3 ms·
The Repressive, Authoritarian Soul of “Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends”
- eli_gottlieb 4y agoYes we know that "Thomas the Tank Engine" is bourgeois. That's kinda what a lot of people like about it.
- krallja 4y ago(2017)
- andai 4y agoDiscussed at the time (266 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15361197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15361197
- gautamdivgi 4y agoMaybe we are wasting too many brain cycles on this. My kids watched this (and Peppa pig) when they were in the 3-4 yr range. They quickly tire of the monotony of where the end result is being "useful" or "well-behaved & happy" all the time and move off to other things. So, yeah, they're kind of repressive & authoritarian. OTOH, I don't think the kids are affected as much unless the parents emulate Sir Topham Hat.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoNow Peppa Pig, _that's_ a dystopia. Just from the episode where they, a bunch of talking animals, go to the zoo, to uh... look at the animals. Feels like something from 19th century imperialist Europe.
- nix23 4y ago>Feels like something from 19th century imperialist Europe. Naa, now we have Facebook, Twitter etc. todo that.
- joemazerino 4y agoIn what world is this journalism and not a high school essay for theory practice?
- ham-sandwich 4y ago
- 0des 4y agoGumshoes don't exist. Conspiracy-me thinks the price of ink dropped and we're getting mcribbed about it.
- mateo1 4y agoNobody holds the new yorker at a high esteem but a critical analysis of thomas the tank engine as a "big gov" propaganda tool is just laughable.
- throwaheyy 4y agoThe author seems to focus on one story out of dozens (with the important moral of ‘don’t be a snowflake, it might backfire’) and calls it a “death sentence”. They ignore that in the very next story Henry is given the chance to redeem himself by coming out of the tunnel and being useful again. This happens when Gordon, making fun of Henry, causes himself to break down and is forced to accept help from Henry to pull his train.
- 7thaccount 4y agoIt's still incredibly creepy and disturbing for a kids show. I couldn't believe the episode ended that way. Even my ultra conservative parents found it to be disturbing.
- throwaway675309 4y agoKids aren't gonna spiral into some navel gazing introspective ivory tower circle jerk, the vast majority are just going to take the show at face value.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoUltimately this is because steam engines are charismatic in a way diesel and electric trains are not (perhaps until you get to something as impressive as the Shinkansen or TGV). So the apparent technological "progress" is emotionally unsatisfying, and we wish to return to the older thing -- to "regress".