3 ms·
As an XPS 13 and MacBook Air (M1) user. I would say the following taking aside the operating system factors (Linux/Windows vs. macOS): - The XPS 13 is better a
by wslh 4y ago
As an XPS 13 and MacBook Air (M1) user. I would say the following taking aside the operating system factors (Linux/Windows vs. macOS):
- The XPS 13 is better and more expensive except because of the battery and performance against the M2?. In the M1 "it is the battery stupid". Nothing compares to the M1 in the battery side.
- The article doesn't talk about the cooling factor, in the older XPSs it has a fan and again the MacBook Air doesn't have one. The XPS 2-1 doesn't have a fan.
- The XPS with a Thunderbolt dock like the TB16 is basically a desktop, with n external monitors while the MacBook Air only supports one.
- Many more things to detail in favor of the XPS 13 (touchscreen, resolution, 32gb of RAM) but for a nomad the MacBook beats it.
- As a last note I should add that the last Ubuntu 22 Wayland freezes when you connect a second external monitor to the XPS: https://askubuntu.com/questions/1407630/os-freezing-with-dual-monitors-on-ubuntu-22-04-lts https://askubuntu.com/questions/1407630/os-freezing-with-dua...
- oneplane 4y agoSome aspects are multi-dimensional. More RAM can be good, but faster or unified RAM can also be good. Neither model has both. Same goes for the CPU which isn't really comparable by spec but perhaps more by productivity. At that point we get in to the 'well what are you intending to do with the device' territory and we end up with nomadic use vs. desktop use etc. I do think that the whole power management (be it cooling fans or runtime on battery) as a complete picture can be compared (pretty much the way you described), but it gets murky again if we try to compare operating systems since they all seem to do it differently. When Linux on the M1 turned out to be very fast, some people thought the systems were artificially limited for no reason and linux would then 'unlock' that free speed, but it turned out to simply be bad power management and run at high performance all the time. That can feel great (or, responsive) but at the same time reduce the on-battery time so much that it becomes pointless. It's tough to make proper comparisons, even when Apple was all-Intel it wasn't easy as even having 'similar SKUs' in terms of silicon doesn't really tell a useful story for the actual user experience.
- mrtksn 4y agoHow is the Windows situation these days? On my Macbook, my uptime is from OS update that needs a restart to OS update that needs to restart, which is usually every few months. I value the always on and ready to go quality on laptop, do you have than on XPS13 with Windows? Is the screen resolution handled properly now on XPS13? Is everything the right size but crisper on high dpi displays?
- wslh 4y agoWindows works fine, as Windows. Windows has a lot of problems that starts with the product definition. I think the main product manager should be fired... but Windows with WSL is great if you plan to use Linux instead of another virtualization software.
- scarface74 4y ago> The XPS 13 is better and more expensive except because of the battery and performance against the M2?. In the M1 "it is the battery stupid". Nothing compares to the M1 in the battery side It’s better even though it’s more expensive, worse battery life and worse performance or did I parse your sentence incorrectly.
- wslh 4y agoYou parse the sentence correctly. There are many more factors that are in favor of the XPS (weight, memory, touch screen, thunderbolt dock extensibility, sd card, external monitors). Performance seems similar in the latest models, eGPU (not supported in Mac). But battery life (not carrying a power adaptor) is a peace of mind in a long day. Even for more than one day plugging the M1.