain undeveloped. When you don’t have sole ownership of a piece of property you don’t have sole say in its use. I am sorry that’s Alaskans feel upset that they don’t have the right to use our property as they see fit
- atum47 4y agoI don't have much to add to this discussion, except that I went to Alaska a few weeks ago and I loved it. Looking as a tourist its easy to say that I would like to preserve as it is, but people living there might think entirely different.
- jacksonmary5699 4y agoHello everyone it is possible to retrieve your stolen bitcoins. I never believed in bitcoin recovery because I was made to understand that it is not possible. But sometime in February I fell for a binary options scam which promised a higher return and I lost close to $75,000. I read an article on (reddit) as regards to a recovery expert and genius so I reached out to Scam Recovery Site, and to my surprise I got all bitcoins recovered within 48hours frame. I don’t know if I’m allowed to share the links on here but you can contact them if you are finding it very difficult to withdraw your funds kindly contact; hackadviserpro @ gmail com…. All Thanks To Them.
- CA0DA 4y agoFor those simply upvoting without reading the article, this case is more nuanced than the headline may sound: > Residents in the community of King Cove want to exchange land to build a gravel road through the refuge to provide access to an all-weather airport in nearby Cold Bay for medical transports.
- phkahler 4y agoIt's not about the residents of King Cove. BTW they've either been without that road for 40 years, or moved there knowing the situation. It's about power and control if you go by this part: “The split panel decision would allow the secretary, without any public process or without compliance with any other laws, to engage in a backroom land exchange,”
- hanniabu 4y agoThat's a pretty fucked up clause
- notch656a 4y ago45% of households in King Cove have children who had no choice in whether the road is there or not 40 years ago. It's hard to just blame them that "they knew the roads weren't there" when they were born thus they're not allowed roads to medical care the way I (and probably you) are.
- mod 4y agoI would sooner take the children away or force the residents to move than pave a road through the Alaskan wilderness. I wouldn't do those things either, though. People get to choose where and how to raise their children. Children don't get a say so in virtually anything that affects them. "Think of the children" is not a good argument. Also the whole population is like 1200 people. We're talking about a relative handful of kids. Like one very small elementary school (edit: Google search says there's 87 kids in PK-12th grade. Combined.)
- 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y agoJimmy's a good man. We need more like him.
- IanDrake 4y ago
- cato_the_elder 4y ago
- codegeek 4y agoEven if he was incompetent as President, he is a good man and nothing can change that.He has done a lot of good over the years as a citizen and it is fair to applaud him for that. He hasn't been President for 42 years so it is time to let that go and just appreciate a great American that he is.
- WalterBright 4y agoJimmy has been the best ex-President we've ever had.
- WalterBright 4y agoJimmy was a terrible President. He's still a very good man, and I admire him, and would love to have him over for dinner!
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoA friend of mine lives near him and has become close to him. They do have the Carters over for dinner a couple times a year. Seems crazy, but Jimmy's just a friendly guy.
- bitwize 4y agoMy girlfriend met him and his wife once during the 80s or so. It's not that crazy, they really are humble and genial with ordinary folks. They made such an impression on her that our dog is named after his wife, following her broader tradition of giving our pets presidential names.
- jfoutz 4y agoLooking at google maps, there's a ferry about 30 mile ride on the water. I don't know the route they're proposing, but maybe 60 miles over mountains. Ugh. The ambulance isn't going to be going 60 over washboard roads. The good people of Alaska can do whatever they want, but if the concern is medical emergencies, they should seriously consider keeping a plane at the airport, illuminate the airport, and make sure the runway stays plowed. Anchorage is about 900 miles away. A helicopter ride over to cold bay, then on a plane to Anchorage might be easier if they can keep a pilots on hand. Actually there's a bunch of really small, really remote communities up there. helicopter service to cold bay, plane to the trauma center might be a really good plan.
- macinjosh 4y agoWe built an interstate across an entire mountain range. Just because a road goes over a mountain does mean it can’t be easily possible at highway speeds.
