8 ms·
Why we think there's a Multiverse, not just our Universe
- trocker 15y agohah, its like a variable in a function making theories about what the whole program is all about, and that there might be many other functions similar to it. :D take a look at this one too - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation
- powertower 15y agoI've always been put off by the many-worlds interpretation. They take something that's perfectly explainable with a probability wave, and turn it into fantasy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave_packet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave_packet
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- TheBurningOr 15y agoFascinating article, but I'd still like to know more about that 8th figure on the inflation model. We are told that the y-axis represents energy, but what is the x-axis? It clearly isn't time because it's being measured in phi over something measured in GeV.
- fl3tch 15y agoThe attribution to Ned Wright takes you here: http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Narlikar/Narlikar3_2.html http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Narlikar/Narlikar3_2.html which has a lot more information. Phi is defined as the Higgs scalar field.
- anakanemison 15y agoThis kind of science has always been hard for me to integrate. Thinking as a Bayesian, these arguments seem to be meant to influence my "prior" over possible initial states or natures of the universe. I'm not accustomed to that. I'm used to science presenting me with evidence meant to influence my "posterior". I can handle that.
- xenophanes 15y agoAre you aware that's irrational? Your assumptions about priors contain plenty of mistakes (all ideas do, mine too) and you should find a way of thinking which better allows for correcting those mistakes.
- anakanemison 15y agoI think it's more unfortunate than irrational. I'd like to think I'm open to changing them--my priors started out (a couple of decades ago) pretty terrible. The process of how to do it well in response to arguments without experimental results is the challenging part.
- xenophanes 15y agoBayesianism is in the empiricist tradition where it's focussed on how to update ideas in response to evidence, but it doesn't actually provide guidance for how to deal with non-empirical ideas that can't be judged by evidence. This (empiricism) has driven philosophers to things like positivism (where they declare everything non-empirical to be worthless or even meaningless). It's a problematic tradition. The problems are made worse because it turns out that the large majority of ideas are assessed in a non-empirical way (not due to people being idiots; this is correct). Using evidence is the less common case (though it is quite important when relevant). In _The Fabric of Reality_ by David Deutsch, he gives an example of the theory that eating a kilogram of grass will cure the common cold. This, he points out, should not be empirically tested, and will not be. Rather it is rejected without evidence because it is a bad explanation. Only good explanations are worth testing. (This does not make us miss out on any truths. If it really was true, someone could figure out some explanation of how it works, and then we'd test it.) In his recent book, _The Beginning of Infinity_, Deutsch further explains that there's no point in testing any theory for which its details can easily be changed around in an ad hoc way, because you can never refute such things with evidence since they will just revise themselves endlessly. The only thing that can refute that sort of approach is philosophical criticism. Only ideas which survive some philosophical criticism and are therefore of higher quality are worthwhile to empirically test. What makes it hard to change a theory around, ad hoc, to avoid refutation, is if there is some actual connection between the content of the theory and the problem it's trying to solve, so most changes to it would make it no longer address the problem as well. Deutsch calls that quality "hard to vary" and says it is what makes explanations good. His books expand on this, and offer a version of Popperian epistemology with (relatively small) improvements. Popperian epistemology, focussed on criticism not justification (which is impossible), and which applies to all types of knowledge without difficulty rather than being narrowly focussed on empiricism, is the solution. One of the Popperian ideas is that because we are fallible and make lots of mistakes, and need to improve on them (by criticism), irrationality has to do with anything that hampers this process of correcting errors. So that's why I regard difficulty error-correcting priors as irrational. Deutsch even proposes that hampering the correction of mistakes is the most important criterion of immorality.
- xenophanes 15y agoIf you're interested in MWI you should read David Deutsch's books: http://beginningofinfinity.com/ http://beginningofinfinity.com/
- gjm11 15y agoI agree -- if you're interested in MWI then you should read Deutsch (in fact, you should read Deutsch anyway) -- but the OP isn't about MWI, it's about a different sort of multiverse, with lots of "pocket universes" even on a single Everett branch because of inflation. Many of the implications are pretty similar, though.
