5 ms·
How a Saxophonist Tricked the KGB by Encrypting Secrets in Music
- jeroenhd 4y agoIt's not really encryption, it's just stenography. Pretty smart stenography for the time, but a code cracker who can read sheet music would make out patterns in not too much time. I'm amused by this quote: “When we arrived, we were immediately pulled aside, and they went through everything in our luggage, to the point of unwrapping Tampax. It was crazy,” Clearly, it wasn't crazy enough, as the Soviets were completely right in suspecting the musicians to be spies. They just oversaw a novel way of smuggling data out of the country, kind of how concatenation of JPG+RAR files was used to smuggle information past American checkpoints during the war on terror.
- pvg 4y agothe Soviets were completely right in suspecting the musicians to be spies They weren't right because the musicians weren't spies.
- atoav 4y agoThis one was. And they suspected everyone who traveled for a living.
- pvg 4y agoWhat's the evidence they were a spy? Helping people emigrate out of the USSR was not spying. 'They suspected everyone for a living' i.e. almost everyone they suspected was not a spy.
- gtsop 4y agoI think your comment is very out of context. For one, it's not even debatable that US had a big network of spies going in and out of the ussr. So, even if those specific musicians weren't spies, there were tons of spies nevertheless, thus the soviets had every motive to search thoroughly. Second, the chances of these musicians not being spies is extremely low, we're talking of an anti-ussr operation during a period when us-ussr tensions were high. A simple civilian doesn't "just travel to an opressesed country to exchange intel against the state using steganography techniques". I'm not saying there are 0 chances they are plain civilians, I'm just saying the chances are very low
- pvg 4y agoSecond, the chances of these musicians not being spies is extremely low, we're talking of an anti-ussr operation So there is no evidence. It's as absurd to call these people spies as it is to call Soviet dissidents and refuseniks of the time spies or western agents or mentally ill - that was the framing of the regime. It's absurd to take it up 40 years later. These were people who wanted to leave and other people who wanted to help them, not an 'anti-soviet operation'. A central premise of a great deal of late-Soviet resistance was essentially scrupulous adherence to Soviet law and international commitments the Soviets themselves made but did not, in practice, adhere to at all.
- MockObject 4y ago> These were people who wanted to leave and other people who wanted to help them, not an 'anti-soviet operation' Wasn't it both? It was certainly against Soviet policy and interests. What else could anti-Soviet even mean?
- pvg 4y agoBecause they called everything they didn't like 'anti-Soviet'. 'What does Soviet (or Socialist or whatever) actually mean?' was precisely the question this kind dissident activity was intended to raise. There was nothing 'inherently' anti-Soviet in simply wanting to live somewhere else or not suffer anti-semitic discrimination. The Soviet constitution ostensibly guaranteed all sorts of freedoms, etc. This gives you the flavour of it, in Czechoslovakia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charter_77 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charter_77 Describing this stuff in the language and framing of a totalitarian regime (or Cold War Bond movies where everyone is a spy) is bonkers.
- MockObject 4y agoIt's not bonkers at all. Presumably the Kremlin didn't want the brain drain, and labor drain, of these folks leaving. Surely you can agree that it was in the Soviet state interest to retain its slaves for exploitation?
- fatnoah 4y agoMy grandfather worked for a company that built industrial sized knitting machines, and his job was to ensure they were installed correctly and to help get them up and running. One frequent destination was Czechoslovakia, where he had a "handler" who had to be with him at all times when he wasn't in the hotel. She eventually became friends of the family and corresponded regularly with the family well into the late '90's.
- Anthony-G 4y agoI’m surprised they didn’t rotate the handlers to prevent this very scenario from occurring. If I was running a totalitarian state, I wouldn’t want my “watchers” becoming too familiar with their targets.
