3 ms·
The issue with these types of studies though is that there's no way to really parse out correlation vs causation, either between these two variables or with soc
by zamiaf 4y ago
The issue with these types of studies though is that there's no way to really parse out correlation vs causation, either between these two variables or with social factors at large. Especially in this case there was no molecular work done to validate the hits or establish causal pleiotropic effects. The authors are incentivized to tell a story but as readers I think we can be a little more skeptical and evaluate the likelihood of those kinds of claims (there's positive selection on genes that both increase "intelligence" and alter eye shape) versus like, environmental and social factors induce a correlation between needing glasses and reading...
- yial 4y agoI agree with this… I don’t think other studies on myopia fit this same narrative. (However I may be wrong!) Example: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-65130-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-65130-w