- xenophanes 15y agoI did read the original link but honestly don't really understand. Seemed to be some kind of argument there has to be a multiverse to account for the expansion of the universe. That seems like a weak argument to me because in my understanding we're not that sure about what's happening to the universe and cosmologists keep changing their minds. Regardless, I didn't quite follow what sort of multiverse they said it implied and how it differs from MWI. Going by your comment, I'm not sure there's as much difference as you may be suggesting. Deutsch's MWI is full of what we might (or might not) call "pocket universes", it's not focussed on just big universe sized branches. I saw the article talking about the wave function spreading out which I think is the same concept Deutsch talks about in BoI with fungible instances of particles spreading out (a multiversal object is a collection of instances).
- knodi 15y agoSometimes I think I was born too soon. To think the new knowledge we well discover with in the next 100, 200, 1000 years is really exciting. I wouldn't be surprised if in the next 20-50 years with all the genetic engineer going on one could live for ever. Of cause as long as you can afford it.
- kingkawn 15y agoAlways true. Yet you have you to embrace now for what it is, as it's what ya got.
- powertower 15y agoI envision a world where, due to technology and science, everyone stops aging after 25. A clock will be constantly visible on your forearm and time will be the only commodity in the world, in which you'll get paid and make payments in. After the age of 25, you'll get 1 to 75 years of "time" deposited in your account. The clock on your arm will decrement by default as time passes, and increase/decrease as you earn/spend. When your time expires (the clock reaches zero), you die. Most people will live day-to-day, only having 24 hours of time in any given moment. Others will have millions of years on their clocks.
- trafficlight 15y agoThis plot doesn't make any sense.
- powertower 15y agoTime is the ultimate currency. Gold is only backed by the agreement of its scarcity; otherwise, it has no value (outside its physical usefulness as a material). Fiat currency is only backed by the confidence of a nation; otherwise, it has no value. Time is a currency that's backed by your life. It is as real as it gets.
- borism 15y agoWhy would time be of any value if nobody is ageing after 25?
- acak 15y agoA great TED talk on the design of the Universe, if any one is wondering about the glass shaped picture (the 5th image) in the essay: http://www.ted.com/talks/george_smoot_on_the_design_of_the_universe.html http://www.ted.com/talks/george_smoot_on_the_design_of_the_u...
- jaequery 15y agoLet's get the facts straight. Believing in a multiverse is no different than believing in heaven/hell.
- borism 15y ago* for a similar enough definition of heaven, hell and multiverse. Have you read the article?
- Confusion 15y agoHe may very well have. There is not a shred of experimental evidence for the multiverse. In fact, experimental evidence is not even possible. That places it firmly in the pantheon of metaphysics. Now it could be an unescapable conclusion from an otherwise very successful theory with many experimental verifications, but unfortunately the article neglects to mention that there are many alternative interpretations and theories that can equally well explain 'how it all started' and still result in inflation and all associated theories. That the multiverse theory successfully appeals to the imagination is the main pillar of its succes. It's a shame he is being downvoted for succinctly stating a plain truth.
- lionhearted 15y agoPotentially a stupid question - How can the universe get "colder"? Does it just mean that the average energy-per-square-meter (or whatever unit) is less? If so, wouldn't that mean that saying "less dense" and "colder" mean basically the same thing at that scale? Maybe I'm asking something stupid and obvious, but I keep thinking that energy can't be destroyed, ergo, there's exactly as much energy (and thus heat?) as before. Or is heat energy density? But doesn't that make "less dense and colder" a redundant statement, since they'd be the same thing?
- count 15y agoLess dense implies colder, as the volume is not constant, but expanding. Temperature and density are different things though - one is how much energy something has, the other is how far away from other things it is. Related, but different. With respect to destroying energy - energy converted into matter is 'colder'. There's not the exact same amount of energy - it's not that it can't be destroyed, it must be conserved with matter (E=MC^2). Great example - kinetic energy is used in a particle accelerator to create new particles, and it takes a ton of energy to make even a tiny bit of mass, so the average temperature would go down as more mass is created (heat being the transfer of energy - once it's trapped in a particle, it's not transferred as freely). (Caveat - I'm not a cosmologist...)
- lionhearted 15y ago> (Caveat - I'm not a cosmologist...) That was really informative, thanks. Man, physics is cool.