- jfoutz 4y agoWell, sure. but they're looking to put in a gravel road. king cove, population 757. I think you'd want a road grader to start, I don't see a quarry on the map, but maybe there's one near by. You could also move a rock crusher up there. I mean, it's fine, but gravel roads are kind of a pain. you have to keep adding more, year after year. I mean, you could pave it, but asphalt doesn't like freezing and thawing over and over. But sure, a good road could be built. If they're concerned about emergency services - Anchorage seems like the closest trauma center. 900 miles away. Maintain the airport and keep a plane there. Screwing around with an hour drive before getting to a plane seems like the kind of plan that won't really help much if you need emergency services.
- Retric 4y agoThey want to connect to an all weather airport which would let them get to the trauma center more quickly and of course do other stuff. The issue isn’t this specific road, it’s every other time someone wants to go through a wildlife refuge.
- zackees 4y agoI understand the need to protect the environment from the destructive effects of farming, which consumes fast areas of land. But an airport? Really?
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoWhat’s wrong with helicopters?
- Vladimof 4y agoThe thing I hate the most about helicopters is that their flying altitude isn't restricted even over homes...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoRead Carter's amicus brief https://www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/amicus-brief-jimmy-carter-anilca-2022.pdf https://www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/amicus-brief-jim... Carter's argument: Regardless of any facts surrounding the purpose of a road, the 1980 ANILCA did not authorise (Trump's) Secretary of the Interior to review and permit development in refuges on an ad-hoc basis, via section 2192(h)(1) land exchanges. A majority of a three-member panel of the Court of Appeals got it wrong. The Court needs to reconvene, en banc. "But the decision of the panel majority in this case rests on a grave misunderstanding of the fundamentals of this vital law. In enacting ANILCA, Congress did not, as the decision concluded, vest the Secretary with discretion to decide whether lands like the Izembek National Wildlife Refuge should be retained in their natural state or whether the economic and social benefits of road-building or other development outweigh the ecological and subsistence harms that such activities would inflict. That is precisely what ANILCA disallowed when it expressly designated particular lands for conservation and subsistence, legislative decisions that carry corresponding, enduring protections. Those designations were not based on the assumption that these lands lacked economic value. Just the opposite: ANILCAs framers and supporters knew there would forever be claims, often advanced by organized and well-financed interests, that they should be put to immediate use for local economic development and other purposes. Valuable benefits to the Nation as a whole, to subsistence users, and to future generations would fare poorly in an ad hoc balancing." Carter is 97 years old.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y ago
- literallyWTF 4y ago
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoI care! I care about this kind of stuff. I would like DDG to be better...
- mistrial9 4y agoIn rural Northern California and across the continental USA there are huge, huge areas, including populated places, without local medical services. "medically underserved" is the google keyword. Read two or three public health research papers and you will quickly find that there are already roads, but no doctors, mainly due to the economics of American health care.
- thghtihadanacct 4y agoMy parents had a penchant for living remote. Its all fun and games until you need a humvee to crash thru snow to take you to the hospital.
- mistrial9 4y agook well my ex-neighbor pulled her own tooth while isolated on a property down a dirt road. I am not new to this. This is a political cover to build infrastructure. I suggest you read Jimmy Carter's letter and we can all discuss it together.
- paulpauper 4y agoCarter and Kissinger both got the live forever genes
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt's the adrenochrome /s
- weeksie 4y agoAtrocious to me that anybody would want to block that road. A mine? Sure. Logging? Yup. Oil exploration? Yeah. A gravel road to an airport in Alaska? Come on. I haven't lived in Rural Alaska in 20 years but I was born and raised in a fishing village. People in the lower 48 have no understanding of the vastness of Alaska and how small a concession this really is. These specious environmental lawsuits are why no infrastructure has been built in this country in 40 years. We need to protect the wilds but a regulatory structure that allows vetos of a gravel road to the airport? What the hell.
- Victerius 4y ago
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThis "we don't negotiate with terrorists" type thinking is going to come back to bite you the nanosecond the tables are turned and it's some interest you care about that's seeking some tiny compromise.
