3 ms·
There's very little in a baby's head to hang those memories on. Not only can we not remember birth, but I'd bet that the baby doesn't remember it after five min
by pessimizer 4y ago
There's very little in a baby's head to hang those memories on. Not only can we not remember birth, but I'd bet that the baby doesn't remember it after five minutes or so (after the fear that it might happen again dies down.)
The only reason I can recall anything is because the words that I use to try to recall it ("what did I do yesterday morning?") take me down a chain of associations that hopefully will spit me out yesterday morning sometime, and that thing I remembered (maybe that I dropped one of my shoes when I was putting them on, or that one of my teeth hurt when I brushed it) can be a conduit to remember the rest of my morning.
The memory experiment just seems like spaced repetition to me [edit:which you can use to teach a cockroach, or a worm.] They show a baby a unique object with a particular use. The next time they show the baby that unique object, they either recall the particular use, or the experimenter demonstrates it again. As these periods grow longer and longer, the memories grow longer. The intuitive reason it would be less effective earlier in life than later is because babies can't see properly, or understand the positions of things in space, so they don't care when a mobile or a train moves; they don't recognize it as interesting.
Note: I can never remember what I did yesterday morning, because with the way I process the world, there's usually nothing in the sentence "What did you do yesterday morning?" that would associate with a particular day; every morning is yesterday morning. If I'm celebrating having done something significant "yesterday," however, I can start with that thing and work backwards to how I prepared for that thing. Some people are journalers/diarists, or heavily scheduled, and knowing what they have to do today, or maybe the last thing they wrote in their journal, would bring up almost immediately the memories that I have a huge difficulty recalling.
- codefreeordie 4y agoWe have done some interesting studies on infant memories. At first, you are correct that they basically can't remember anything. Even then, though. At a very early age, they will recognize their mother. This comes well before "object permanence," which happens at about 8 months. (Object Permanence is the ability to remember a thing even after you can't see it anymore, and to recognize it as the same, rather than a new one, when it returns. It is the ability to mentally follow an object when it "goes away" and to understand that it still exists)
- pessimizer 4y ago> At a very early age, they will recognize their mother. If there's any stimulus that gets worked over and over, it's your mother's face. Surely in a traditional mother-child relationship you use your mother's face to learn how faces work, probably even your own face. I'm not sure what you're trying to explain to me. I'm aware of object permanence.
- RobotCaleb 4y agoMaybe they were trying to explain object permanence to you? How do they know you know it already?
- WalterBright 4y agoMy memories are not connected to the calendar. Things I remember are free floating in time, except if they are in a particular place I remember when I was in that place, but that isn't part of my memory of the place. I've lived in the same house for 20 years now, and don't have anchors to connect memories to dates because of that. I have memories that could be 5 years old or 15, I couldn't say.
- anyfoo 4y agoSame. I also do this thing, where when I read about something that was some time ago with a specific year, I try to see it in the context of what I was doing back then, and what situation I was in. For example "ah, this was my last year of university, so I was living in that apartment, meeting so and so...". Again all those things are "free floating" with no feeling of calendar in my mind, but factually knowing what I was doing during some time frame and using other specific "anchor dates" of important events in my life and the world, it's fun to read about something old and reconstructing it in the context of my life back then. It does not work very well the other way around. There are a lot of memories similar to: "Oh, I remember that party... wonder when that was. I definitely was in university then, but that's not narrowing it down." (Especially because "pre-PhD" university studying lasted much longer in Germany back then than it is nowadays.) If I really wanted to know the exact year, it would be detective work.
- WalterBright 4y agoI've kept all my emails going back over 20 years now, that helps a lot. I've also been experimenting with keeping a journal, I'm curious how that will work for my future self. My dad kept a journal of his WW2 experience. He told me some years ago that he read it, and was shocked that it didn't jibe with his recollections. Sometimes I wonder how people who write autobiographies can possibly remember things in such detail.