- aranchelk 4y agoSteganography, not stenography.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agohttps://www.thedailystar.net/india/news/3-photojournalists-jammu-kashmir-win-pulitzer-prize-1899742 https://www.thedailystar.net/india/news/3-photojournalists-j... "So the AP photographers went to the Srinagar airport and sought out strangers willing to carry memory cards and flash drives to New Delhi and call AP after landing in the Indian capital." this is more common and more recent than any cold war thing
- thriftwy 4y agoI wonder why they didn't use Dropbox.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agothere was no internet for 5-8 odd months for a around 8 million people. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/india-restores-4g-mobile-internet-kashmir-after-18-month-ban-n1256930 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/india-restores-4g-mobile-... A blanket internet ban, the longest in a democracy, which rights activists dubbed a "digital apartheid," came into effect in 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/05/the-personal-and-economic-cost-of-kashmirs-internet-ban https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/05/the-personal-a...
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoHah, I used that, JPG+JPG to smuggle erotica out of a cyber cafe when I was a teenager.
- Ntrails 4y agoI'm not sure I understand the JPG+RAR notation. I assume they didn't just rename file extensions or whatever? (sorry, google very unhelpful here unsurprisingly)
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoIt's relatively easy, the JPG format specifies the length of the file, so you can append anything at the end of the file and it will get ignored. I appended an erotica JPG at the end of an innocent looking one. They probably appended a RAR.
- erie 4y ago' suspecting the musicians to be spies' add to it journalists, preachersetc, and everyone is suspect now. Few years ago I was stopped for 2 hours at a Russian airport for a sport event, it was a KAFKAESQUE Nightmare, but it seems that they have some justifications.
- l33t2328 4y ago> JPG+RAR files was used to smuggle information past American checkpoints Have any more information about this? I couldn’t find anything on google.
- jeroenhd 4y agoGoogle is notoriously bad at finding older news articles and its competitors don't do nuch better. If memory services, the technique used relies on one file format putting its offsets and metadata in the header (like JPEG does) and another putting everything in the footer (looking into this, ZIP makes more sense). Concatenate the two files and you've got a file that's both a valid JPEG with some garbage at the end and a valid ZIP with some garbage before the first header. The JPEG parser would start at the front and seek until the length specified in the header has been processed, the ZIP parser would start at the central directory at the end and work its way backwards through offsets to find the first header. In Windows this could be as simple as `copy /b picture.jpg /b data.zip secret.jpg`. Rename secret.jpg to secret.zip and you've got a working ZIP file you can add files to as you please, rename back to secret.jpg and you've got an inconspicuous JPEG of about 3GB sitting on your desktop. Perhaps this simple methodology was just an urban legend, it certainly made seemed like an impressive trick when I was in high school. Articles online regarding this topic mention steganography but describe more advanced methods (i.e. encoding data in the least significant bit in pixels of a frame, encoding data in the cosine table of a JPEG, etc.). From what I can tell, this all seems to be based on a single security researcher explaining the concept of steganographry to a single news source followed by simplification and loads of copy/pasting.
- Anthony-G 4y agoOT: > Google is notoriously bad at finding older news articles and its competitors don't do nuch better. It’s not just Google. I’ve found the same to be true for Duck Duck Go and Bing. :(
- Anthony-G 4y agoIndeed. It would be more correct for Wired to say “encoding” instead of encrypting as Merryl Goldberg developed a system for encoding letters of the alphabet as musical notes. It was an ingenious technque but it wasn’t a cipher.
- JetAlone 4y agoMy takeaway from this is, when literally any configuration of matter can be used to encode potentially dangerous information, there is no amount of paranoia sufficient to completely prevent that information from being transmitted. The sword of Damocles can never, ever be taken down.
- mtrycz2 4y ago
- yellowapple 4y agoI got the precise opposite impression: that censorship is a losing battle, and those who engage in it are doomed to fail.
- danuker 4y ago> there is no amount of paranoia sufficient to completely prevent that information from being transmitted Given enough government paranoia, costs to transmit (especially broadcast) information go significantly up.
