4 ms·
It's important to remember as an "outsider" that termination may be legal, even if it's unethical. Because law is not always strongly aligned to ethical. The OP
by ggm 4y ago
It's important to remember as an "outsider" that termination may be legal, even if it's unethical. Because law is not always strongly aligned to ethical. The OP makes it clear they expect to be in litigation which typically ends in a settlement for non disclosure. So we may never know exactly which "AI" product or research this is.
Whistle-blower defences are fantastically hard to invoke. I believe usually they just become part of the logic of settlement.
Much of this story rings true: the structural indifference to risk of an AI ethic issue, and the structural adherence to "you disclosed outside the company wall" policy, overarching an ethical concern.
This is because loss of IPR and first mover advantage is a real world loss, whereas suspected ethics concerns are at best, second order risks. It would depend on the regulator (FTC?, equal opportunity commission?) And their ranges of penalty and consequence compared to share value. Managers are often KPI rewarded for risk to achieve profit, rarely for avoidannce of risk in ethics. We'd need cross-industry shifts to move the dial on this, ethics in e.g. banking and fintech has plagued the industry and continues to plague the industry, Enron and Barings brothers and Bernie Madoff not withstanding. It would be naive to think Google or any other FAANG is somehow immune to this kind of lapse of (ethical) concern, and remember its an argued breach, not a proven one at this point.
Much sympathies to the OP, I'd hate to be in this position, alignment of personal values to company values is very hard sometimes. They may well be "better off" outside the farm, although I suspect less well renumerated.
- babyshake 4y agoDoesn't California have specific whistleblower protection laws? Why is it so hard to invoke them?
- ggm 4y agoWhat percentage do you think are successful and what percentage are unsuccessful. I tend to think a very small minority are successful, because many Whistle-blower allegations are suspicion based not evidenced.
- babyshake 4y agoWhistleblower protection means it is illegal for employers to retaliate if they have believe you may be a whistleblower. It does not require you have an accurate safety concern.
- gundmc 4y ago"Fired for raising AI Ethical Concerns" sounds a lot worse than the details in the WashPo article - they insisted an internal chatbot was sentient despite refutation and evidence to the contrary, brought in a lawyer to "represent" the chatbot's rights and leaked internal details to the press.
- ggm 4y agoYea. I'm probably wrong, and he's dived off the deep end. His personal values fell out of alignment with the company, but if the termination is because he thinks its sentient, and not because of applied societal harms like I thought, much of what I said is irrelevant.