3 ms·
I think the TFA's point is that whatever the merits of budgeting itself, it will not bring about the goals it is frequently associated with. The author explicit
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
I think the TFA's point is that whatever the merits of budgeting itself, it will not bring about the goals it is frequently associated with. The author explicitly compares it with dieting, which may have its own virtue, and may even temporarily result in goal attainment, but has a long term record of failing to bring about the desired changes.
Also, the budgeting referred to in the article may be similar to handling questions like "should i go buy a Porsche with my retirement fund", but is absolutely not the same.
- manmal 4y agoRe dieting doesn’t work - temporary calorie restriction is often beneficial. It really depends on how it is done, eg IF, water fasting, and fasting-mimicking diet have been documented to yield interesting results. I’m not a fan of such blanket claims, they are not conducive to learning.
- Apocryphon 4y agoIt doesn't work in that often dieting without long-term changes just lead to weight being gained back in short order.
- manmal 4y agoI tend to agree when it's phrased like that.