- JetAlone 4y agoI appreciate this consideration, you're right, particularly in the case of broadcasting. My thought is that in general, a network of committed enough transmitters can potentially use their communication ability to eventually bring about an unexpected means of broadcasting which is cheaper than the paranoia it would cost to prevent their transmissions. I imagine something like the ending of "They Live", where a small network struggles to affect the state of broadcasting. They bring a deceitful broadcast down in that story so it's not 100% the same. Either way, just when you think you've found a way to dodge the sword of Damocles forever, you find a new one, somehow, suspended above your new super ultra safe throne.
- orangepurple 4y agohttps://tidbits.com/2020/08/17/the-case-of-the-top-secret-ipod/ https://tidbits.com/2020/08/17/the-case-of-the-top-secret-ip... The Case of the Top Secret iPod It was a gray day in late 2005. I was sitting at my desk, writing code for the next year’s iPod. Without knocking, the director of iPod Software—my boss’s boss—abruptly entered and closed the door behind him. He cut to the chase. “I have a special assignment for you. Your boss doesn’t know about it. You’ll help two engineers from the US Department of Energy build a special iPod. Report only to me.” Discussion (2020): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24212520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24212520
- thriftwy 4y ago> Only four people at Apple knew about this secret project. Me, the director of iPod Software, the vice president of the iPod Division, and the senior vice president of Hardware I wonder what Steve Jobs would have thought if he got to know.
- fatnoah 4y agoApple is no stranger to secret projects. A few years ago, when I worked for a large (> $25 billion in revenue) software company, we were approached by Apple to be part of a beta program for a new API feature. Their requirement was that no more than 4 people in our entire company could know about it, which made it really awkward for the lone Engineer in the loop since even his manager didn't know what he was doing.
- mccorrinall 4y agoThis is probably why jazz sounds like jazz.
- egypturnash 4y agoAll Jazz is encoding secret messages, you are simply not hip enough to decode them.
- xcambar 4y agoJoke aside, my jazz musicians friends introduced me to the world of Jazz standards and how much of Jazz is about stretching these standards and hiding them in new pieces. As much respect as I have for Jazz and jazz enthusiasts and Jazz practitioners, it really is a lot about jargon and entre-soi and self-reference. Or so I've been told.
- ghostpepper 4y agoA good way to "understand" jazz for a newcomer IMHO is to listen to some non-jazz versions of those standards. A good example is the song Autumn Leaves. Listen to Frank Sinatra's stripped-down, straightforward version, and then listen to a jazz version (I recommend Bill Evans'). You'll hear bits and pieces of the original melody, interrupted by minutes of improvisation and embellishment, but it's still the same song underneath.
- dale_glass 4y agoCool, but I don't quite get what was the point of it from that article. If the information was for herself, why write it down? Why not memorize it instead? They had 4 people, and the information was names and addresses. Those shouldn't be that difficult to remember. And if you're being followed around, you're not hiding much by doing this -- the authorities can see where you're going and who you're talking to. A list on paper introduces extra risk, as if they figure it out you can no longer claim that you bumped into somebody by accident.
- Etheryte 4y agoThis greatly downplays both the amount information and the complexity involved. Their first destination was Moscow, Russia, where Cyrillic is used. Their second destination Georgia, where a different script is used [0], and then Armenia, where a third one is used [1]. At the time, none of those had a "standard" way to write them in English, so even if you slightly misremember a name or an address, you will have a very hard time figuring out where you actually wanted to go. On top of that, they also wanted to smuggle information out: names of people who wanted to leave the USSR, updates from dissidents, etc. Add to all of this that you would be under constant stress and surveillance and you wouldn't want to rely on your memory for all of this information. In the USSR, if you had a tail it was often very obvious you had a tail — it was a part of the intimidation tactics to put people under pressure and make them make mistakes. Of course, a paper trail of any kind is risky, but past a certain point you simply can't juggle everything in your head. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgian_scripts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgian_scripts [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_alphabet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_alphabet
- dale_glass 4y agoOkay, that explains things. Thanks!
- redbar0n 4y agosecurity by obscurity, that worked.
- 0daystock 4y agoWhy didn't they just memorize the information? Retaining even a few dozen names and addresses can be mastered with a few weeks' training.