- 30thElement 15y agoHow does converting energy into mass make it "colder"? If you have 1 protons worth of energy in a volume, and you have 1 nonmoving proton in another area with the same volume, isn't there the same amount of energy in both regions? Or is it "colder" because you can't have a region with energy and nothing else, it must be something like kinetic energy, which gives heat?
- 15y ago
- sendos 15y agoIsn't this like having a function that explains very well data that is within an observable range, and then stating with confidence that that function also applies to data in a range that is unobservable to you? Yes, that function may hold outside your observable space, but it may not. We can't simply state as fact the predictions that come from assuming that this function applies outside our observable space.
- redwood 15y agoSpot on, and even much of what is 'observable' here is not even close to understood. Inflation and dark energy/matter are both concepts that have been built to explain observation but which are themselves not yet explained at least not with much consensus.
- Confusion 15y agoAs the only criticism on this article has been downvoted strongly, I feel compelled to repeat my explanation of that criticism (that believing in the multiverse is like believing in heaven or hell) at a higher level, in the hopes that people will be somewhat more critical of what esteemed scientists are peddling as truth: There is not a shred of experimental evidence for the multiverse. In fact, experimental evidence is not even possible. That places it firmly in the pantheon of metaphysics. That there is a multiverse could be an unescapable conclusion from an otherwise very successful theory, with many experimental verifications, but that isn't the case. The article neglects to mention that there are many alternative interpretations and theories that can equally well explain 'how it all started' and still result in inflation and all associated 'best' theories for the experimental observations of the universe. This article is all unwarranted extrapolation (back to the beginning of time and before). The main pillar of the success of the multiverse theory is that it successfully appeals to the imagination. The main reason that it is being promoted is because the great physicists promoting the idea do not realize they are not as great philosophers as they are physicists.
- Umofomia 15y agoThe author responds to this point in one of the comments; I quote: this is -- and I make no pretensions otherwise -- theoretical physics. It's not airy-fairy pie-in-the-sky speculation, but it also isn't proven the way you would prove that a * b = b * a. You may want to read this recent guest essay (http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2011/10/guest_essay_you_are_a_scientis.php http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2011/10/guest_essay_...) that does a wonderful job of explaining, with some brilliant metaphors, what this sort of theory is (and isn't).
- gizmo 15y agoAssertions that take the form "X is like religion" are not enlightening. When it is prefaced with "get the facts straight" then of course it's going to get downvoted. There is nothing being "peddled" here, there is no hidden agenda by "esteemed scientists". We have experimentally demonstrated that the universe is a really, really weird place. Time and space can bend. Whoah. But hey, we proved that beyond a shadow of a doubt. Then there's quantum mechanics. Wave functions! Entanglement! Turns out the universe really works that way. Then the universe starts looking really non-deterministic. Then we figured out that the simplest interpretation of QM implies Many Worlds, that the universe splits and splits and splits into a bazillion near-copies. The quantum events just look non-deterministic from our perspective. Do we know everything? Hell no. But we know that QM is true and that it uses some form of Many Worlds. We know that the world is deterministic. We don't know for sure how the universe came into being (but we are sure the universe is expanding). We don't know if there really is such a thing as the multiverse, but as we figure out more about the big bang, about background radiation, about black holes and dark matter and the shape of our universe there's a good chance we'll figure it all out eventually. Physics is treading on the domain of philosophy because we're getting better at physics. Philosophers debated since the dawn of time about free will and didn't get anywhere. Now we know that non-reductionist or dualistic world views make little sense. Philosophers debated for ages about morality. Now neuroscience is starting to deliver concrete answers. Philosophers debated for ages about religion and heaven/hell. And elementary Bayesian math shows the questions are just nonsensical. Philosophy is about reasoning about topics we don't really understand. As our understanding of physics, math, neuroscience and biology grows philosophy has to make way.
- rms 15y agoI cannot recommend the writings of Max Tegmark on the multiverse enough. Among people doing science at the heights of their fields, he is perhaps a uniquely talented popular writer. He even keeps it readable on his scientific papers, which read mostly just like his popular papers except shorter and with more math. http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/0905/0905.1283v1.pdf http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/0905/0905.1283v1.pdf is his overview of the levels of multiverses. If that properly blows your mind, see Bostrom's Infinite Ethics. http://www.nickbostrom.com/ethics/infinite.pdf http://www.nickbostrom.com/ethics/infinite.pdf