- lovich 4y agoI think the point is that it’s not a tiny compromise in aggregate. Pointing to the one instance here and treating the decision like it’s in a vacuum is not what the people against the road believe will happen, based on the points in the article about how this will lead to further development
- asdfk-12 4y agoYour view seems fundamentally misanthropic - instead of autochthonous population having access to a resource that you take for granted, you would rather kick them out into an expensive urban area where their life is disrupted? All for a perceived risk to a comparitively tiny corridor?
- askin4it 4y agoThis is about the holy trinity of living today: being correct, being on the right team, and getting your way all the time, every time. It's only a matter of time before it won't be enough to let them call the shots on everything. You know what's after that, you'll either like all this stuff or you'll be part of the reason why it isn't ushering in utopia. Misanthropic is 100% accurate.
- macinjosh 4y agoGas is $6 a gallon, poor families are going hungry, but ok… Human life should matter more than some self-hating environmentalists’ desire for the earth to be some perceived paradise devoid of humanity.
- Victerius 4y ago> Human life should matter more than This logic will lead to the complete destruction of all natural environments on the only planet in the solar system to host life, and then to our extinction. "They paved paradise and put up a parking lot."
- ironmagma 4y agoAll you have to do is go to LA or Orlando to see this principle in action. There’s nothing human about a tarmac.
- postingforonce 4y ago
- asoneth 4y agoBeyond the validity of the legal arguments, I wonder about the second-order impacts if this goes through. For one thing I'd imagine there's a significant amount of private land with negligible monetary value because it lacks transportation infrastructure and the legal rights to construct such infrastructure. If local communities can convince the state to build roads through national parks, refuges, and wilderness areas I'd imagine the private lands around those areas will hugely increase in value. I wonder if this will kick off a land rush and drive more development in these areas. The downside of course is that the ecological value of these lands would plummet, since many animals that roam or hunt require uninterrupted contiguous areas.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- soupbowl 4y agoIt is funny to see all the big city folk comment on this one.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoWhy?
- seanw444 4y agoIsn't it great that big city folk get to vote and decide on your location and livelihood, from the other side of the country? Totally makes sense.
- asdfk-12 4y ago'Adverse development' is the term they use for the King Cove community's road to access an airport for emergency medical services. A group of rural Americans need access to a critical resource. They aren't building an open-pit mine. 'Trustees for Alaska' seems to be another majority out-of-state funded greenie organization that prioritizes a twisted anti-human agenda where if they got their way, entire villages would be eliminated and all of the residents relocated to an urban center.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> entire villages would be eliminated Entire towns have been relocated for the greater good. Some examples are to build dams and reservoirs. Butler, Tennessee. American Falls, Idaho. Grand Coulee Dam forced the relocation of 3000 people. So many others, like these: https://www.uncharted101.com/the-submerged-towns-of-america/ https://www.uncharted101.com/the-submerged-towns-of-america/
- yellowapple 4y ago> Some examples are to build dams and reservoirs. Yeah, dams and reservoirs that obliterated not just those towns but any and all surrounding habitats - while also in many cases interfering with fish stocks/migration. "Greater good" indeed. Maybe we should be tearing down those dams before quibbling over a gravel road.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> but any and all surrounding habitats They also created new habitats.
- yellowapple 4y agoFor some reason I doubt the creation v. destruction works out in the favor of dams.
- trhway 4y agoInstead of fighting for the road to the airport they'd better fight for the electric VTOL - a way to get their air transport without violating the wilderness refuge. Alaskan low density makes it a great place for the new technology to get tested in real use and have its early problems worked out.
- notch656a 4y agoeVTOL aren't anywhere near to being certified for commercial flight, and anyone telling you they are is a charlatan trying to cash out on investment fraud. I know because I worked for a semi well known eVTOL entrepreneur who continually facilitated an enterprise engaged in lying to customers that they would get an eVTOL in short order when in fact the FARs didn't even provide a path to certification.
- trhway 4y ago>the FARs didn't even provide a path to certification and that is the fight those people should spend their effort/money at.
- narrator 4y agoWhat's up with all these old western Apparatchiks? You got Jimmy Carter at 97, his wife is 94. Henry Kissinger is 99. Do they all go to the same clinic?