10 ms·
From the article: "The concept stems from the theory of 'parental alienation syndrome' coined in the 1980s by US child psychiatrist Richard Gardner. The 'syndro
by rayiner 4y ago
From the article: "The concept stems from the theory of 'parental alienation syndrome' coined in the 1980s by US child psychiatrist Richard Gardner. The 'syndrome' went on to be largely rejected."
Psychology is not a science and we need to stop treating it like one. So much harm has been done by people giving credibility to faddish psychological theories. For example: https://psmag.com/social-justice/dangerous-idea-mental-health-93325 https://psmag.com/social-justice/dangerous-idea-mental-healt...; https://lithub.com/moral-panic-and-the-myth-of-recovered-memory https://lithub.com/moral-panic-and-the-myth-of-recovered-mem....
It's not just "a few bad apples," either. These things keep happening because the field isn't rigorous, and can't feasibly be made rigorous.
- carapace 4y ago
- sanderjd 4y agoOr maybe because its proponents make vague allusions to it from which is impossible for people to tell what they're talking about? I have no clue what you're talking about in this comment, nor any way to research it.
- orzig 4y agoAgreed, I’m curious enough to spend 10 minutes reading a link but not go on a wild goose chase.
- ceejayoz 4y agoMaybe no one is using it because it’s proponents forget to say what is is?
- canjobear 4y agoWhat are you referring to?
- carapace 4y agoNeurolinguistic Programming.
- canjobear 4y agoWhat resources could you provide on this for a skeptical cognitive scientist? What convinced you that it is rigorous?
- carapace 4y agoI see from your homepage that this may not be an idle request. Cheers! Let me reply to your questions in reverse order. > What convinced you that it is rigorous? I originally stumbled across some books on (the other) NLP and they just made sense, and the "algorithms" they described worked. I had some emotional issues and used the techniques to overcome them to some degree. I also carried out informal experiments, mostly on myself but occasionally with friends, to double check that I wasn't fooling myself. I suffered from pretty severe depression that interfered with living a normal life (I was homeless for a few years after high school) Eventually, I managed to go see one of the co-founders of NLP, Richard Bandler, and he cured my depression in a single ten-minute intervention. (I know how that sounds, but it's true. I've written about it once or twice before in comments here on HN if you want more details, or just ask.) So that pretty much clinched it for me. After my depression was cured I went on to have a fairly successful career as a programmer, and I am more-or-less a functioning adult thanks to Bandler. But I also lost interest in NLP personally (I mean, I still use what I've learned, but I don't feel called to be a therapist or anything like that.) I mention it from time to time because what kind of a monster would I be if I didn't? But I often get flak for it. (One fellow on here has called me a liar, fool, and scammer for talking about getting cured of depression.) When I say that the material "made sense" I don't mean merely that it sounded plausible, I mean that it was similar to electronics or mathematics: there are formal patterns in the structure of subjective experience, and we can learn to notice and deliberately manipulate those patterns in repeatable codified algorithms. (E.g. the "Five-Minute Phobia Cure" pattern, which eliminates phobic responses quickly and durably (the phobia never comes back.)) The original work grew out of linguistic analysis of particularly effective therapists (Satir, Perls, Erikson), they were literally transcribing therapy sessions and started applying ideas from Chomsky's Transformational Grammar. > What resources could you provide on this for a skeptical cognitive scientist? First of all, I'm sorry to say that most of the stuff on the Internet about (the other) NLP seems to be fluffy and nonscientific (to put it politely). If I'm being frank, I don't think most people practicing NLP understand it very well from a scientific viewpoint. I would recommend going to the source. Find and read "The Structure of Magic" (both volumes but especially the first, which explores linguistic patterns, the second volume then generalizes to the sensory channels.) You're probably going to be interested in what they call the "Meta Model" which is a set of questions designed to elicit elided information in a therapeutic setting. Beyond that I don't really have any recommendations. It really depends on what you want to do. You might enjoy "Trance-FORMATIONS" which is IMO one of the best books on hypnosis ever written, it's all about how language affects and guides the mind. I suppose you could also go take a class or course?
- howmayiannoyyou 4y agoThere are clinical means for evaluating a parent for manipulation & personality disorders, but they are time consuming and therefore expensive; and the expense does not end with the evaluation, the deposition and testimony that inevitably follows is prohibitively expensive; and you can double the cost if your former spouse retains their expert(s). To the extent there is a strategy for legitimately addressing this, its patiently documenting over an extended period time. Logging things like significant decline in social life, significant negative change in grades, significant comments from teachers, significant negative changes in behavior. While documenting this you have to be squeaky clean, refraining from disparaging the other parent and engaging in your behaviors that may muddy the waters. More often than not, one or several of your kids will show signs something isn't right to an extent that a 3rd party (Guardian, the Court, etc) or even your former spouse can't deny it. At that point, for many people, the system gives way to change. For some people justice for the child is never done and the family and society often pays a terrible price in those cases. Can't recommend this book enough if this topic hits close to home for anyone: https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Boy-Crisis-Audiobook https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Boy-Crisis-Audiobook
- rayiner 4y ago> There are clinical means for evaluating a parent for manipulation & personality disorders The fact that its clinical doesn't make it rigorous. Psychological disorders in general are not even defined in a rigorous way, and even the expensive diagnostic methods are qualitative and not rigorous.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 4y agoThe silly part of this is referring to it as a "syndrome" like it's a disease. It's simply a thing that you can choose to do to a child, and easy to understand without medicalizing it.